Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: ground loop / lightning protection for a CNG bus maintenance facility?

User: SeniorElectricalEngineer, Location: VA

Asked on: Tuesday, November 26, 2024 at 12:04 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:41 am EST

Question: Greetings, we are designing a CNG bus maintenance facility where I am specifying a ground loop around the facility as per NFPA 780 7.3.7.1:"7.3.7.1 A ground ring electrode or ground loop conductorsupplemented by grounding electrodes as identified in 4.13.2through 4.13.7 shall be provided for structures containingflammable vapors, flammable gases, or liquids that can give offflammable vapors."However, one electrical designer on the design team is stating that the ground loop around the facility is not required. Here is what he is stating, which I think is incorrect:"No fueling in the building. The only flammable gases are inside a gas tank of a vehicle and therefore no grounding loop is required because a vehicle is not part of the building. This is an additional cost that is not required nor is needed. If there were flammable vapors, gases then it would require by code (1) loop for lightning and (1) loop for grounding".Any feedback from those who have designed such facilities would be appreciated.

You're right to question this designer's assertion. While he's technically correct that there isn't fueling inside the building in the traditional sense, his interpretation of NFPA 780 as it applies to a CNG bus maintenance facility is likely too narrow. Here's why: The Purpose of NFPA 780 7.3.
7.1

This section isn't solely about preventing ignition during fueling operations. It's about mitigating the risk of ignition from lightning strikes in structures where flammable materials are present. A lightning strike near a CNG bus inside the building could:


Induce Sparks

Create sparks via induction near the CNG tank or fueling components of the bus, even if the tank itself remains intact.

Damage CNG System

Damage the bus's CNG system, leading to a release of CNG and subsequent ignition.


Create a Voltage Gradient

A lightning strike creates a voltage gradient in the earth. If the facility's grounding isn't sufficient, this gradient could cause dangerous potential differences within the building, increasing the risk of arcing and ignition.

"Containing Flammable Vapors, Flammable Gases..." is Broad

The key phrase in NFPA 780 7.3.
7.1 is "structures containing flammable vapors, flammable gases, or liquids that can give off flammable vapors." A building that
routinely houses CNG buses contains flammable gas. While the CNG is inside the bus's tank, the potential for leakage and the frequency of that potential are what make this requirement applicable. Maintenance procedures often involve some degree of access to the CNG systems.

Likelihood of CNG Release

During maintenance, there's a higher likelihood of a small CNG release, even if unintended, than in a typical vehicle storage situation. Mechanics are working on the system, potentially disconnecting fittings, performing inspections, and so on.

NFPA 52 (Vehicular Gaseous Fuel Systems Code)

While NFPA 52 primarily addresses fueling stations and vehicle design, it underscores the hazards of CNG. It provides guidelines for safety equipment and practices, highlighting the need for robust safety measures in CNG environments.


Importance of a Comprehensive Grounding System

The ground loop, properly bonded to the building's steel structure and other grounding electrodes, helps to:

Equalize Potential

Minimize potential differences within the building during a lightning strike.


Dissipate Current

Provide a low-impedance path for lightning current to flow to ground.

Protect Equipment

Safeguard sensitive electronic equipment from surges induced by lightning.


Loop Count Interpretation

His interpretation of "(1) loop for lightning and (1) loop for grounding" is incorrect. NFPA 780 addresses lightning protection grounding. The NEC (National Electrical Code) governs the general grounding system. While there are interactions and bonding between the two, NFPA 780's ground loop isn't separate from the electrical grounding.

Here's what I recommend


Consult with a Lightning Protection Expert

Engage a qualified lightning protection consultant (someone certified by the Lightning Protection Institute, LPI) to evaluate the specific risks at your facility and provide recommendations. A lightning risk assessment will help determine the appropriate level of protection.2.

Review the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)

Discuss the code requirements with the local AHJ (fire marshal, building inspector). Their interpretation is what ultimately matters. Present a well-reasoned argument based on the potential hazards and the intent of NFPA 780.3.

Document Your Rationale

If, after consulting with experts and the AHJ, you decide not to install the ground loop, document your rationale thoroughly. Include the risk assessment, the AHJ's input, and any mitigating factors that justify the decision. This documentation is crucial for liability purposes.4.

Consider a Safety Analysis

Perform a formal safety analysis (e.g., a Hazard and Operability study - HAZOP) to identify potential hazards associated with CNG maintenance and determine the necessary safety measures. Grounding is a key aspect of a comprehensive safety plan.

In summary,
while there might be specific circumstances where a ground loop isn't strictly required, a CNG bus maintenance facility generally falls under the scope of NFPA 780 7.3.
7.1. The potential for CNG release during maintenance activities and the risk of ignition from lightning strikes justify a robust grounding system, including a ground loop. Don't rely solely on the interpretation of an electrical designer who may not be familiar with the specific requirements for CNG facilities. Get a second opinion from a lightning protection expert and the AHJ. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question