User: nhee2, Location: NH
Asked on: Tuesday, April 22, 2025 at 7:05 pm EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, April 22, 2025 at 7:05 pm EDT
Question: We need to feed a Type TC-ER, VFD cable into an explosion proof junction box in a Class I, Division 2 location. While a large portion of the install is in tray, the final run to the exp box is in conduit. We are trying to determine the best method of entry into the box, considering both the need to seal per 501.15(B)(1), and maintaining effectiveness of VFD shielding/cable benefits.- In looking at the TMCX fittings, it looks like these can be used for type TC-ER cable? I had thought they were only listed for MC-HL. is there any reason i could not transition from conduit and use a TMCX into the box? (note also in looking at the UL sheet, it appears only 1.25 - 2" are listed for TC-ER cable...)- If we use an EY seal fitting, we'd need to remove cable jacket and pour chico around the conductors - will removing jacketing and separating grounds in the cable, and running conductors immediately to the terminations inside the box nullify the benefits/performance of using the VFD cable? (VFD cable was used largely to allow it to be run in tray for 90% of the run - if we had been running in conduit the whole way, we'd have just run individual conductors.)
Okay, let's break down the options and considerations for feeding your VFD cable into the explosion-proof junction box in a Class I, Division 2 location.
Understanding the Requirements and Challenges Class I, Division 2
This environment requires enclosures and wiring methods that prevent the ignition of flammable gases, vapors, or liquids that might be present under abnormal conditions.
Sealing (501.15(B)(1))
A seal is required within 18 inches of an enclosure that contains arcing, sparking, or high-temperature devices. In your case, it's highly likely you need a seal at the junction box.
VFD Cable
The benefits of VFD cable (shielding for noise reduction, proper grounding for EMC, and robust construction) are important for reliable VFD system operation. Disrupting the cable's integrity can reduce its effectiveness.
TC-ER Cable
TC-ER (Tray Cable - Exposed Run) is suitable for use in cable tray and for exposed runs between tray and utilization equipment (motors, etc.) where supported.
TMCX Fittings
These fittings are designed to provide a secure, explosion-proof seal for cables entering enclosures, while also maintaining grounding continuity.
Analysis of Your Options1. TMCX Fitting
TC-ER Listing
You've correctly noted the limitation. While TMCX fittings can be used with some types of cable, specifically check the manufacturer's documentation and UL listing for the exact TMCX fitting size and type you are considering. As you found, many TMCX fittings are only listed for MC-HL cable and not for TC-ER. This is critical.
If the fitting is not listed for TC-ER cable, it's a code violation to use it. Benefits of TMCX (if applicable)
If the fitting is listed for your cable size and type, the TMCX is an excellent option because it provides a proper seal without disrupting the cable construction. It maintains the shielding and grounding effectiveness of the VFD cable. The grounding path provided by a listed TMCX fitting is superior to standard conduit terminations.
Transition from Conduit
The transition from conduit to the TMCX fitting is perfectly acceptable. You will need a suitable conduit fitting (like a conduit union) to connect the conduit run to the threaded entry of the TMCX fitting.
Key Question
What is the size of your cable? This will determine if a listed TMCX fitting exists for TC-ER cable. Start your search here, and consult the documentation very carefully.2.
EY Seal Fitting
Jacket Removal and Conductor Separation
This is where the problem lies regarding VFD cable performance. Removing the jacket and separating the conductors within the seal fitting disrupts the controlled impedance and grounding arrangement of the VFD cable. You will lose the shield's effectiveness against noise, which can lead to motor performance issues, drive faults, and interference with other equipment. Separating the grounds can create ground loops and introduce noise into the system.
Compromised Performance
In short, using an EY seal fitting on VFD cable significantly degrades the performance benefits of using VFD cable in the first place. It's essentially turning it into individual conductors in conduit.
Code Compliance (with caveats)
The EY seal fitting would satisfy the explosion-proof sealing requirement if installed correctly with proper sealing compound. However, electrical performance will be compromised.
Recommendations1. Prioritize a Listed TMCX Fitting for TC-ER (if available)
This is the best solution, assuming a properly sized and listed TMCX fitting exists for your TC-ER cable. Check the manufacturer's documentation. Consider using a different cable if a listed TMCX does not exist for your existing VFD cable size.2.
If a TMCX Fitting is Not Available (TC-ER Listing Limitation)
Re-evaluate the Cable Run
Consider if you can run the entire length in conduit and use individual conductors specifically designed for VFD applications. This avoids the compromise of the VFD cable's shielding and grounding. (For example, use THHN/THWN conductors with a separate, insulated grounding conductor.) Be aware of the proper grounding techniques when using individual conductors for VFD applications.
Consult with the VFD Manufacturer
Before using an EY seal, contact the VFD manufacturer for their recommendation. They might have specific guidance or acceptable alternatives based on your application and the cable's specifications. They might suggest specific grounding methods if an EY seal is unavoidable.3.
If You Must Use an EY Seal Fitting (Last Resort)
Minimize Jacket Removal
Remove as little jacket as absolutely necessary to comply with the sealing compound requirements.
Maintain Grounding
Ensure that the ground conductor is properly terminated within the explosion-proof enclosure and that a suitable ground path exists from the enclosure back to the VFD drive. Consider using a grounding braid or similar to maintain a low-impedance ground connection through the seal fitting.
Document Everything
Thoroughly document the installation, including the justification for using the EY seal and the steps taken to mitigate the loss of shielding and grounding effectiveness. This is important for future troubleshooting and maintenance.
Consider Testing
After installation, consider performing EMC (Electromagnetic Compatibility) testing to verify that the system is not generating excessive noise or interference.
Important Considerations AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)
Always consult with the local electrical inspector (AHJ) for approval of your chosen method. They may have specific requirements or interpretations of the code.
Manufacturer's Instructions
Follow the manufacturer's instructions for all fittings and sealing compounds.
Proper Installation
Proper installation is crucial for explosion-proof integrity. Use qualified personnel experienced in installing explosion-proof systems.*
UL Listing
Verify the UL listing of all components and ensure they are suitable for the Class I, Division 2 environment.
In Summary
The best solution is to use a TMCX fitting that is specifically listed for use with your TC-ER VFD cable. If that is not possible, carefully consider the alternatives and take steps to minimize the impact on the VFD cable's performance. Always consult with the VFD manufacturer and the AHJ to ensure compliance and a reliable installation. Flag for review