Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Regular 4 square vs masonry boxes for concrete

User: JoeNorm, Location: WA

Asked on: Tuesday, December 3, 2024 at 11:18 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:51 am EST

Question: Is a regular 4 square box rated to be embedded into concrete? Are the masonry boxes just stronger?If I wanted to extend a masonry box, like I can with a variety of mud rings, how would I do so? Can you adapted them to round boxes?To me, using the 4sqare seems easier due to the variety of mud rings available but I have not done much work in concrete.This particular job will have cast in place boxes that are flush with concrete, then the wall will get a stone veneer so the box will need to be extended?

Let's break down the use of electrical boxes in concrete and how to handle your specific situation.

Regular 4-Square Boxes vs. Masonry Boxes in Concrete



Regular 4-Square Boxes

While you
can technically embed a standard metal 4-square box in concrete, it's

generally not recommended
and often not code compliant for direct burial. Here's why: Corrosion

Regular steel boxes are prone to rust in the damp, alkaline environment of concrete. This can compromise the box's integrity and the electrical connections within.

Strength

While decent, their walls are thinner than masonry boxes and they can deform under the pressure of the concrete pour. They can be damaged during construction if not properly protected.


Listing/Approval

They're typically not listed for direct concrete encasement. Electrical codes usually require boxes and fittings used in concrete to be specifically listed for that purpose.

Masonry Boxes (Concrete Boxes)

These are designed for concrete applications.


Robust Construction

They're made of thicker, more durable steel, often galvanized or with a special coating to resist corrosion.

Strength

They are much more rigid and able to withstand the pressure during the pour and vibration.


Designed for Attachment

They often have external mounting ears or flanges that allow them to be securely fastened to forms before the pour.

Listing/Approval

They
are listed for use in concrete, meeting code requirements.

In summary: Masonry boxes are stronger, corrosion-resistant, and code-compliant for embedding in concrete.
Extending Masonry Boxes

Extending a masonry box isn't quite as straightforward as using mud rings with a 4-square box, but it's done. Here are the typical methods:1.

Concrete Box Extensions

Some manufacturers make purpose-built extension rings for their masonry boxes. These bolt or screw onto the existing box, providing a defined extension. Look for these from the same manufacturer as your boxes.2.

Using Couplings and Conduit

You can use threaded rigid metal conduit (RMC) couplings to extend the box. Here's the process:
The masonry box must have a threaded hub (most do). Thread a short nipple of RMC into the box's hub. Thread a coupling onto the other end of the nipple. Thread another nipple of RMC into the coupling, extending to your desired depth. Terminate the end of the extension with a threaded conduit body (LB, T, or similar) or a weather-tight fitting if exposed. This provides a strong, code-compliant extension.3.

Chipping Out and Replacing (Worst Case)

If the extension needed is too great, or the box is in very poor condition, you might have to carefully chip away the concrete around the existing box and replace it with a deeper box (or one with a compatible extension). This is labor-intensive and should be a last resort.

Adapting to Round Boxes

Adapting a 4-square masonry box to a round box isn't really done, though some mud rings for 4-square boxes have round hole patterns for mounting devices. I do not know of a safe way to adapt the square box to round.

Your Specific Scenario (Cast-in-Place Boxes with Stone Veneer)

Here's how to approach your job:1.

Use Masonry Boxes

Start with the correct tool for the job. Use masonry boxes that are specifically listed for concrete encasement.2.

Accurate Placement

Take extra care to position the boxes accurately during the concrete pour. Consider the thickness of the stone veneer and ensure the
finished face of the box will be flush with the finished face of the stone veneer.3.

Pre-Planning

Measure the thickness of the stone veneer accurately. Then select the boxes and the correct extension method.4.

Extension Options

If the stone veneer is a small amount of thickness, you might get away with using deeper masonry boxes that accommodate the stone veneer. Use the threaded extension method (couplings and conduit) to bring the box out the proper distance. This gives you a strong, adjustable, and code-compliant extension. Use concrete box extensions.5.

Sealing

Use silicone or similar sealant around the box where it meets the stone veneer to prevent water ingress.

Why 4-Square Isn't Always Easier (Especially in Concrete)

While 4-square boxes have a lot of mud ring options, the issue is the suitability for concrete. The threaded extension method with masonry boxes is a robust and safe solution, even if it requires a bit more effort than snapping on a mud ring.

Important Considerations



Electrical Code

Always adhere to your local electrical code. The NEC (National Electrical Code) or your local amendments will have specific requirements for boxes and conduit in concrete.

Inspection

Have your work inspected by a qualified electrical inspector to ensure it meets code.

In summary, while the variety of mud rings for 4-square boxes might seem appealing, using masonry boxes with appropriate extension methods is the correct and safest approach for embedding electrical boxes in concrete, especially when you have a stone veneer to consider.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question