User: mtsparky, Location: Minnesota
Asked on: Wednesday, August 6, 2025 at 11:26 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, August 6, 2025 at 11:41 pm EDT
Question: Had an inspector today call me on having both my equipment ground and iso ground in 1 pipefor example this underground pipe feeds 4 circuits 1 of which serves an iso recep for a POS systemHe couldn’t cite a code but said both grounds could not be in the same pvc pipe…. 250.146(D) ?
Okay, let's break down the inspector's concern and whether 250.146(D) applies.
Understanding the Issue
The inspector's concern likely stems from a misunderstanding about why isolated grounds are installed. The intent of an isolated ground is to reduce noise and interference on sensitive equipment. The thought is that having both a standard equipment grounding conductor (EGC) and an isolated ground conductor (IGC) in the same conduit might negate the isolation benefits.
Why the Inspector's Concern Might Arise Perceived Coupling/Induction
The concern is that electromagnetic fields (EMF) generated by current flow in the EGC could induce current in the IGC if they are run closely together in the same conduit. This induced current could then re-introduce noise into the isolated ground system, defeating its purpose.
Lack of Complete Isolation
Running both conductors in the same conduit could be viewed as compromising the physical isolation that's intended.
Why the Inspector is likely WRONG (especially if using PVC) PVC is Non-Conductive
PVC is a non-metallic conduit. Therefore, it does not provide a path for magnetic field coupling between the EGC and the IGC. The shielding effect of a metallic conduit, which could induce currents, is not present with PVC.
NEC Doesn't Explicitly Prohibit It (with important caveats)
The NEC doesn't have a specific rule that prohibits running both an EGC and an IGC in the same non-metallic conduit (PVC, for example).
Analyzing 250.146(D)
Let's look at NEC 250.146(D) closely. It says:> (D) Isolated Receptacle Grounding. Where required for the reduction of electrical noise (electromagnetic interference) on the grounding circuit, a receptacle with an insulated grounding terminal shall be permitted. This receptacle shall be identified by an orange color and the words “Isolated Ground.”>> (1) The branch-circuit equipment grounding conductor shall be installed as required by 250.134.>> (2) The insulated equipment grounding conductor shall be connected to the equipment grounding conductor as required by 250.146(A) or (B) for services and separately derived systems respectively.>> (3) The insulated equipment grounding conductor shall be installed in the same raceway, cable, or cord as the circuit conductors. 250.146(D)(3) is KEY
This section states the opposite of what the inspector claims! It requires the insulated grounding conductor (IGC) to be installed in the same raceway, cable, or cord as the circuit conductors. This implies that the EGC could also be in the same raceway since it's required by 250.134 and is part of the overall circuit.
Arguments to Present to the Inspector1. NEC 250.146(D)(3) Supports Your Installation
Clearly point out that this section of the code requires the isolated ground conductor to be in the same raceway as the circuit conductors. If the EGC is also present, it's still compliant.2.
PVC is Non-Conductive
Explain that PVC conduit does not support the induction of current between the EGC and the IGC because it's a non-metallic material. The inspector's concern about electromagnetic coupling is not valid with PVC.3.
Ask for a Code Reference
Politely ask the inspector to provide the specific code section that prohibits the installation. If they cannot provide one, you have a strong case.
Important Considerations Metallic Conduit is Different
If you were using metallic conduit (steel, aluminum), the inspector's concern would have more merit, though still not strictly prohibited by the NEC. Metallic conduit can create a path for induced currents.
Best Practices
While the NEC might allow it, some argue that it's best practice to separate the IGC and EGC in metallic conduit runs to minimize potential interference. This is a design choice and not a code requirement.
Local Amendments
Be aware that some jurisdictions may have local amendments to the NEC that could address this issue specifically. This is unlikely but always worth checking.
In Summary
Based on the NEC, particularly 250.146(D)(3), and the fact that you're using PVC conduit, your installation is likely code-compliant. The inspector's objection is likely based on a misunderstanding of the purpose of isolated grounds and the properties of PVC conduit.
How to Handle the Situation1. Be Polite and Respectful
Avoid being confrontational.2.
Present Your Case Clearly
Explain your reasoning based on the NEC and the properties of PVC.3.
Ask for a Specific Code Reference
"Could you please point me to the specific section of the NEC that prohibits this installation? I want to make sure I understand the requirement."4.
If the Inspector Persists: If the inspector remains unconvinced, you can ask to speak to their supervisor or the head of the inspection department to get a second opinion. You can also appeal the decision if necessary.Good luck! I hope this helps. Flag for review