User: RussB, Location: Albuquerque, NM.
Asked on: Wednesday, November 27, 2024 at 7:20 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:43 am EST
Question: HI,I'm studding for my masters.And going through Multifamily Calculations. in one of the questions was about 10x 8k Ranges.the book says use column b in table 220.55 = 27.20k.I was thinking I should be using column C @ 25k for minimum.The way i understood in column A and B were options to Column C. and you should use the lower.Am i wrong in my thinking?
You're asking about applying Table 220.55 from the National Electrical Code (NEC) to calculate the demand load for ten 8kW electric ranges in a multifamily dwelling. Let's break down the confusion and clarify why Column B is the correct choice in this specific scenario.
Understanding Table 220.55 (NEC): Demand Factors for Household Electric Ranges, Wall-Mounted Ovens, Counter-Mounted Cooking Units, and Other Household Cooking Appliances Over 1 3/4 kW Rating The Purpose
This table reduces the total connected load of ranges when calculating the service or feeder size. Ranges are rarely all used at their maximum capacity simultaneously, so a demand factor allows for a smaller, more realistic feeder/service.
Column A
Applies to dwelling units with a nameplate rating of each range NOT over 12kW.
Column B
Applies to dwelling units with a nameplate rating of each range NOT over 12kW. This column usually results in lower demand loads than column A but higher than column C.
Column C
Applies to dwelling units with a nameplate rating of each range NOT over 3 1/2 kW
Why Column B is likely correct in your case
Range Rating
You stated the ranges are 8kW. This clearly exceeds the "3 1/2 kW" limit for Column C.2.
Column A & B Choice The note at the top of Table 220.55 allows for using either column A or Column B for ranges rated not over 12kw.
Why your initial thinking is incorrect (typically)
You're right to look for the lowest load. That's a good principle for safe, conservative design. However, you can't just pick and choose from any column. Each column has specific conditions that must be met. In most cases you will use Column B instead of Column A because of the reduction in load.
Summary For ten 8kW ranges, Column B of Table 220.55 is almost certainly the correct starting point. The table yields a demand factor of 27.20kWTo be absolutely sure, you should also consider these factors
Local Codes and Amendments
Always double-check your local electrical codes or any amendments made by your jurisdiction. They might have slightly different rules or interpretations of the NEC.
Specific Instructions in Your Book: Review the surrounding text in your textbook question carefully. There might be additional information or context that would change the interpretation.In conclusion, while the goal is to minimize load calculations (within code limits) to save on equipment costs, you must strictly adhere to the conditions specified for each column in Table 220.55. Since your ranges are 8kW, Column B is likely the appropriate choice for your calculation. Verify the absence of local amendments and double-check the book's surrounding text. Flag for review