User: elec_eng, Location: New Jersey
Asked on: Tuesday, December 3, 2024 at 9:12 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:51 am EST
Question: During the site observation in one of my customers facilities, I found this very interesting set up. They have this piece of equipment that requires 150A, 208V, 3ph input. Instead of providing (1)150A 3ph circuit to this equipment, they provided (3) 50A 3ph circuits, paralleled. All three circuits are coming from the same panel and they have provide some sort of handle ties for three CBs. They have enough lugs to accept 3 circuits at the equipment.I think they couldn't install 150A 3Ph CB in the panel and they have (3) 50A spare cbs so they installed it this way. I never seen this kind of set up and not quite sure if this is allowed by the code but couldn't pinpoint the code violation. Shouldn't there be a common trip in additional to handle tie?
You're right to question this setup. Paralleling conductors, and especially paralleling entire circuits like this, is heavily restricted by the NEC. Here's a breakdown of the issues and relevant code sections
Why This is Problematic and Likely a Code Violation
NEC 310.10(H) - Conductors in Parallel
This is the primary code section governing paralleling. It specifically allows conductors to be connected in parallel only under the following conditions:
(1) Minimum Size
Conductors must be
1/0 AWG and larger. Your 50A circuits likely use conductors much smaller than this, violating this fundamental requirement. (2) Material
All parallel conductors shall be of the same material (copper or aluminum).
(3) Insulating Type
All parallel conductors shall be the same insulation type (e.g., THHN, XHHW).
(4) Termination
All parallel conductors shall be terminated in the same manner.
(5) Same Length
Parallel conductors must have the same length. Even a slight difference in length can significantly alter the current distribution.
(6) Same Conductor Area
Parallel conductors must have the same cross-sectional area (same AWG size).
(7) Same Insulation
Parallel conductors must have the same insulation.
Unequal Current Distribution
This is the biggest practical problem. Even with handle ties, the slight differences in impedance between the three circuits (due to variations in length, connections, or conductor imperfections) will cause unequal current sharing. One circuit could carry significantly more than 50A, overloading the conductors and potentially causing a fire.
Overcurrent Protection (Lack of Coordination)
The purpose of a 150A breaker is to protect the entire downstream circuit and equipment against overloads and faults up to 150A. Your setup provides only 50A of overcurrent protection per circuit. If the load draws 160A total, each circuit could, in theory, draw ~53A. But due to resistance variations, one circuit could draw as high as 60A before any breaker trips. That's 20% overload on that circuit and will likely cause a fire.
Handle Ties vs. Common Trip
Handle ties only ensure that the breakers are switched on/off simultaneously. They do not provide coordinated tripping in the event of an overcurrent or fault. You are correct; a
common trip is required for proper protection when you are allowed to parallel conductors.
Why They Probably Did It (and Why It's Still Wrong) Lack of a 150A Breaker
As you suspect, it's possible they didn't have a 150A breaker available or the panel didn't have space.
Using Existing Circuits
They may have had spare 50A circuits already installed and tried to repurpose them.
Misunderstanding of Paralleling
They may have misunderstood the NEC's rules on paralleling and thought handle ties were sufficient.
What to Tell Your Customer1. This setup is highly likely a code violation and creates a significant safety hazard.2. Immediate Action Required
The setup should be disconnected and corrected as soon as possible.3.
Corrective Options
Install a proper 150A, 208V, 3-phase circuit
This is the ideal solution. Run the correct size conductors and install a correctly sized breaker.
If the panel cannot accommodate a 150A breaker, consider sub-feeding the equipment with a sub-panel. Downsize the equipment or its load requirements
Determine if the customer can modify the equipment or its operating parameters to reduce the amperage draw to a level that can be safely supplied by existing circuits without* paralleling.
In Summary
This is a dangerous and likely non-compliant installation. The customer needs to correct it immediately to ensure safety and compliance with the NEC. Explain to them the risks of unequal current distribution and inadequate overcurrent protection. Provide them with the relevant code sections (specifically NEC 310.10(H)) so they can understand the requirements for paralleling conductors. Flag for review