Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Siemens SPD

User: tom baker, Location: Bremerton, Washington

Asked on: Thursday, November 28, 2024 at 10:22 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:46 am EST

Question: Installed a Siemens FSPD060 type 2 SPD on an exterior service panel. The factory leads were very long. I have installed a lot of Leviton 120/240 spds, the leads were only 18” and were zipped tied every 2”. I always install directly opposite the branch breaker with short leads

It sounds like you're concerned about the length of the leads on your new Siemens SPD and how that might affect performance. Let's break down why lead length is important for SPDs and how it relates to your installation

Why Lead Length Matters for SPDs
Inductance

Longer wires have higher inductance. Inductance opposes changes in current flow. A surge is a very rapid change in current. Excessive inductance can impede the SPD's ability to quickly divert the surge, diminishing its effectiveness and potentially causing the surge voltage to bleed through.


Increased Clamping Voltage

Higher inductance means a higher voltage drop across the leads during a surge. This voltage drop adds to the clamping voltage of the SPD itself, meaning the voltage that actually gets through to your downstream equipment is higher.

Your Installation & Concerns
Long Factory Leads

Yes, some SPD manufacturers provide longer leads than others. The Siemens FSPD060 does have longer leads than some other brands, like Leviton.


Leviton's Short Leads & Zip Ties

The short leads (18") and zip ties used by Leviton (and others) are a design strategy to minimize inductance. Tying the leads together helps reduce loop area, further lowering inductance.

Opposite Breaker with Short Leads

You've been correctly prioritizing short lead lengths by installing the SPD directly opposite the breaker it is protecting. This is best practice.

How to Address the Long Leads on the Siemens SPD
1. Minimize Lead Length

The
most important thing is to cut the leads as short as safely and practically possible. You want to have the SPD located so that the leads can run directly and as straight as possible to their connection points (circuit breaker terminals and neutral/ground bar).2.

Bend, Don't Coil

If you have
any excess lead length, bending the wire in wide arcs is far preferable to coiling it. Coiling creates an inductor. Avoid sharp bends, which can damage the wire.3.

Secure Leads Together (Bundling)

If you have a bit of excess length,
loosely secure the phase and neutral leads together (zip ties are fine). This helps reduce the overall loop area and therefore the inductance. Do not overtighten the zip ties, as that can damage the wire's insulation.4.

Direct Connection vs. Pig-Tailing (if applicable)

If you have the option of connecting the SPD wires directly to the breaker terminal or ground/neutral bar, do so instead of pig-tailing (connecting to existing wires with a wire nut). Pig-tailing can add inductance.5.

Safety First

Always de-energize the panel before working on it and follow all applicable electrical codes. Use properly insulated tools.

Specific Considerations for Siemens FSPD060



Read the Installation Instructions

The Siemens SPD installation instructions should provide guidance on lead length and installation best practices. Follow those instructions first and foremost. If the instructions specify a maximum lead length, adhere to that.

Siemens' Design

Siemens designed the SPD with those leads in mind. While shorter is
generally better, it's also important to recognize that they've engineered the device to function within a certain range of lead lengths.

Important Notes



Panel Space

While minimizing lead length is crucial, don't overcrowd the panel. Ensure there's adequate space for proper heat dissipation and that you don't violate any fill requirements in the panel.

Proper Termination

Ensure that all wire terminations (to the breaker, neutral bar, ground bar) are clean, tight, and secure. Loose connections can create resistance and heat, which is dangerous.


Professional Advice

If you're unsure about any aspect of the installation, consult a qualified electrician. Working with electrical panels can be dangerous.

In summary:
Shorten those leads as much as safely and practically possible, secure them together, avoid coiling, and follow the manufacturer's instructions. While the longer leads might make you uneasy based on your experience with other SPDs, remember Siemens has designed the unit with those leads in mind, as long as you install it according to their instructions. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question