User: zooby, Location: Indiana
Asked on: Thursday, August 7, 2025 at 11:29 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, August 7, 2025 at 11:29 am EDT
Question: Existing 13,200 -- 277/480 xfmr. Hits the (3) ATS's . All conduits leaving have BOY and N...and G.New bldg being added. Contractor has pulled BOY and G to new ATS. Did the first contractor pull an unneeded conductor or is the current contractor wrong? Thanks for any help! Doug
Okay, let's break down this scenario: Existing System
13,200V to 277/480V Transformer feeds (3) Automatic Transfer Switches (ATSs). All conduits leaving the transformer have Brown, Orange, Yellow (BOY) phases, Neutral (N), and Ground (G) conductors.
New Building
Contractor has only pulled Brown, Orange, Yellow (BOY) phases and Ground (G) to the new ATS. They did not pull a neutral.
Question
Did the first contractor pull an unneeded Neutral (N), or is the current contractor wrong for not pulling a Neutral?
Analysis
Whether or not the Neutral is required at the new ATS depends ENTIRELY on the type of loads to be fed from that ATS and the wiring configuration within the new building. Here's a breakdown of the key considerations:
Need for Neutral at the ATS
277V Loads
If the new building will have only 480V 3-phase loads (e.g., large motors, some HVAC equipment), AND no 277V loads (e.g., lighting, receptacles), and no single-phase loads, then theoretically the neutral is not required at the ATS. The three phases provide power for balanced three-phase loads.
277V or 120V Loads
If the new building will have any 277V line-to-neutral loads (lighting is the most common), or if the contractor will derive 120V loads from the 277V/480V panel board (typically via a step-down transformer), then a Neutral is absolutely required. The neutral provides the return path for the unbalanced current from line-to-neutral loads.
Grounding
The ground (G) is always required for safety, regardless of whether a neutral is needed for operation.
Possible Scenarios and Conclusion
Original Contractor Likely Correct
The original contractor likely pulled the neutral because they anticipated the need for 277V or 120V loads in the existing system. This is a common and conservative approach to ensure flexibility for future use.2.
Current Contractor Potentially Wrong
The new contractor may be incorrect in not pulling the neutral, UNLESS they absolutely know that the new building will never have any 277V or 120V loads. This is an unlikely scenario in most commercial buildings.
Recommendation
The best course of action is to clarify the load requirements for the new building. Specifically, ask: "Will there be any 277V lighting or other 277V loads in the new building?" "Will there be any single-phase or 120V loads, requiring a 480V-120/240V or 277V-120/240V transformer in the new building? This is very common."If the answer to either of those questions is "yes," then the new contractor must pull a neutral conductor from the transformer to the new ATS. If the answer to both questions is absolutely "no", then and only then, would it be acceptable to not pull a neutral to the new ATS.
Important Note
Code compliance requirements also depend on the application and jurisdiction.
NEC 250.24(C) Location of Main Bonding Jumper
If the transformer serving the building is located outside the building, NEC 250.24(C) requires that the grounded conductor (neutral) be run to the building and bonded. This applies to separately derived systems.
In summary, it is highly probable that the new contractor is wrong and needs to pull a neutral conductor. You should confirm the load requirements of the new building to make the final decision. Flag for review