User: User Name, Location: USA
Asked on: Tuesday, November 26, 2024 at 8:19 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:42 am EST
Question: Hey guys, might be a long shot but thought I'd try. Just did a new install of a kohler 20rca generator. Everything all done, can run the generator in manual, can put the generator in auto, but it won't start or transfer if the power is shut off, it just sits there. It's like it knows the power is there, but when it's shut off, it still thinks the power is there.On the transfer switch there's some status indicators, and on the generator there's some status indicators showing where the power is coming from, both have never lit up. But the digital display on the generator works.I personally think the transfer control board is bad, but all the LED lights on the board are lit up. The dealer that sold it to us doesn't know, and doesn't think it's the control board because they've never had one go bad. Well someone's got to be the first right? He tried to say it was my wiring, but I followed the manual, and I have 2 other identical units for the same customer I did along side this project and they work fine.I'm just kind of rolling the dice and hoping someone here has had the same problem. I've combed through both the transfer switch and generator for loose connections or something unplugged, can't find anything. Kohler is no help, they won't talk directly to anyone, you have to be a dealer. Problem is my dealer doesn't know what to do .
Okay, this is frustrating, but let's break it down. You've got a good handle on the situation, and your logic is sound. The fact that you have two other identical units working correctly is a huge advantage. Here's a systematic approach to troubleshoot this, building on your existing knowledge
1. The Obvious (but Double-Check):
Voltage Sensing
This is the heart of the problem. Since the generator doesn't "see" the power outage, the transfer switch won't trigger. Focus on this.
Dedicated Voltage Sensing Lines
Ensure the voltage sensing wires from the utility are connected correctly and securely to both the generator and the transfer switch. These are usually separate from the load wires. These sensing wires must be connected or the transfer switch will never know it lost power.
Voltage Levels
Using a multimeter, verify the voltage on those sensing lines at both the generator and the transfer switch. They should be reading the expected utility voltage when power is on, and zero when power is off. Don't assume; measure. A slightly loose connection can sometimes carry enough voltage to light an LED but not enough to trigger the control system.
Polarity
Ensure the polarity of these sensing wires is correct, even though it's AC. A lot of control systems have voltage sensing circuits that monitor both L1 and L2 voltages for balance. A reversed wire might throw off the readings.
Neutral/Ground Bonding
Verify that the neutral/ground bonding is set up correctly in both the generator and the transfer switch, especially if this is a separately derived system. If not, it can cause voltage sensing problems.
2. Comparator Check
I'm unsure of the model number for your transfer switch, but many residential transfer switches have a comparator that constantly watches for utility power coming from the panel, and sends voltage back to the generator to signal that the utility is present. On Generac transfer switches there is a 12VDC signal. Check for proper voltage back at the generator
During a utility power outage, ensure you do not have the presence of voltage at the generator, indicating to the generator that utility power is present.
3. Direct Comparison with Working Units
Voltage Sensing (Again!)
Go to one of your working units. With the power on, measure the voltage on those sensing wires at both the generator and the transfer switch. Note the exact voltage reading. Then, turn off the power to that unit and measure again. Compare these readings to the readings on your problem unit. This will give you a baseline for what's "correct."
Control Wiring
Compare the control wiring (the wires that communicate between the generator and the transfer switch) between a working unit and your problem unit. Look for:
Wire Colors
Confirm the colors match up correctly at both ends. It's easy to accidentally swap a wire.
Wire Gauges
Are the wire gauges correct for the distance? Undersized wires can cause voltage drops.
4. Deep Dive into the Transfer Switch
Specific Transfer Switch Model
Find the exact model number of the transfer switch. This is critical for finding the right documentation.
Detailed Manual
Download the full installation and troubleshooting manual for that transfer switch model. Don't just rely on the quick start guide.
Terminal Blocks
Carefully inspect every terminal block in the transfer switch. Look for:
Loose Wires
Pull gently on each wire to ensure it's securely connected.
Corrosion
Check for any signs of corrosion or oxidation on the terminals. Clean with a wire brush and electrical contact cleaner.
Incorrect Wiring
Double-check that every wire is connected to the correct terminal according to the manual. Pay close attention to the control wiring between the generator and the transfer switch.
Dip Switches
Verify the dip switch settings on the transfer switch control board are correct for your application (e.g., voltage, frequency). The manual will tell you the correct settings.
LED Status Codes
While you mentioned the LEDs are lit, see if they blink or have a specific pattern. The manual may have a table that decodes those LED status codes.
5. Generator-Specific Checks
Generator Model Number
Find the exact model number of the generator.
Generator Diagnostic Codes
Consult the generator manual to see if there are any diagnostic codes or error messages that aren't displaying on the main screen. You may need to access a hidden menu or connect a diagnostic tool.
Voltage Regulator
The voltage regulator in the generator is responsible for maintaining the correct output voltage. If the regulator is malfunctioning, it could be affecting the sensing circuits.
Stator Windings
Very unlikely but you should be able to check the stator windings for short to ground.
6. Isolating the Problem
Force Transfer
If possible, try to manually force the transfer switch to the generator position (consult the manual for how to do this). If the generator starts and runs when forced, this suggests the problem is in the sensing circuit of the transfer switch.
Simulate Power Outage at Generator
Try disconnecting the utility sensing wires directly at the generator while the generator is in Auto. Does the generator start? If so, the problem is likely in the wiring or the sensing circuits between the utility, the transfer switch, and the generator.
Simulate Power Outage at Transfer Switch
Try disconnecting the utility sensing wires directly at the transfer switch while the generator is in Auto. Does the generator start? If so, the problem is likely in the wiring or the sensing circuits between the utility and the transfer switch.
7. Contacting Kohler (Indirectly)
Be Prepared
Before calling the dealer again, arm yourself with very specific questions based on the troubleshooting steps above. "The voltage on the utility sensing wire at terminal X in the transfer switch is reading Y volts when the power is off. Is that normal?" This shows them you've done your homework.
Escalate
If the dealer is still unhelpful, ask to speak to a supervisor or someone with more technical expertise.
Social Media/Forums
Post your problem (with the model numbers) on online forums dedicated to generators or electrical work. You might find someone who has encountered the same issue.
Important Safety Notes
Work Safely
Always disconnect power before working on any electrical equipment. Use proper personal protective equipment (PPE), including insulated gloves and eye protection.
Qualified Electrician: If you are not comfortable working with electrical equipment, consult a qualified electrician.Good luck! I know this is a long list, but by systematically working through these steps, you should be able to pinpoint the problem and get your generator working correctly. Remember to keep detailed notes of your findings. Flag for review