Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Transformer

User: the juicer, Location: US

Asked on: Sunday, December 1, 2024 at 12:18 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:48 am EST

Question: Changed out a sub panel 400 amp -277 /480 volt , being fed from a 2000 amp mdp, turned on the 400 amp feed in mdp,all breakers turned on in sub panels feeding lights came on with no issues. We turned on the 2- breakers In Sub panel feeding 2 separate 75 kva dry type transformers,well we tried. When either transformer got power turned on it would trip the 400 amp in the mdp instead of transformer breaker. Did the same thing with either transformer. Scratching head now. These things have been working fine since mid 80s. Changed out sub panel because of ac units frying some breakers in sub panel.also installed a main in sub panel,which didn't trip.

Okay, this is a classic troubleshooting scenario. Let's break it down and explore the potential causes. Since both transformers cause the 400A breaker in the MDP to trip, the problem is likely not the transformers themselves (though they need to be investigated). It's something in the overall setup or an interaction with the new subpanel. Here's a systematic approach to figuring this out

1. Initial Considerations and Safety:
Safety First

Double-check EVERYTHING before energizing anything again. Verify all connections are tight, properly insulated, and that nothing is obviously damaged.


Qualified Electrician

This is high voltage, and you need a qualified and experienced electrician to handle this. My suggestions are for informational purposes, and do not substitute professional on-site troubleshooting.

Documentation

Have all relevant documentation readily available:
One-line diagram of the electrical system. Transformer nameplate data (voltage, kVA, impedance (%Z)). Breaker trip curves (if available). Wire sizes and insulation types.

Metering and Testing

Have the following equipment on hand and know how to use it safely: High-voltage multimeter. Clamp meter (capable of measuring inrush current). Insulation resistance tester (Megger). Power quality analyzer (optional but helpful).

2. Potential Causes and Troubleshooting Steps



Inrush Current

Transformers have a very high inrush current when initially energized (typically 8-12 times the full-load current). This could be the most likely culprit. The new 400A breaker in the MDP may be more sensitive than the old one.


Troubleshooting


Verify Breaker Type

Ensure the 400A breaker in the MDP is properly sized and rated for transformer loads. It should be an instantaneous trip (magnetic) breaker with an appropriate AIC rating. Check its trip curve; it may be tripping on instantaneous overcurrent due to the inrush.2.

Measure Inrush Current

Use a clamp meter capable of capturing inrush current. Measure the current on each phase immediately after closing the 400A breaker in the MDP. Compare this to the breaker's instantaneous trip setting.3.

Staggered Starting

If possible, try energizing the transformers one at a time with a delay of a few seconds between them. This might reduce the overall inrush seen by the MDP breaker.4.

Pre-Magnetization

Consider a pre-magnetization circuit (if feasible) to reduce inrush. This is more common in very large transformers, but it's a theoretical possibility.5.

Upgrade Breaker (Carefully)

As a last resort, you might consider a slightly larger breaker in the MDP if the existing wiring is properly sized for the larger breaker and the transformer overcurrent protection is still adequate.

This requires careful analysis and is NOT a substitute for fixing the underlying problem if one exists. This should be performed by a qualified individual and after a load study.
6. Soft Starter/Inrush Current Limiter

Consider using an inrush current limiter on the transformer primary side.

Ground Fault

A ground fault in the wiring, transformers, or connected equipment can cause a high fault current that trips the breaker.


Troubleshooting


Insulation Resistance Test (Megger)

De-energize the entire circuit. Use a Megger to test the insulation resistance between each phase conductor and ground, and between each phase conductor and the neutral conductor (if present). Low resistance indicates a potential insulation breakdown and ground fault. Test both the primary and secondary sides of the transformers.2.

Ground Fault Relay

If the system has a ground fault relay, check its settings and operation.3.

Visual Inspection

Carefully inspect all wiring, connections, and equipment for any signs of damage, overheating, or insulation breakdown. Look for pinched wires, loose connections, or water ingress.

Short Circuit

A short circuit between phase conductors will cause a very high current draw and trip the breaker.


Troubleshooting


Continuity Testing

With the circuit de-energized, use a multimeter to check for continuity between phase conductors. There should be no continuity.2.

Visual Inspection

Look for any signs of damaged or crossed wires.

Transformer Issues

While you said the transformers worked before, they need to be verified.


Troubleshooting


Turn Ratio Test

Verify the transformer's turns ratio matches the nameplate data. This can indicate winding faults.2.

Winding Resistance Test

Measure the resistance of each winding. Compare the resistance of the windings; significant differences can indicate winding damage.3.

Exciting Current Test

With the transformer energized at a low voltage (using a variac or similar), measure the exciting current. An unusually high exciting current can indicate core damage or winding faults.

Wiring Errors in the New Subpanel

Even a small wiring error can cause significant problems.


Troubleshooting


Double-Check Wiring

Carefully review all wiring in the new subpanel, ensuring it matches the design drawings and NEC requirements. Pay close attention to the connections to the transformers.2.

Neutral and Ground

Verify that the neutral and ground are properly bonded (if required) and that there are no unintended connections between them. Especially, make sure the grounding electrode conductor (GEC) is properly connected.3.

Phase Rotation

Incorrect phase rotation can cause issues with some loads. While it's unlikely to cause a direct trip, it's good to verify it's correct.

Harmonics

While less likely in this scenario, harmonics can contribute to breaker tripping, especially if there are significant non-linear loads connected.


Troubleshooting


Power Quality Analysis

Use a power quality analyzer to measure harmonic distortion in the system.2.

Consider Harmonic Mitigation

If harmonics are a problem, consider using harmonic filters or reactors.

New Breaker Sensitivity

As mentioned earlier, the new 400A breaker in the MDP may be more sensitive than the old one.


Troubleshooting


Compare Trip Curves

Obtain the trip curves for the old and new breakers and compare them.2.

Adjust Trip Settings (If Possible)

Some breakers have adjustable trip settings. Consult the manufacturer's documentation to see if the settings can be adjusted to accommodate the transformer inrush current.

3. Step-by-Step Troubleshooting Procedure


De-energize the entire circuit.
2. Visually inspect all wiring, connections, and equipment.3. Perform insulation resistance tests on the wiring and transformers.4. Perform continuity tests on the wiring.5. Verify the transformer's turns ratio and winding resistance.6. Energize the circuit with one transformer connected. Measure the inrush current.7. If the breaker trips, analyze the inrush current and compare it to the breaker's trip curve.8. Repeat steps 6 and 7 with the other transformer.9. If the problem persists, investigate the other potential causes listed above.Important Considerations



Coordination

Ensure that the overcurrent protection devices (breakers and fuses) are properly coordinated to prevent nuisance tripping and to provide selective fault clearing.


NEC Compliance

Ensure that all wiring and equipment comply with the National Electrical Code (NEC) and local electrical codes.*

Consult with Experts:
If you are unable to resolve the problem, consult with a qualified electrical engineer or transformer specialist.This is a complex issue, and it's important to be methodical and thorough in your troubleshooting. Always prioritize safety and consult with qualified professionals when necessary. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question