User: benjamin8761, Location: Laconia
Asked on: Tuesday, December 3, 2024 at 2:59 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:52 am EST
Question: A separately derived system is provided on the 4th floor of a high rise.We have connected the neutral and Ground at the transformer and then provided a Grounding Electrode Conductor from the Neutral terminal block of the transformerto building steel.The impedance from building steel (4th Floor) to the ground bar in the electrical room is 9.2 ohms. Is this acceptable, will this clear a fault and will it preventunacceptable transients during a lightening strike or intermittent secondary short on the secondary side of the transformer.Please reference exhibit 250.14 for configuration.Is there an article that dictates max impedance from these remote transformer to ground at the main service, what is the impact of a 9.2 Ohms impedanceThanks in advnace
Okay, let's break down this scenario and address your questions regarding the separately derived system (SDS) on the 4th floor.
Understanding the Setup
You have a separately derived system (SDS) on the 4th floor. This likely means you have a transformer stepping down voltage for equipment on that floor. You've correctly:1. Bonded the neutral and grounding conductor at the transformer (creating the system bonding jumper).
2. Connected a Grounding Electrode Conductor (GEC) from the neutral terminal block of the transformer to the building steel.
Analysis of the 9.2 Ohm Impedance
Here's where the concerns arise. A 9.2 Ohm impedance between the 4th-floor building steel (where your GEC terminates) and the main service ground bar is highly problematic and unacceptable.Why 9.2 Ohms is a Problem
Fault Clearing
The primary purpose of the grounding system is to provide a low-impedance path for fault current to return to the source (the transformer). A 9.2 Ohm impedance significantly impedes this current flow. This means:
Slower fault clearing times
Overcurrent protective devices (circuit breakers, fuses) may take longer to trip, exposing equipment and personnel to dangerous voltage.
Higher touch potential
The voltage rise on the building steel during a ground fault could be significantly higher, creating a shock hazard.
Inadequate fault current
Insufficient fault current may not even trip the overcurrent device at all, leading to a sustained fault condition.
Transient Voltages
A high impedance path is also detrimental during transient events like lightning strikes or intermittent secondary shorts. The impedance will limit the ability of the grounding system to shunt the high-frequency energy to ground, potentially leading to:
Equipment damage
Transients can damage sensitive electronic equipment connected to the SDS.
Increased noise
Transients can introduce noise into the electrical system, affecting the performance of sensitive equipment.
Code Compliance
The NEC requires a low-impedance ground fault path. 9.2 Ohms is almost certainly not compliant.
Exhibit 250.14 and Related NEC Articles
250.30 Grounding Separately Derived AC Systems
This is the key NEC article for your situation. It covers the requirements for grounding SDSs. It mandates bonding the neutral to ground at the SDS and connecting a GEC to a suitable grounding electrode.
250.4(A)(5) Effective Ground-Fault Current Path
This section emphasizes the requirement for a low-impedance path to facilitate the operation of overcurrent protective devices in the event of a ground fault.
250.4(A)(1) Grounding of Electrical Equipment
Ensures that the grounding system is capable of safely conducting fault current and minimizing voltage rise on equipment enclosures.
250.168 Grounding Electrode Conductor Connection to Grounding Electrodes.
It is difficult to directly connect to the effectively grounded metal frame of the building or structure as noted in 250.68Is There a Specific Maximum Impedance Value in the NEC? No, the NEC doesn't explicitly state a maximum impedance value for the path from the SDS's grounding electrode to the main service ground. Instead, it focuses on the performance of the grounding system, requiring a "low-impedance" path sufficient to clear faults and limit voltage rise. However, 9.2 Ohms is high enough to not effectively clear faults.
Impact of 9.2 Ohms Impedance
The impact of a 9.2 Ohm impedance includes: Compromised Safety
Increased risk of electrical shock and fire due to slow or failed fault clearing.
Equipment Damage
Increased susceptibility to damage from transient voltages.
Code Violation
Non-compliance with NEC requirements for grounding SDSs.
Operational Issues
Potential for electrical noise and malfunction of sensitive equipment.
Corrective Actions
Identify the Cause of the High Impedance
The most critical step is to determine why the impedance between the 4th-floor steel and the main service ground is so high. This could be due to:
Poor connections
Loose or corroded connections in the building steel.
Insulating materials
Non-conductive coatings or gaps in the steel structure.
Long and indirect path
The grounding electrode conductor may be routed through a circuitous path that increases resistance and inductance.2.
Provide a Dedicated Equipment Grounding Conductor
Run a dedicated equipment grounding conductor (EGC) from the SDS on the 4th floor back to the main service equipment ground. This EGC should be sized according to NEC Table 250.122, based on the size of the overcurrent protective device protecting the transformer secondary conductors. This will create a low-impedance path back to the service.
3.
Improve Building Steel Grounding
Bond sections of the building steel more effectively. Use bonding jumpers to bypass any insulating materials or gaps.4.
Consider a Supplemental Grounding Electrode
Install a local supplemental grounding electrode system near the SDS (ground rods, ground plates, etc.). This can help to lower the overall ground impedance.5.
Perform Impedance Testing
After implementing corrective actions, perform impedance testing again to verify that the impedance has been reduced to an acceptable level. A qualified electrician using appropriate testing equipment (e.g., a ground impedance tester) should perform this testing. Aim for a value much lower than 1 ohm, and ideally, as close to zero as possible.
Lightning Strikes
While a proper grounding system helps to mitigate the effects of lightning, it's important to recognize that it's not a complete protection solution. For adequate protection against lightning, consider a comprehensive lightning protection system installed according to NFPA 780, Standard for the Installation of Lightning Protection Systems.
In summary, a 9.2 Ohm impedance from the SDS to the main service ground is unacceptable and creates serious safety and performance issues. You must take corrective actions to reduce this impedance significantly. Flag for review