User: John165, Location: New Mexico
Asked on: Wednesday, November 27, 2024 at 3:21 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:45 am EST
Question: I just looked at a job and someone had added a 3 phase sub panel. He ran 4 1/2" runs of emt to a gutter and pulled one run of #2 in each pipe. I thought this was against code, if it is against code why? Thanks John
You are correct to be concerned. This situation raises multiple potential code violations and safety concerns under the National Electrical Code (NEC). Let's break down the issues
1. Conduit Fill Issues:
NEC 314.28(A) & Table C1, Annex C
While a single #2 AWG conductor in a 1/2" EMT conduit meets the fill requirements (meaning the conductor doesn't take up too much physical space), the problem here is the
parallel conductors. Parallel Conductors
The NEC allows for parallel conductors for certain applications (like large ampacity feeds), but not without specific requirements and usually not with this size of conductor. Typically, NEC 310.10(H) requires conductors to be #1/0 AWG or larger to be run in parallel. Since the conductors are only #2 AWG, they are likely to be against code.
2. Incomplete Circuit
NEC 300.3(B)
"All conductors of the same circuit and, where used, the grounded conductor and all equipment grounding conductors and bonding conductors shall be contained within the same raceway or cable or be installed in close proximity." You are running a
three phase circuit. Where is the neutral? Where is the ground?3. Gutter (Auxiliary Gutter) Use
NEC 366
Auxiliary gutters are covered by this article. They are intended to supplement wiring spaces at meter centers, distribution centers, switchgear, and similar points.
NEC 366.104(A)
Gutters are generally not intended to be a continuous raceway system like you're describing. There are limitations on the length of a gutter and how many conductors can pass through it. The installation sounds like the gutter is being used as a raceway.
NEC 366.56
Sum of cross-sectional areas of all conductors must not exceed 20 percent of the interior cross-sectional area of the auxiliary gutter.
4. Inductive Heating
Separating Phase Conductors
Running individual phase conductors in separate ferrous (metal) conduits like EMT creates a significant problem. Each conduit acts like a single-turn transformer. The magnetic field produced by the current in the conductor induces a circulating current in the conduit itself. This current causes the conduit to heat up. In extreme cases, this can lead to insulation damage, fire, and potentially even melting of the conduit. This effect is mitigated when all phase conductors (and the neutral, if present) are in the same raceway because their magnetic fields tend to cancel each other out.
5. Conduit as a Ground Path
NEC 250
Even if the EMT is properly connected, it is
not a reliable sole grounding path, especially in a fault condition. An equipment grounding conductor (EGC) must be installed with the circuit conductors.
Why is it against code?
The code exists to ensure electrical installations are safe and reliable. In this scenario, the concerns are: Fire Hazard
Inductive heating of the EMT.
Shock Hazard
Inadequate grounding.
Overheating
If the conduit fill is actually too high, the conductors could overheat due to lack of ventilation.
Fault Current Path
An incomplete equipment grounding conductor system can lead to dangerous voltage on equipment and a delayed or failed circuit breaker trip in the event of a fault.
In summary, this installation has many red flags. It is almost certainly not up to code and presents a significant safety hazard. It should be thoroughly evaluated and corrected by a licensed electrician. Flag for review