User: junkhound, Location: Renton, WA
Asked on: Thursday, December 5, 2024 at 5:53 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:57 am EST
Question: Repairing anode contact of a Toyota starter,I know, just buy a new starter, but easy fix and save $100+$$The anode side of the starter relay contact eroded enough so that consisten contact not made.Options for repair (cannot find a source for just the bolt and copper ring)a. surface weld on copper to eroded area - high risk of damage to boltb. just silphos filler on the eroded part.c. I have coin and 99% silver pieces, silphos15 silver contact area to existing boltd. straight brass braze rod. fillerThe erosion is due to anode arcing, the motor side contact erosion is minimal.Anyone with arc resistance of these methods?
Okay, let's analyze the options for repairing your Toyota starter anode contact, keeping in mind the environment (high current, frequent switching, arcing) and your desire for a durable, cost-effective solution. Given the inherent challenges, none of these options are guaranteed to be as reliable as a new component, but we can aim for the best compromise
Assessment of Your Options
a. surface weld on copper to eroded area - high risk of damage to bolt
Pros
Copper welding (TIG or MIG) can provide a good electrical connection and build up the eroded area.
Cons
High risk of damaging the bolt
The heat involved in welding can distort the bolt threads, weaken the metal, and even melt nearby components. It's VERY difficult to control the heat precisely enough to avoid these issues. The arc resistance of the copper will be good, but the surrounding metal may be softened.
Verdict
Generally Not Recommended. The risk of damaging the bolt outweighs the potential benefits. It requires specialized skills and equipment. b. just silphos filler on the eroded part
Pros
Lower temperature than welding, easier to apply with basic torch setup. Sil-phos will provide some arc resistance but is relatively brittle.
Cons
Not durable enough. Sil-phos (silver-bearing brazing alloy) is better than solder, but it's still not designed for high-current, repeated arcing applications. It's not as mechanically strong as copper welding, and it's more prone to cracking under vibration and thermal stress. The silver content is relatively low, so the arc resistance will not be superior. Verdict
Weakest option. It might work temporarily, but expect it to fail relatively quickly. c. I have coin and 99% silver pieces, silphos15 silver contact area to existing bolt
Pros
Higher silver content could improve arc resistance and electrical conductivity. Coins are often not pure silver, so I would suggest using only the 99% silver. The use of sil-phos 15 is the same as using silver solder. Sil-phos 15 also has a low mechanical strength.
Cons
Still has inherent risks. It depends on the coin alloy and the filler rod's composition, and if any of the coins are corroded, you should not use them. Joining silver to the bolt is not as strong mechanically as a single piece. If the silver detaches it may cause a short. Verdict
Potentially Better than B, but still limited. The higher silver content might help, but the mechanical strength and risk of failure remain concerns. d. straight brass braze rod. filler Pros
Brass is more robust than solder, good conductivity
Cons
Brass is an alloy of copper and zinc. It has inferior arc resistance and conductivity compared to pure copper or high-silver alloys. Brass braze filler has fairly low melting temperature and poor mechanical strength.
Verdict
Similar to B, potentially better if your only concern is conductivity. Not a great choice for arc resistance.
Recommended Approach (Compromise for Durability & Feasibility)
Before anything, clean the existing bolt thoroughly with a wire brush or abrasive pad to remove all corrosion, grease, and loose material. Good surface prep is critical for any of these to have a chance.1. Option C modified with caveats
If you are determined to use the coin/silver + sil-phos route:
Use ONLY the 99% silver. Avoid the coins if they aren't pure silver and/or corroded. Minimize Heat
Apply heat gradually and locally, just enough to melt the sil-phos and bond the silver. Avoid overheating the bolt. Use heat sink paste if you have it.
Build a Robust Shape
Try to create a slightly domed shape with the silver to provide a good contact point. Use a small file to smooth it after the silver cools.
Testing
Before reinstalling, thoroughly inspect the joint for cracks or porosity. Use a multimeter to verify good electrical conductivity.2.
Consider a Partial Solution (If all else fails)
Clean the existing bolt contact area as best as possible. Apply a thin layer of
conductive grease (NOT regular grease) to the contact surfaces. This can help improve electrical conductivity and reduce arcing, even with a slightly eroded contact. You can find conductive grease at auto parts stores or electronics suppliers. This is a band-aid, not a permanent fix, but it might buy you some time.
Important Considerations Safety
Wear appropriate eye protection and gloves when working with a torch or grinder. Work in a well-ventilated area.
Heat Management
The biggest risk is damaging the bolt with excessive heat. Use a small torch tip, apply heat gradually, and let the bolt cool down between passes. A heat sink compound or wet rag placed on the opposite side of the bolt head can help draw away heat.
Reassemble Carefully
When reassembling the starter, ensure all connections are clean and tight. Loose connections will contribute to arcing and premature failure.
Final Recommendation
While a new starter is the best option, if you're set on repairing it, a carefully executed modification of option C, using only the 99% silver and minimizing heat input, gives you the best (albeit still limited) chance of success. Remember that any repair is a compromise, and the longevity of the repair is uncertain.Good luck! Let me know if you have any more questions. Flag for review