User: Mark Stone, Location: Sioux Falls, SD
Asked on: Wednesday, November 27, 2024 at 11:57 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:44 am EST
Question: I am preparing a calculations training for several of our electricians. I wanted to go a little deeper into voltage drop and give them background into how it was developed. This is when I came across an article on the EC&M website that states that K needs to be adjusted for cable larger than 1/0. The adjustment is achieved by multiplying K by Q. Q is found by dividing the AC resistance by the DC resistance. I wanted more than one source, before putting this information out in training. I see there are a few posts in the forum that references this adjustment. Can anyone provide me with another reference other than the EC&M website? I have posted the link to the article below.
You're right to seek confirmation from multiple sources before incorporating this into your training. The adjustment of the 'K' factor for larger conductors due to AC resistance is a nuanced topic that's often glossed over in basic voltage drop calculations.Here are a few alternative resources that discuss the adjustment of the 'K' factor or address the difference between AC and DC resistance in conductors: IEEE Standards
While it will not discuss adjusting K directly, the IEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers) publishes numerous standards related to electrical power systems. Standards like IEEE 141 (Recommended Practice for Electric Power Distribution and Coordination of Industrial and Commercial Power Systems, also known as the Red Book) often contain detailed discussions of conductor characteristics, including AC resistance and skin effect. They might not explicitly discuss the 'Q' factor as presented in the EC&M article, but they provide the underlying principles. (Note: Accessing IEEE standards usually requires a subscription or purchase.)
Power System Analysis Textbooks
Textbooks on power system analysis frequently discuss the differences between DC and AC resistance due to factors like skin effect and proximity effect. These books provide the theoretical foundation for why such adjustments are necessary. Look for sections on conductor modeling or transmission line parameters.
Manufacturer's Data
Some cable manufacturers provide more detailed specifications for their products, including AC resistance values at various frequencies. This information can be used to calculate the 'Q' factor for a specific cable size and frequency.
Key Concepts to Understand (Underlying Why 'K' Needs Adjustment)
Skin Effect
At higher frequencies (like 60 Hz AC), current tends to flow more towards the surface of a conductor than through its center. This effectively reduces the cross-sectional area available for current flow, increasing the AC resistance compared to the DC resistance. This effect is more pronounced in larger conductors.
Proximity Effect
When conductors are close together, the magnetic field created by the current in one conductor can induce eddy currents in neighboring conductors. These eddy currents oppose the flow of current, further increasing the AC resistance.
'K' Factor Simplification
The 'K' factor (circular mil ohms per foot) used in basic voltage drop calculations is a simplification that assumes a constant resistance per unit length based on DC resistance. This assumption is reasonable for smaller conductors where skin effect and proximity effect are less significant.
Engineering Toolbox
The following website has some calculation tools that cover skin effect. Although it is not directly discussing K, the result of skin effect is the adjustment of K.[https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/skin-effect-d_910.html](https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/skin-effect-d_910.html)
How to Use These Resources for Your Training
Explain the limitations of the basic voltage drop formula
Emphasize that the simple voltage drop formula using a constant 'K' is an approximation that works well for most residential and small commercial applications using smaller wire sizes.2.
Introduce the concepts of skin effect and proximity effect
Explain these phenomena in a clear and accessible way, using diagrams or animations if possible. Explain how they cause AC resistance to be higher than DC resistance.3.
Present the adjusted 'K' factor
Explain that for larger conductors, a more accurate voltage drop calculation requires adjusting the 'K' factor to account for the difference between AC and DC resistance.4.
Explain the 'Q' factor
Show how the 'Q' factor (AC resistance / DC resistance) is used to modify the 'K' factor. Explain that the AC resistance can often be found in manufacturer's data or calculated using more advanced methods.5.
Provide practical examples
Work through examples that compare voltage drop calculations using the basic 'K' factor and the adjusted 'K' factor for a large conductor. This will illustrate the potential error that can arise from using the basic formula in these cases.
Important Considerations
Complexity
Be mindful of the level of complexity you introduce. This topic can quickly become mathematically intensive. Focus on providing a conceptual understanding of why the adjustment is necessary rather than getting bogged down in complex calculations.
Practical Application
Emphasize the practical implications of this knowledge. For example, electricians should be aware that voltage drop calculations for long runs of large conductors may require more accurate methods to ensure compliance with code requirements and proper equipment operation.
Software Tools: In many real-world scenarios, engineers and electricians rely on specialized software tools to perform voltage drop calculations, especially for complex systems. Mention these tools and explain that they typically incorporate more sophisticated models of conductor behavior.By combining information from multiple sources and focusing on the practical implications of AC resistance, you can provide your electricians with a deeper understanding of voltage drop and equip them to handle more challenging electrical installations. Flag for review