User: JustRob, Location: Colorado Springs, CO
Asked on: Wednesday, November 27, 2024 at 4:28 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:45 am EST
Question: I'm in my second year of business, I have no employees aside from the occasional 1099 apprentice. I never got into estimating but I noticed that the T&M's I did for my previous employer always worked out, so I've just been pricing up my jobs the same way.I'm pretty good at accounting for about 95-100% of material, put a small mark up on it and then just try to guess how long it's going to take me to do the job. Right now I'm using $95-$120/hr. depending on what its for. It can take some time but I feel its a good way to make it profitable and a good price for the customer.The only problem is that I have no idea where I stand when it comes to the average prices that home owners/contractors are paying for these services. I'm in central Colorado. I'm getting a lot of custom kitchen remodels, basement finishes and service upgrades. The smaller service jobs are a no brainer to price up but when I throw out a number for a basement finish, I'm left guessing whether this method is producing normal pricing.I've tried to wrap my head around price per square foot and price per opening but I don't know what the average price is to begin with and some of the custom work I do absolutely cannot be priced up that way. I hear about people paying 7k for a service upgrade that I could easily do for 3500. I also have contractors asking for flat rates for air conditioning and service work, that sound crazy to me unless I just shoot real high.The only feedback that I've gotten so far is that my prices are on the low end. I have had one contractor come back and say that my number for a kitchen was on the high side, but I still got the job.
Okay, you've identified a crucial area for improvement: your pricing strategy. You're essentially winging it, and while it's been working okay so far, you're leaving money on the table and potentially scaring off some customers with numbers that feel random. Here's a breakdown of how to improve your pricing, specifically for Colorado and the types of jobs you're doing
1. Acknowledge the Weakness and Commit to Improving
The fact that you're aware of this is the first step. Good! Stop relying on "guessing" labor hours. It's unsustainable and leads to inconsistency.2. Market Research - Find Your Comps (Comparables) Online Research (Limited)
HomeAdvisor, Angi, Thumbtack
Use these as a VERY rough guide. Search for the specific services you provide in your zip code (or a few surrounding ones). They can give you a ballpark, but take the numbers with a huge grain of salt as they often include wide ranges and don't account for custom work.
Local Forums and Social Media Groups
Join local homeowner groups on Facebook, Nextdoor, etc. You can occasionally see people asking for price estimates on projects. Observe the responses. Don't directly solicit business unless the group rules allow it.
Networking is Key
Talk to Other Contractors (Carefully)
Network with other contractors (not direct competitors) who offer complementary services (plumbing, HVAC, etc.). You can ask them about typical pricing ranges for specific jobs. Be discreet – don't give away all your pricing information. Focus on gathering general market rates.
Subcontractor Rates
Pay attention to what other trades are charging you (or what you'd expect to pay them). This gives you insight into the local labor market.
Secret Shopping
Get Quotes from Competitors
If you have the time and a trusted friend or family member willing to play the role of a customer, get quotes from your competitors for the types of jobs you commonly do (kitchen remodel, basement finish). This is the most direct way to see what others are charging. Be ethical – don't waste their time if you have no intention of hiring them.
3. Develop a Better Estimating System Break Down the Work
Instead of guessing total hours, break each project down into individual tasks (e.g., demolition, framing, electrical rough-in, drywall, painting, etc.).
Track Your Time
This is the MOST IMPORTANT step. For every project you do, meticulously track how much time you spend on each task. Use a time tracking app, a spreadsheet, or even a notebook. Be as accurate as possible. Do this now and keep doing it consistently. After a few jobs, you'll have a much better understanding of your labor costs.
Create a Cost Database
Build a spreadsheet or use estimating software (more on that later) to store your time tracking data. You'll start to see patterns emerge and understand how long it takes you to complete specific tasks.
Factor in Overhead
This is where many contractors fail. Overhead includes all the costs of running your business that are not directly tied to a specific project (e.g., rent, insurance, vehicle expenses, advertising, office supplies, your salary). Calculate your total monthly overhead costs. Divide your total monthly overhead by the number of billable hours you work each month. This gives you your overhead cost per hour. Add this overhead cost to your hourly labor rate.
Profit Margin
Decide on your desired profit margin. A good target for construction is typically 10-20% (or higher for specialized work). Add this profit margin to your total costs (materials + labor + overhead).
Example
Materials
$5,000
Labor (tracked hours x hourly rate)
40 hours x $100/hour = $4,000
Overhead (calculated per hour)
40 hours x $25/hour = $1,000
Total Cost
$10,000
Desired Profit Margin (15%)
$1,500
Project Price
$11,500
4. Software and Tools to Consider
Spreadsheet Software (Excel, Google Sheets)
Great for basic time tracking and cost tracking.
Estimating Software
QuickBooks Online (with Estimating)
If you're already using QuickBooks for accounting, the integrated estimating features can be helpful.
Buildertrend
Popular cloud-based project management and estimating software specifically designed for contractors.
Jobber
A simple, user-friendly option for scheduling, invoicing, and estimating.
Houzz Pro
Project management, client communication, and lead generation platform used by many contractors.
5. Square Footage and "Per Opening" Pricing (When to Use, When to Avoid)
When Square Footage Works
Use it as a starting point for standard basement finishes or simple additions. Research typical costs per square foot in your area (again, use online resources and network with other contractors). Then, adjust the price based on the specific features and finishes the client wants.
When "Per Opening" Works
Can be useful for things like window/door replacements in simpler projects. Again, know your market rates.
When to Avoid Square Footage and "Per Opening"
Custom kitchen remodels, complex additions, or any project with unique design elements require detailed, task-based estimating. Relying solely on square footage in these cases will lead to inaccurate pricing.
6. Dealing with Contractors and Flat Rates
Flat Rates for Contractors
Understand what's driving their request for flat rates. It's often for budgeting purposes or to simplify their own project management.
How to Handle Flat Rate Requests
Be Transparent
Explain your detailed estimating process and why you prefer to provide itemized quotes.
Pad the Estimate
If you're forced to provide a flat rate, significantly pad the estimate to account for potential unforeseen issues and to protect your profit margin. Be clear in your contract what is included in the flat rate.
Consider T&M with a Cap
Offer a compromise: Time & Materials up to a maximum price (cap). This gives the contractor budget certainty while protecting you from unlimited scope creep.
Walk Away
If the contractor's flat rate requirements are unreasonable or you feel pressured to cut corners, don't be afraid to walk away from the project.
7. Service Upgrades
The $7,000 vs. $3,500 service upgrade scenario highlights the importance of knowing your market.
Investigate the Difference
Try to find out what's included in the $7,000 service upgrade. Are they using higher-end materials? Are they including additional services (like panel upgrades, surge protection, or permits)?
Differentiate Yourself
If you can offer the same quality service for a lower price, highlight this in your proposals. Explain your cost savings to the client.
8. Key Takeaways
Track Your Time RELIGIOUSLY. This is the foundation of accurate estimating. Know Your Costs (Materials, Labor, Overhead). Research Market Rates. Develop a Consistent Estimating Process. Be Confident in Your Pricing. If you've done your homework and know your costs, don't be afraid to charge what you're worth. Communicate Clearly with Clients. Explain your pricing and the value you bring to the project.By implementing these strategies, you'll move beyond "guessing" and create a sustainable and profitable business. Good luck! Flag for review