Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: NEC 110.26

User: alixenos, Location: Florida

Asked on: Tuesday, November 26, 2024 at 9:56 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:41 am EST

Question: Hi,In 110.26, the following clarification is provided." Minimum working clearances are not required if the equipment is not likely to require examination, adjustment, servicing, or maintenance while energized. However, access and working space are still required by the opening paragraph of 110.26".This seems contradictory to me. If the equipment does not require examining, adjusting, servicing, or maintaining, does it require an access and working space or not?Thanks.

You've hit on a common point of confusion with 110.26. The key is understanding the different types of spaces and the reasons behind them. While the minimum working clearances (defined by specific dimensions in tables like 110.26(A)(1)) might not be required, access and working space are always required. Here's a breakdown: Minimum Working Clearances (Table 110.26(A)(1))

These are the specific distances required in front of energized electrical equipment. They are based on voltage to ground and condition of the location (presence of grounded parts or walls opposite the equipment). These clearances are intended to provide safe space for electricians to perform live work (examination, adjustment, servicing, or maintenance).


Access and Working Space (Opening paragraph of 110.26)

This is a more general requirement and refers to the overall area needed to simply reach the equipment and work around it, even if the work doesn't require the equipment to be energized. This includes things like:

Adequate illumination (110.26(D)).
Headroom (110.26(E)). Width and depth to safely maneuver. A clear path to reach the equipment for initial installation or future replacement. Space to open doors and panels. Space to perform de-energized maintenance.

Let's clarify with an example:Imagine a completely sealed, maintenance-free junction box mounted on a wall. It has no moving parts, requires no adjustments, and is designed to never need servicing or examination while energized. Minimum Working Clearances

Based on 110.26's exception, because it's not likely to require work while energized, the specific clearances from Table 110.26(A)(1)
do not apply. You don't need 3 feet, 3.5 feet, or 4 feet of clearance in front of it.

Access and Working Space

However, you still need adequate space to: Install the junction box in the first place. Access the junction box to disconnect the wiring for replacement at the end of its service life. Provide safe headroom above the junction box. Provide adequate illumination to work on it. Keep the space in front of the junction box clear, so it can be accessed for de-energized repairs in the future.

In summary

The exception in 110.26 waives the
specific, measured clearances when live work isn't expected. It does not waive the general requirement for enough access and working space to safely install, replace, or perform de-energized maintenance on the equipment, or to meet the other conditions, such as proper illumination, headroom, etc.

Why the Contradiction Exists (and Why It's Important):


The NEC is focused on safety. Even if a piece of equipment is designed to be maintenance-free, things can go wrong. Components fail. Technology evolves, and equipment gets replaced. The access and working space requirements ensure that, even in these unexpected situations, electricians have a safe area to work on the equipment, even if it must be de-energized first. It also ensures the equipment can be properly installed in the first place.Think of it like this: the specific clearances are for
live work. The access and working space are for all* work, including installation, de-energized work, and future replacement. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question