User: Kedward, Location: San Jose, CA
Asked on: Monday, December 2, 2024 at 2:52 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:49 am EST
Question: Hello,I've been struggling on requirements for the TC-ER, ITC-ER, and PLTC-ER from 501.10(B) with respect to EGCs.(3) Type PLTC cable or Type PLTC-ER cable used for Class 2 and Class 3 circuits, including installation in cable tray systems. The cable shall be terminated with listed fittings. Type PLTC-ER cable shall include an equipment grounding conductor in addition to a drain wire that might be present.(4) Type ITC cable or Type ITC-ER cable as permitted in 335.4 and terminated with listed fittings. Type ITC-ER cable shall include an equipment grounding conductor in addition to a drain wire.(5) Type MC, Type MV, Type TC, or Type TC-ER cable, including installation in cable tray systems. Type TC-ER cable shall include an equipment grounding conductor in addition to a drain wire that might be present. All cable types shall be terminated with listed fittings.I read this as:1. PLTC-ER requires an EGC if a drain wire is present.2. ITC-ER will always have an EGC and drain wire.3. TC-ER requires an EGC if a drain wire is present.These requirements aren't entirely making sense to me, but I'm just wondering if I'm even interpreting the language correctly. I feel like it can be interpreted that all acceptable -ER cables for hazardous locations require an EGC but the wording being different for ITC-ER vs PLTC/TC-ER is making me question that.
You're right to be paying close attention to the specific wording! The NEC is very precise, and seemingly small differences can have significant implications. Let's break down your interpretation and then discuss the overall intention
Your Interpretation:
1. PLTC-ER
"Type PLTC-ER cable shall include an equipment grounding conductor in addition to a drain wire that might be present." This means: PLTC-ER must have an EGC, period. It might also have a drain wire. If it does, the EGC is in addition to that drain wire.2.
ITC-ER
"Type ITC-ER cable shall include an equipment grounding conductor in addition to a drain wire." This means: ITC-ER must have an EGC. ITC-ER must have a drain wire.3.
TC-ER
"Type TC-ER cable shall include an equipment grounding conductor in addition to a drain wire that might be present." This means: TC-ER must have an EGC, period. It might also have a drain wire. If it does, the EGC is in addition to that drain wire.
Therefore, your interpretation of the requirements is correct. All three types (PLTC-ER, ITC-ER, and TC-ER) MUST have an EGC. The difference in the wording is only related to whether a drain wire is also present or might be present.Why the "Might Be Present" Wording?
The difference in wording ("in addition to a drain wire that might be present" vs "in addition to a drain wire") is likely due to the typical construction practices for each cable type. The code writers know that ITC-ER cables are almost universally manufactured with a drain wire. PLTC-ER and TC-ER cables might be manufactured with or without a drain wire.
The Importance of an EGC in these Cables
Here's the bigger picture and why the NEC is so specific: Safety
An EGC provides a low-impedance path back to the source in the event of a ground fault. This allows overcurrent protective devices (circuit breakers or fuses) to trip quickly and clear the fault, preventing dangerous voltage from being present on exposed metal parts of equipment. This significantly reduces the risk of electric shock.
Equipment Protection
Quickly clearing ground faults also protects the equipment from damage due to sustained fault currents.
ER (Exposed Run)
The "-ER" designation means the cable is suitable for exposed runs without conduit or other raceway. This increases the potential for physical damage to the cable, which could lead to ground faults. Therefore, a reliable EGC is even more critical.
Hazardous Locations
As you mentioned, many of these cable types are used in hazardous locations. The safety implications of a ground fault in a hazardous location are even more severe (potential for ignition of flammable substances).
Drain Wire Purpose: Drain wires are primarily for shielding purposes; they do not replace the need for an EGC to provide a safe ground-fault current path to facilitate circuit breaker operation.
In Summary:
You've correctly interpreted the NEC language regarding EGC requirements for PLTC-ER, ITC-ER, and TC-ER cables. All three must* have an EGC. The difference in wording around the "drain wire" is due to typical construction practices for each cable type, and the NEC's intent is to ensure a reliable ground-fault current path for safety and equipment protection, especially when cables are run exposed or in hazardous locations. Always refer back to the NEC and manufacturer's specifications for the most accurate and up-to-date information. Consult with a qualified electrical inspector or engineer if you have any doubts about the proper installation and grounding of these cables. Flag for review