Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Type 2 SPD installed as a Type 1 SPD in ATS for standby generator

User: MrTomas, Location: Pennsylvania

Asked on: Saturday, November 30, 2024 at 2:24 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:48 am EST

Question: Greetings. My electrician installed an Eaton CHSPT2SURGE type 2 surge protector in the ATS by double-tapping into the main lugs on the line side. I am about to schedule the final inspection for this work, and I'd like to know what to expect. My amateur opinion is its against code. I believe we are talking NEC 2023. Furthermore, as you can see in the picture, the 2 status LEDs on the SPD are out. They randomly go out, either one or both of them, then come back. I assume the very cold weather caused the double-tapped lugs to loosen. The ATS is Generac model RXSW200A3 (I think; another model # is given in the pic). I read nothing in the ATS owners manual saying the N1 and N2 connectors may be double-tapped.Is this code compliant? How bad is this? Thanks in advance.

Okay, let's break this down. You're right to be concerned and get this clarified before the inspection. Here's my assessment based on your description and the picture, referencing NEC 2023, and what to expect from an inspector

1. Double-Tapping the Main Lugs: Likely a Code Violation
NEC 110.3(B)

This is the fundamental rule. Equipment must be installed according to the manufacturer's instructions. If the Generac ATS manual doesn't specifically allow double-tapping those N1 and N2 lugs, it's a violation. You need to consult the ATS manual and any accompanying documentation.


NEC 110.14(A)

Connections need to be tight and made with appropriate connectors. Double-tapping on a lug not designed for it can lead to loose connections, arcing, overheating, and eventually failure or fire.

NEC 408.41

Deals with surge protection. This section will lead you to other relevant sections and specifically mentions that the SPD's connection must be made in accordance with its instructions and any labeling. This leads back to 110.3(B).


Your Assessment

Your intuition is correct. The inspector will likely flag this.

2. Status LED Issues: Indicative of Problems
Connection Issues

The intermittent nature of the LEDs going out strongly suggests a connection problem. It could be at the lugs, or even internal to the SPD itself due to voltage fluctuations caused by the poor connection.


SPD Malfunction

While less likely (since it's new), there's a chance the SPD is faulty.

Cold Weather

While cold weather
can exacerbate existing connection problems by causing expansion and contraction of materials, it shouldn't cause properly installed and tightened connections to fail.

3. How Bad Is This? Potentially Very Bad
Fire Hazard

Loose connections are a major fire hazard. Arcing and overheating can ignite nearby materials.

SPD Ineffectiveness

A loose connection renders the surge protector less effective or completely useless. It might not be able to shunt surges properly, leaving your equipment vulnerable.


Equipment Damage

Voltage fluctuations caused by the loose connection can damage sensitive electronics in the ATS and downstream.

Inspection Failure

This WILL likely fail inspection, requiring costly rework.

4. What to Expect from the Inspector
Rejection

The inspector will most likely reject the installation due to the double-tapping violation. They'll cite NEC 110.3(B) and possibly 110.14(A).

Request for Manufacturer Documentation

They might ask for the Generac ATS manual to confirm whether double-tapping is allowed.


Emphasis on Safety

The inspector will emphasize the fire hazard and the need for a proper, code-compliant connection.

5. What You Should Do Immediately
1. Consult the ATS Manual

Before doing anything else, thoroughly review the Generac RXSW200A3 ATS manual, specifically the section on wiring connections. See if it explicitly allows double-tapping those lugs. If you can't find it, contact Generac directly for clarification.2.

Contact Your Electrician ASAP

Explain your concerns and the likelihood of a failed inspection. Tell them about the LED issues. A good electrician will recognize the problem and offer a solution.3.

Possible Solutions (To Discuss with Your Electrician)



Replace Lugs

The ideal solution would be to replace the existing lugs with appropriately sized lugs that are rated for multiple conductors (if available and compatible with the ATS).


Wire Splicing/Taps

Install a short length of appropriately sized wire from each lug to a listed and labeled connector (like a Polaris connector) that is rated for multiple wires. Then connect both the original wire and the SPD wire to that connector. This moves the double-tap away from the lug itself.

Subpanel

Install a small subpanel downstream of the ATS (if space and design permit) to properly terminate the SPD. This is often the best and safest solution.4.

Address LED Issue

The electrician should troubleshoot the LED problem
after fixing the connection issue. It might resolve itself once the connection is secure. If not, the SPD might need to be replaced.

Important Considerations
Work Quality

The wiring in the picture looks somewhat sloppy. While not necessarily a code violation on its own, it's indicative of a rush job. Good electrical work is neat, organized, and well-labeled.

Safety First:
Do not attempt to fix this yourself if you are not a qualified electrician. Working with live electricity is extremely dangerous.In summary, this installation has a high probability of failing inspection. Prioritize getting this fixed by a qualified electrician before* the inspection to avoid delays, added costs, and, most importantly, potential safety hazards. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question