User: vinnie, Location: washington
Asked on: Thursday, November 28, 2024 at 1:41 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:46 am EST
Question: helloI have a customer that lives in a duplex, and he has lost one phase in his service panel reads 100v I did check all the lugs to confirm that they were tight. The feeders run from his house panel under the duplex to the other side of the duplex and connects to meter. Both phases read correct voltage coming in and going out the meter 120v on each, so I believe one of the feeders underground is damaged. My issue is there no way to dug underground to install new feeders, but the duplex garages are connected together, and I do have access to run the feeders in the attic. Question if I install emergency disconnect at meter location and run SER cable over the garages to the existing house panel would that be to code.
Okay, let's break this down and address your options, keeping in mind that code interpretation can vary slightly by local jurisdiction, so you'll always want to check with your local electrical inspector before committing to a solution.
Understanding the Problem
Lost Phase/Low Voltage
You've correctly identified a potential open or high-resistance issue in one of the underground service conductors.
Meter is Good
The fact that the meter reads 120V on both phases coming in and going out strongly suggests the meter itself is not the problem. The issue lies between the meter and the house panel.
Underground Obstruction
You're dealing with a common but frustrating scenario where direct replacement isn't feasible.
Proposed Solution: Overhead SER Cable via Garages
This is where things get interesting and require careful consideration. Here's an analysis of your proposal and relevant code concerns: Emergency Disconnect at the Meter
This is generally a very good idea for safety. It provides a readily accessible way to kill power to the dwelling in case of an emergency. Most jurisdictions now require an accessible disconnect like this.
SER Cable (Service Entrance Riser) Overhead
This can be a viable solution, but it MUST adhere to all applicable code requirements. This is where you'll want to focus your attention and verification with your inspector.
Code Compliance Focus Points
Article 230: Services of the National Electrical Code (NEC) is the primary article governing service conductors. You'll need to pay close attention to the following: 230.6: Conductors Considered Outside the Building
Since you're running the SER cable outside the main dwelling (across garages), this becomes critical. NEC 230.6(1) states that conductors are considered outside a building where installed under not less than 2 inches of concrete or encased in 2 inches of concrete within a building or under a building. If you don't meet this minimum, then the conductors are inside the building and must meet the code rules for feeders.
230.9: Clearance from Building Openings
You'll need to ensure the SER cable is at least 3 feet from windows, doors, porches, fire escapes, or similar locations.
230.24: Clearance from Ground
SER cable must maintain required clearance from the ground. The specific height will depend on the voltage and whether it's over driveways, sidewalks, etc. It's likely going to be higher than a standard NM cable run inside a dwelling.
230.43: Wiring Methods for Services
SER cable is generally an acceptable wiring method for service conductors.
Type SER Cable
Make sure the cable is suitable for the application (weather-rated, UV resistant, etc.). Consider using aluminum SER cable if the amperage requires a larger conductor; it is typically less expensive than copper.
Physical Protection
How will you protect the cable from physical damage? Conduit might be necessary in certain locations, especially where it's exposed or near areas where vehicles or people might come into contact with it.
Support
The cable must be properly supported at appropriate intervals.
Attic Access/Work Space
Ensure there is adequate and safe access to the attic spaces for installation and future maintenance.
Fire Rating
This is critical. You're running the service conductors through the garage attics. The NEC is very sensitive about fire ratings and protecting dwellings from fire.
Concerns & Considerations
Fire Rating of the Garage Attic
This is the biggest potential issue. Garages are often considered fire-rated areas, designed to contain a fire for a certain amount of time. Running service conductors through the attic could compromise this fire rating. You might need to enclose the SER cable in a fire-rated raceway (conduit) or use a fire-rated cable, though these are typically expensive.
Joint Ownership
If the garages are jointly owned, you need to be absolutely sure you have the unquestionable right to run electrical service through them. Get written permission.
Alternative Route? Before committing to the attic, explore every other possible route, even if it seems difficult. Could you trench around the building? Could you bore under a section? Even if these are more expensive, they might be safer and more code-compliant in the long run. Load Calculation
Ensure the existing panel and service conductors are adequately sized for the customer's load. This is always a good practice when making any service changes.
Steps to Take
Talk to Your Local Electrical Inspector
This is the most important step. Explain your situation and your proposed solution. Get their feedback before you start any work. They can tell you if this approach is likely to be approved and what specific requirements you'll need to meet. Bring a detailed sketch of your plan.2.
Complete Load Calculation
Verify the existing service is adequate.3.
Obtain Necessary Permits
Once you have approval from the inspector, obtain all required permits before starting work.4.
Professional Installation
This is not a DIY job. Hire a qualified electrician who is experienced in service upgrades and familiar with local codes.5.
Thorough Inspection
After the work is complete, have the inspector thoroughly inspect the installation to ensure it meets all code requirements.
In summary: Running SER cable across the garage attics might be acceptable, but it depends heavily on local code interpretation and specific conditions (fire rating, physical protection, clearances, etc.). The most important thing is to communicate with your local inspector first and get their approval before you start any work. Good luck! Flag for review