Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Utility Solar Project Grounding Question

User: cyriousn, Location: ME / CT

Asked on: Tuesday, November 26, 2024 at 9:25 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:40 am EST

Question: I'm reviewing a ground mounted utility scale solar project and I'm questioning my understanding how this project should be grounded.The project connects to a 23kv 4-wire network, goes through a 2MVA Yg-Yg transformer to a 2500A 600V switchboard.The project shows the ground and neutral bonded at the secondary of the transformer with both ground and neutral going to the switchboard. The switchboard does not have a bonding jumper installed between neutral and ground bus.The switchboard connects to multiple inverters and feeds some aux load.Does this sound correct? I can't get out of my head that we derive the neutral at the first means of disconnect which would be at the switchboard but this is a solar PV project and not a typical electrical service.

You've hit on a key point that often confuses people, and it's good you're questioning it. Here's a breakdown of the situation and why what you're describing is likely incorrect and potentially dangerous.

Understanding the Fundamentals Separately Derived System (SDS)

The secondary side of your Yg-Yg transformer IS a separately derived system. This means, for grounding and bonding purposes, it's treated as a brand-new electrical system, completely independent of the 23kV source.


Neutral Point Derivation and Grounding

In a separately derived system, the neutral must be bonded to ground at one and only one point. This is typically at the source of the SDS (i.e., the transformer secondary). This bond creates the reference point for the neutral and establishes the voltage potential to ground.

Why Only One Bonding Point?
Having multiple points where the neutral is bonded to ground creates parallel paths for neutral current to flow through the grounding system. This can lead to: Objectionable Current

Current flowing on the grounding system, potentially creating voltage drops and interfering with sensitive equipment.

Increased Risk of Shock

A fault condition can elevate the voltage potential of the grounding system, increasing the risk of electrical shock.


Arc Faults

Erratic current on the grounding system can increase the likelihood of arcing faults.

Safety Hazard

In the event of a ground fault, the multiple ground paths can reduce the effectiveness of the ground fault protection devices.


Importance of Grounding Electrode System (GES)

Your facility MUST have a robust grounding electrode system connected to the grounding bus. This system is your primary connection to earth and ensures the entire electrical system is at a stable and predictable voltage relative to the surrounding ground.

Analyzing Your Project Description


Based on your description, here's why I suspect there's an issue:1. Ground and Neutral Bond at Transformer

This part is correct. The secondary of the Yg-Yg transformer should have the neutral bonded to ground. This is where the separately derived system is established.2.

Ground and Neutral to Switchboard WITHOUT a Bonding Jumper



THIS IS LIKELY INCORRECT and UNSAFE.
Since the neutral and ground are already bonded at the transformer secondary, there should NOT be another neutral-to-ground bonding jumper at the switchboard. The switchboard should have a separate neutral bus and ground bus. The neutral conductor from the transformer secondary goes to the neutral bus in the switchboard. The equipment grounding conductor from the transformer secondary goes to the ground bus in the switchboard. The ground bus in the switchboard connects to the grounding electrode system.

Corrected Configuration (Proposed)


Transformer Secondary

Neutral bonded to ground
at the transformer.2.

Switchboard

Separate neutral and ground buses. Neutral from transformer secondary to neutral bus. Equipment grounding conductor from transformer secondary to ground bus.

NO
neutral-to-ground bonding jumper at the switchboard. Ground bus connected to the grounding electrode system (GES).3. Inverters and Auxiliary Loads

Neutral conductors connect to the neutral bus in the switchboard. Equipment grounding conductors connect to the ground bus in the switchboard.

Why the Confusion?


You mentioned your thought process about deriving the neutral at the first means of disconnect. This is the typical practice for a standard service entrance in a building fed directly from the utility. However, in your case, the secondary of the transformer is a separately derived system. The "service entrance" for that separately derived system is at the transformer secondary, not the switchboard.

Code References (U.S. - NEC)



NEC Article 250: Grounding and Bonding

This is the KEY article. Read it carefully, paying close attention to:


250.20(B)

Grounded Systems.

250.30: Grounding Separately Derived AC Systems.
This section will outline the specific requirements for grounding your transformer secondary. 250.24 (A)(5)

Grounding of supply side bonding jumper.*

NEC Article 690: Solar Photovoltaic (PV) Systems

While not directly related to this specific grounding question, you should be very familiar with this article for all aspects of your solar project.

Recommendations


Consult with a Qualified Electrical Engineer

This is crucial. Have a qualified electrical engineer review the design and ensure it complies with all applicable codes and standards.2.

Review Grounding and Bonding Studies

A proper grounding study should have been performed as part of the design process. Review this study to verify its conclusions and ensure they align with the actual installation.3.

Verify Equipment Listings and Instructions

Make sure all equipment (transformer, switchboard, inverters) is properly listed and that the installation follows the manufacturer's instructions.4.

Grounding Electrode System Inspection

Ensure that the GES is properly installed and tested to meet the required resistance to ground.

In summary, based on your description, the switchboard should NOT have a neutral-to-ground bond. The bond should only be at the transformer secondary to avoid creating multiple ground paths and potential safety hazards.
Make sure to get this reviewed by a qualified professional ASAP. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question