Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Annex B - Cable Ampacity Studies

User: MJP, Location: Houston

Asked on: Wednesday, November 27, 2024 at 2:12 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:44 am EST

Question: Dear AllHoping someone can provide some advice here.I'm managing an electrical installation for EV chargers and my A&Es have been using the standard NEC 310.15 for the cable sizing. There will be up to 12 cables in a duct bank, as this is a large installation. There have been some challenges from certain parts of the business, that we should be using Annex B to correct for cable grouping and temperature. The general consensus from my A&Es, is this is not applicable in this use case, wondered if anyone had any opinions on when Annex B is relevant?Apologies I'm not a PE, so probably have left out some key elements here.

Okay, let's break down NEC 310.15 and Annex B and how they apply to your EV charger installation. It's a very common debate, and it's important to get it right for safety and code compliance.

Understanding the Basics NEC 310.15 (Ampacity Tables)

This section of the National Electrical Code (NEC) provides the
basic ampacity (current-carrying capacity) of conductors based on their insulation type and the assumed ambient temperature. These tables (like 310.15(B)(16)) give you a starting point. They assume specific conditions: Up to three current-carrying conductors in a raceway, cable, or earth (directly buried). An ambient temperature (typically 30°C or 86°F).

Derating (Adjustment Factors)

When the conditions differ from those assumed in the ampacity tables, you must apply correction factors. This includes:

Ambient Temperature Correction (310.15(B)(1), and the tables associated)

If the ambient temperature is
higher than the temperature the table is based on, you reduce the ampacity.

Number of Conductors in a Raceway or Cable (310.15(B)(3))

If you have more than three current-carrying conductors in a raceway, cable, or directly buried, you reduce the ampacity. This is the key part for your situation.

Annex B (Example Calculations)

This is an
informative annex (not mandatory) that provides detailed examples of conductor ampacity calculations, often for more complex scenarios, including underground installations (duct banks). Annex B supplements the requirements of Article 310; it doesn't replace them. It's more granular and precise in its calculations.

Why the Debate? When is Annex B More Applicable?


The core of the debate lies in
how precisely you need to determine the ampacity and whether the assumptions in 310.15 are sufficient for your installation. When 310.15 is Usually Sufficient

Relatively few conductors in the duct bank. Good thermal dissipation (e.g., widely spaced ducts). Conservative design (oversized conductors). Lower charging loads, where the chargers are not all fully utilized simultaneously.

When Annex B
Should Be Considered (More Likely)



Many conductors in a confined duct bank (as in your case with up to 12 cables).
This is a significant factor. The heat generated by multiple energized cables will raise the temperature within the duct bank, reducing the ampacity of each cable. High charging load / Demand Factor. If all (or most) chargers are expected to be used near their maximum output simultaneously, the heat buildup will be substantial. Poor thermal dissipation

Close spacing of ducts, poor soil thermal conductivity, or high ambient ground temperature.

Critical applications where reliability is paramount.
If your calculations using 310.15 result in conductors that seem "small" for the expected load. This is a gut check. Local AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction) requirements. Some jurisdictions require or strongly recommend Annex B calculations for larger installations, especially those with duct banks.

In Your Specific Case (EV Chargers with 12 Cables in a Duct Bank)

Given that you have
up to 12 cables in a duct bank, it is highly advisable to perform a more detailed ampacity calculation considering the specific thermal characteristics of your installation. Here's why:1.

Significant Grouping Effect

With so many conductors, the heat generated by each cable will affect the others significantly. The grouping factors in 310.15(B)(3) might not be granular enough to accurately reflect the heat buildup.
2.


Thermal Resistivity

The thermal resistivity of the soil or backfill material surrounding the duct bank is crucial. Poor thermal resistivity means the heat cannot dissipate effectively, leading to higher temperatures within the duct bank. Annex B calculations allow you to input this parameter directly.3.

Load Diversity/Demand Factor
Determine if the charging load is continuous or intermittent. EV charger load is generally not continuous, so you can apply a demand factor.

How Annex B Helps (in a Simplified Way)

Annex B methods (specifically B.310.15(B)(2)) involve calculating the
thermal resistance of each layer of the installation: Cable insulation Duct material Backfill material SoilThese thermal resistances are combined to determine the overall thermal resistance between the conductor and the surrounding earth. This allows for a more accurate calculation of the conductor temperature and, therefore, its ampacity.

Steps to Take


Consult with a Qualified Electrical Engineer (PE) familiar with Annex B calculations.
This is crucial. They can perform the necessary calculations and ensure code compliance. While your A&Es may be confident, this is a situation where a second opinion and specialized expertise are highly recommended.2. Gather Detailed Information



Soil Thermal Resistivity (ρ)

This is critical. You'll need to obtain this data through soil testing or from local geological surveys.

Duct Bank Configuration

Dimensions, spacing of ducts, material of ducts.


Cable Specifications

Insulation type, size, number of conductors.

Ambient Earth Temperature

The average temperature of the earth at the depth of the duct bank.


Charging Load Profile

How many chargers are expected to be used simultaneously, and at what power level? Determine the load factor.3.

Perform Annex B Calculations

The PE will use the data gathered to perform the calculations, typically using specialized software or spreadsheets.4.

Compare Results

Compare the ampacity calculated using Annex B with the ampacity obtained using 310.15. If the Annex B ampacity is significantly lower, you'll need to increase the conductor size.
5.


Document Everything

Keep detailed records of all calculations, assumptions, and data sources. This will be essential for future reference and for demonstrating code compliance to the AHJ.6.

Consider Oversizing

Even with Annex B calculations, it's often prudent to slightly oversize the conductors as a safety margin.

Key Takeaways:
NEC 310.15 is a starting point, but it has limitations. With 12 cables in a duct bank, Annex B calculations are highly recommended to ensure accurate ampacity determination. Consult with a PE experienced in Annex B calculations. Gather detailed data about the installation.In short, your business unit has a point. With that many cables, a deeper dive is warranted. It is better to be safe and compliant than sorry later. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question