Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Cable sizing with MCCB tolerance band and "I2≤1.45xIz" rule

User: DarrowZan, Location: Australia

Asked on: Tuesday, December 3, 2024 at 12:22 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:50 am EST

Question: Hi!As per AS/NZS 3000:2018, a cable is protected if Iz≥In and I2≤1.45xIz, where In is the MCCB nominal current, Iz is the derated current capacity of the cable and I2 is the effective tripping current of the MCCB.What I don’t understand is the I2≤1.45xIz part. As per AS/NZS 60898, 1.45xIn was tested to trip circuit breakers within a time <2hr for In>63A. So for currents below this level the MCCB may not trip? In that case, shouldn't the cable be sized for >1.45xIn?The I2≤1.45xIz seems to imply that if my I2=100A (effective tripping time is 100A), then a cable with derated capacity of 70A is perfectly okay… but for any loading between 70A and 100A in that cable my MCCB may never trip and my cable will burn eventually?I'm looking to use a TemBreak PRO with a +5% to +20 tolerance band, so my I2 would be 1.2xIn as a worst case I assume, not 1.45xIn.I have a client asking for a 630A MCCB to feed a 630A switchboard. If I have a 600A load with the 630A MCCB and a cable derated for 690A we pass all items, but if someone keeps adding loads to the switchboard until I have 720A then my MCCB may never trip as the effective tripping current is 630x1.2=756A and my cable will slowly burn? So do I size my cable for >756A?Thanks!

You've identified a critical area of understanding regarding cable protection and circuit breaker coordination. Let's break down the confusion

Understanding the Standards and Principles
AS/NZS 3000:2018 (Wiring Rules)

This standard outlines the rules for electrical installations in Australia and New Zealand. Its primary goal is safety. The conditions you mentioned, `Iz ≥ In` and `I2 ≤ 1.45 x Iz`, are crucial for ensuring cables are protected against both overload and short-circuit conditions.


AS/NZS 60898 (Circuit Breakers for Household and Similar Installations)

This standard specifies the performance requirements for circuit breakers. The 1.45 x In (or sometimes 1.13 or 1.3) relates to the

conventional tripping current
, which is used to verify the tripping characteristics of the breaker during the compliance testing process. Key Principles



Overload Protection

`Iz ≥ In` ensures that the cable can continuously carry the nominal current of the circuit breaker without overheating.

Fault Current Protection

`I2 ≤ 1.45 x Iz` or `I2 <= K^2S^2/t` ensures the cable will be protected for a short circuit condition, where
K is the material factor (copper vs aluminium), S is the cable size and t is the tripping time.

Addressing Your Concerns
1. The 1.45 x In vs. AS/NZS 60898

You're correctly highlighting that the 1.45 (or 1.13 or 1.3) figure is a
testing parameter to demonstrate compliance. It's not a guarantee that the circuit breaker will trip at exactly that value in every real-world scenario. However, in the event of a fault, this factor is what dictates how long the cable can carry the current for, and how large the cable needs to be.

Important Note

The 1.45 (or 1.13 or 1.3) overload protection is often overlooked and incorrectly applied to the overload rating of the circuit breaker, when in fact it is the fault protection. In that case, 1.45Iz must be greater than the let through energy of the MCCB (I^2t), which can be found on the manufacturers datasheet.
2.


Scenario: I2 = 100A, Iz = 70A

Your concern is valid. If the cable's derated current carrying capacity (Iz) is 70A, and the circuit breaker's effective tripping current (I2) is 100A, there is a potential overload scenario where the cable is exposed to currents above its safe limit but below the immediate tripping threshold of the breaker. This is exactly the situation the standards are trying to prevent.3.

TemBreak PRO with +5% to +20% Tolerance

You're correct to use the worst-case scenario of +20% to determine the maximum potential tripping current (I2 = 1.2 x In). The manufacturer's tolerances are critical to consider for proper coordination.
4.


630A MCCB, 600A Load, 690A Cable, Potential Overload

This is the crux of your question. Let's break it down:

Current Situation (600A Load)

In (MCCB) = 630A Iz (Cable) = 690A I2 (MCCB worst-case) = 1.2 x 630A = 756A `Iz ≥ In`: 690A ≥ 630A (Passes - cable is sized to carry the breaker's nominal current) `I2 ≤ 1.45 x Iz`: 756A ≤ (1.45 x 690A) = 1000A (Passes - cable is protected against short circuit)

Potential Overload (720A Load)

The cable is now carrying 720A, which exceeds its derated capacity of 690A. The MCCB might not trip immediately because the current is below the I2 threshold of 756A.

This is a problem!
The cable is overloaded and will overheat over time, potentially leading to insulation damage and fire.

What Should You Do?

You are right to be concerned. Here's how to address the situation and provide proper protection:1. Re-evaluate Cable Sizing

Yes, you likely need to size the cable for a higher current carrying capacity. The goal is to ensure that any foreseeable overload condition (including the worst-case tolerance on the breaker) will cause the breaker to trip before the cable is damaged.

Option 1: Size for the Maximum Foreseeable Load and I2

Determine the
absolute maximum load the switchboard will ever be expected to carry. Let's say it's projected to potentially reach 750A in the future. Then, the cable's Iz must be greater than or equal to the larger of: The MCCB nominal current (630A) The maximum foreseeable load (750A) So, you'd need a cable with Iz ≥ 750A. Additionally, you still need to ensure `I2 ≤ 1.45 x Iz`. In this case, I2 = 756A and 1.45 x 750A = 1087.5, so you're good.

Option 2: Limit the Switchboard Load

If you can
guarantee the load will never exceed a certain level, you could install a physical or administrative limit on the switchboard to prevent additional circuits from being added. This is often impractical in a real-world environment.2.

Consider Alternative Protection Devices



Electronic Trip Units

MCCBs with electronic trip units often offer adjustable overload settings. You could potentially set the overload protection to a lower value to provide better protection for the cable, but this needs to be carefully coordinated.

Fuses

Fuses generally offer better current limiting characteristics and faster tripping times than circuit breakers for high fault currents. However, they require replacement after operation.3.

Documentation and Client Communication

Thoroughly document your calculations and the rationale for your cable sizing. Clearly communicate the limitations of the system to your client. Emphasize the importance of not exceeding the designed load limits of the switchboard.

Key Takeaways
The 1.45 (or 1.13 or 1.3) factor is a testing parameter, but it does relate to the ability of the MCCB to protect the cable in a specific circumstance. Always consider the worst-case tolerance of the circuit breaker. Ensure that any foreseeable overload condition will cause the breaker to trip before the cable is damaged. Proper coordination between the cable and the protection device is paramount. If you cannot guarantee the load of the switchboard (and in most situations you can't!), you should size the cable based on maximum loading plus a safety margin.In summary, you are right to question the seemingly simple application of the standards. A deeper understanding of the underlying principles and the limitations of the equipment is essential for designing a safe and reliable electrical installation. You do likely need to increase the size of your cable to ensure adequate protection, given the potential for overload and the tolerance of the circuit breaker. Consider reviewing the AS/NZS 3008.1.1 and AS/NZS 3017 to ensure compliance. Also, always consult with the manufacturer's data and recommendations for the specific circuit breaker you are using. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question