Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Company with no electrical drawings/records

User: Pulwuj, Location: Santa Rosa CA

Asked on: Wednesday, December 11, 2024 at 6:14 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 6:10 am EST

Question: Currently working as an Electromechanical Engineer for a nameless company. I was initially hired to design low voltage automation lines and help install them in the field with electricians and technicians, something I'm fairly experienced with.After a few months I quickly realized this company doesn't have load calculations for any of their panels that I'm aware of and no accessible digital/hard copies of their panel schedules or electrical layouts. On top of this the current technical director is instructing me to basically do planless installs which would essentially add on to the undocumented mess that is this facility.Besides consulting NFPA 70 for guidance on any new projects, what would be the best course of action (besides saying no) to start documenting the electrical in this building safely and effectively?My first thought would be doing individual load calculations for each machine circuit by circuit then documenting in AutoCAD (what I've done in the past) but doing this alone will take time and justification. The justification is obvious (from my perspective) but I can't seem to convince the management to actually let me or an outside contractor start this process. I've never dealt with this level of incompetence or maybe just a lack of understanding but I'd like to hear some perspective or advice from anyone here.

This is a challenging situation, but you're right to prioritize safety and proper documentation. You've correctly identified the problem: a potentially dangerous and unsustainable electrical system lacking proper documentation. Here's a breakdown of actionable steps you can take, along with considerations for navigating the management's resistance

1. Prioritize Safety First (And Document Your Concerns):
Formal Written Communication

This is
critical. Document your concerns in writing to your technical director and their superior (if applicable). Clearly and concisely state the potential risks of undocumented electrical systems and planless installs. Use professional language, focus on facts, and avoid accusatory tones.

Example snippets for your email

"I am concerned that the lack of documented electrical load calculations and panel schedules presents a potential safety hazard and increases the risk of system failures." "Implementing installations without proper planning and documentation could lead to overloads, short circuits, and potential fire hazards, in addition to making future maintenance and troubleshooting significantly more difficult and costly." "I recommend prioritizing the creation of accurate electrical documentation to ensure the safe and reliable operation of the facility's electrical systems."

Keep Records

Save copies of all emails, memos, and any other communications related to your concerns and recommendations. This creates a paper trail.

Specific Examples

If you've encountered a
specific safety issue or near-miss due to the lack of documentation, include that in your communication. This adds weight to your argument. For example: "During the recent installation of Machine X, we encountered [problem] due to the absence of accurate panel schedules. This resulted in [consequence/delay/risk]."

2. Build a Compelling Business Case



Focus on the Positives (Not Just the Negatives)

Reframe the documentation project as an investment, not just a cost.

Highlight the Benefits (Beyond Safety)



Reduced Downtime

Accurate documentation allows for faster troubleshooting and repairs, minimizing production downtime. "With proper documentation, we can diagnose and resolve electrical issues X% faster, reducing downtime by Y hours per month."

Improved Energy Efficiency

Load calculations and panel schedules can reveal inefficiencies and opportunities for optimization. "Documenting the electrical system will allow us to identify and correct any imbalances in the system, reducing wasted energy and improving overall efficiency"


Simplified Maintenance

Easier access to information reduces the time and effort required for routine maintenance. "Having up-to-date electrical documentation will streamline maintenance procedures, reducing the risk of errors and improving overall efficiency"

Future Scalability

Documented systems are easier to expand and modify. "This documentation is important for future projects that will require electrical tie-ins."


Regulatory Compliance

Highlight the potential legal and financial consequences of not complying with electrical codes. "Documenting the electrical systems will ensure that our facility meets the requirements of NFPA 70, OSHA, and other relevant codes and regulations, reducing the risk of fines or other penalties"

Insurance

Many insurance companies require up-to-date electrical documentation.


Cost-Benefit Analysis (Even a Rough Estimate)

Try to quantify the benefits in dollar terms (e.g., reduced downtime translates to X dollars in saved production). Compare the cost of documentation to the potential cost of a major electrical failure, fire, or regulatory fine.

Phased Approach Proposal

Suggest a phased approach to documentation, starting with the most critical areas or systems. This makes the project more manageable and allows management to see tangible results.


Phase 1: Critical Systems

Begin by focusing on the most essential equipment and circuits that are critical to production.

Phase 2: Expansion

Expand the documentation project to include other areas of the facility as resources become available.


Visual Aids

Create a simple presentation with visuals to illustrate the current problems and proposed solutions.

3. Suggest Practical Solutions (and Be Proactive)



Offer to Assist (Within Your Capacity)

"While I understand the workload is high, I am willing to dedicate [X hours per week] to begin the documentation process, starting with [specific area]."


Champion a Pilot Project

Suggest starting with a small, manageable area to demonstrate the value of documentation. "I propose that we start with documentation of one critical panel to demonstrate the benefits of this process."

Explore Alternative Documentation Methods (if applicable)



Software Solutions

Research and recommend electrical design and documentation software. Some have features for load calculations, panel schedules, and automated report generation. (e.g., SKM Power Tools, ETAP, EasyPower)

Tablet-Based Documentation

Explore using tablets with specialized apps to capture data and create documentation on the go.


Photography/Videography

While not a replacement for detailed schematics, taking photos and videos of panels, wiring, and equipment can provide a valuable visual reference.

Get Buy-In from Other Departments

Talk to maintenance, operations, and safety personnel. If they understand the benefits, they can help advocate for the project.

4. Document Your Own Work (and Lead by Example)



Start with Your Projects

Even if you can't get approval for a full-scale documentation project, meticulously document your new installations and modifications.

Create Your Own Panel Schedules

Even if they are initially hand-drawn, create panel schedules for any panels you work on.


Label Everything Clearly

Make sure all new wiring, panels, and equipment are clearly labeled and identified.

5. External Contractor (If Management Remains Resistant)



Get Quotes

Obtain quotes from reputable electrical contractors specializing in documentation and load studies.


Present the Quotes with Your Business Case

Show management the cost of a professional assessment and documentation project compared to the potential costs of not doing it.

6. Know When to Escalate (and When to Consider Leaving)



Escalate to Higher Management

If your technical director is consistently dismissive of your concerns, consider escalating the issue to their manager or to the company's health and safety department.


Document Your Attempts

Keep detailed records of all your efforts to address the safety concerns.

Consider Your Options

If the company is unwilling to prioritize safety and documentation, and your concerns are consistently ignored, it may be time to consider other employment opportunities. Your professional reputation and, more importantly, your personal safety are at stake.

Important Considerations



NFPA 70E (Safety in the Workplace)

Familiarize yourself with NFPA 70E. This standard addresses electrical safety requirements for employees. You may be able to use it as a leverage point in your discussions.

OSHA

OSHA has regulations regarding electrical safety in the workplace. Ignorance of these regulations is not an excuse.


Liability

Remind management that the company is liable for any accidents or injuries resulting from an unsafe electrical system.

In Summary:


Your goal is to create a persuasive case for prioritizing electrical documentation. You need to frame it as an investment in safety, efficiency, and long-term reliability. By taking proactive steps, documenting your concerns, and offering practical solutions, you can increase the likelihood of getting management buy-in. However, be prepared to escalate your concerns if necessary, and don't hesitate to consider other options if the company is unwilling to address the risks. Your safety and professional ethics are paramount. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question