User: fltpa, Location: Florida
Asked on: Sunday, December 1, 2024 at 3:44 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:48 am EST
Question: Recently purchased an older home that has had its fair share of electrical issues. Opened up a cabinet this morning to find this exposed NM cable running to an outlet housed on the side of it. I was told by the QA guy within my company to encase it in carflex for protection since it’s a short length and call it a day.Personally, it seems like hack job suggestion. Is it even up to code? What better solutions are out there?Thanks
You're right to be skeptical. Your QA guy's suggestion might technically meet the minimum requirements in some cases, but it's far from the best or safest solution, and very likely not up to code. Here's a breakdown of the issues and some better alternatives
Problems with the Carflex (Flexible Nonmetallic Conduit) Suggestion:
Physical Protection
While carflex can offer some protection, it's easily damaged, especially in a cabinet where it's likely to be bumped, snagged, or cut. It's not designed for heavy impact or abrasion.
Appearance
It looks unprofessional and doesn't improve the overall aesthetic of the installation.
Not Always Permitted
While you can technically sleeve an existing NM cable with carflex for physical protection, it doesn't necessarily mean it meets code and/or is approved by local jurisdiction, especially if the cable is already damaged or improperly routed.
Why It Might Not Be Up to Code (Consult local codes)
Here's the deal. There are always local variations to the National Electrical Code (NEC), so you need to consult your local building codes and/or a licensed electrician. But here are the common issues:
Improper Use of NM Cable
NM cable (Romex) is intended for dry, interior locations. Running it exposed inside a cabinet might not meet this requirement, especially if the cabinet is near a sink or other damp area.
Physical Damage
If the NM cable is already damaged, adding carflex doesn't magically fix it. Damaged cables need to be replaced.
Securing and Support
NM cable needs to be properly secured and supported. Simply sleeving it in carflex doesn't necessarily address this. NM cable is typically secured to framing members every 4.5 ft. 12" from the cabinet should be supported if the cable is 12" long.
Better Solutions (In order of Preference and Safety)
Rewire with Conduit (Best Option)
Description
This is the most code-compliant and professional solution.
How to Do It
Disconnect the circuit (very important!). Remove the NM cable completely. Install rigid metal conduit (RMC), intermediate metal conduit (IMC), electrical metallic tubing (EMT), or even PVC conduit (if allowed by local code for this application) from the power source to the outlet box. Run individual THHN/THWN wires inside the conduit.
Why It's Best
Provides superior physical protection, is code-compliant, and allows for future upgrades or repairs. Metal conduit also offers grounding.
Considerations
Requires more skill and potentially more materials. May need to install junction boxes for ease of pulling wire.2.
Replace with Armored Cable (MC or AC Cable)
Description
A flexible metal-clad cable with insulated conductors inside.
How to Do It
Disconnect the circuit. Replace the NM cable with MC (Metal Clad) or AC (Armored Cable). Secure and support the cable properly.
Why It's Good
Offers good physical protection and is easier to install than rigid conduit. AC cable requires a bonding strip to ensure proper grounding.
Considerations
More expensive than NM cable. Still requires proper securing and support.3.
Properly Secure and Protect the Existing NM Cable (Least Preferred, But Sometimes Acceptable)
Description
If the existing NM cable is in good condition and its use is acceptable based on the cabinet's environment, you might be able to improve the installation without rewiring.
How to Do It
Secure the cable properly to the framing. Protect the exposed section with a metal or heavy-duty plastic raceway (not just carflex). This can be a surface-mounted raceway designed for electrical wiring. Ensure the raceway is securely mounted to the cabinet.
Why It's Least Preferred
Still relies on the NM cable being in good condition and properly rated for the environment. Offers less protection than rewiring with conduit or AC/MC cable.
Considerations
This is the option most likely to be questioned by an inspector.
Important Considerations
Hire a Licensed Electrician
Electrical work can be dangerous. If you're not comfortable working with electricity, always hire a licensed electrician. They can assess the situation properly and ensure the work is done safely and to code.
Local Codes
Always check with your local building department or a qualified electrician to ensure your work complies with local electrical codes. These codes can vary significantly from place to place.
Disconnect Power
Always disconnect the power to the circuit before working on any electrical wiring. Use a voltage tester to confirm the circuit is dead.
Grounding
Ensure all metal boxes and conduit are properly grounded.
In summary:
While your QA guy's carflex suggestion might technically be something, it's not the right something*. It's a band-aid solution that doesn't address the underlying issues and might not even be up to code. Prioritize safety and code compliance by choosing one of the better solutions outlined above. The best approach is to consult with a licensed electrician to determine the most appropriate and safe solution for your situation. Good luck! Flag for review