Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Metal Old Work Boxes

User: Jimmy7, Location: Boston, MA

Asked on: Tuesday, November 26, 2024 at 5:43 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:42 am EST

Question: We were planning to utilize existing metal old work boxes that are already cut into wood. I noticed that all of the boxes are secured by nails through the ears rather than screws. Will we have to remove the nails and use screws, or are nails compliant?

The NEC (National Electrical Code) doesn't explicitly prohibit the use of nails for securing old work boxes if the nails are already there and are providing adequate support. However, there are a few important considerations: Secureness

The primary requirement is that the box is securely and rigidly supported. If the nails are loose, bent, or otherwise compromised, they're not providing adequate support, and you
must replace them with screws.

Removal Difficulty

Removing the nails without damaging the box or surrounding drywall can be difficult. This is where the decision often lies. If the nails are solid, leaving them in place is generally acceptable if they provide sufficient support.

Best Practice

Screws are
always the preferred method for securing old work boxes. They offer superior holding power and are less likely to loosen over time. Therefore, if you can remove the nails relatively easily and replace them with screws, that's the best approach.

Inspection

An electrical inspector has the final say. If they deem the nail installation inadequate, they can require you to replace them with screws.

In summary


Evaluate the Existing Installation

Check how securely the boxes are held in place. Try wiggling them. If they move, you need to improve the support.2.

Easiest to Remove?
If the nails are very easy to remove without damaging the box or drywall, then remove and use screws.3. Can the Nails Remain?

If the nails are solid, secure, and the box does not move, you can likely leave them in place.4.

Be Prepared to Adapt

Be prepared to replace the nails with screws if the inspector requires it. Have the appropriate screws on hand.

Recommendations



Try to tighten the nails

If the nails are loose, gently tap them in further, but avoid damaging the box or surrounding wall.


Consider adding screws

If you can fit screws alongside the nails, this can provide extra security without removing the nails.

Consult with an electrician or inspector

If you're unsure, it's always best to consult with a qualified electrician or your local electrical inspector to get their opinion. They can assess the specific situation and provide guidance based on local codes and practices.

Therefore, while nails
might* be compliant if they provide adequate support, screws are the better and more reliable option. Carefully assess the existing installation, consider the ease of replacement, and be prepared to meet inspection requirements.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question