Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: What would happen

User: OK Sparky 93, Location: Iridea14Strat

Asked on: Thursday, August 7, 2025 at 11:31 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, August 7, 2025 at 11:32 am EDT

Question: I've been doing this a little over 30 years. I must say that a lot of things are muscle memory. It is the way you were told it was supposed to be. Just pass the inspection! Maybe no one could really explain, or took the time, just do it.Education is never a bad thing! Getting ready to order Mike's grounding and bonding book.Anyway, two scenarios. at least.1) Suppose we have a sub panel, and everything is proper. Utility loses a neutral, and at the same time you have a ground fault. Breaker wouldn't trip. Is there a potential unsafe situation?2)The same exact situation minus an EGC.? And if in this situation, someone bonded the enclosure to the grounded conductor. I would think fault or no fault, if utility loses a neutral this could potential be a bad situationWhat could be ramifications from not bonding enclosure at the main?I ran onto one yesterday that has been that way for the last 20 plus years. New HO's. did the previous ever experience any issues? IDK!

You've hit on some very important scenarios that highlight the necessity of proper grounding and bonding in electrical systems. Let's break down each case

Scenario 1: Sub Panel - Proper Grounding/Bonding, Lost Utility Neutral, Ground Fault
The Setup

Properly wired subpanel with separate neutral and ground bars. EGC (Equipment Grounding Conductor) properly connected back to the main panel.


The Event

Utility loses its neutral and a ground fault occurs on a circuit in the subpanel.

The Outcome

This is
potentially unsafe, but the EGC should mitigate the danger. Here's why:

Lost Neutral Complications

The lost neutral means the subpanel neutral is now floating. Voltage imbalance can occur between phases, potentially damaging sensitive equipment. The neutral-to-ground voltage on the load side of the service can rise significantly.

Ground Fault Path

The ground fault now has a path back to the source
through the EGC and the grounding electrode system at the main panel. This path should have low enough impedance to allow sufficient fault current to flow, tripping the breaker.

The "Should"

The success of the breaker tripping depends on several factors:

Impedance of the Fault Path

If the EGC path back to the main panel has high impedance (e.g., loose connections, undersized conductor), the fault current might be insufficient to trip the breaker quickly.


Breaker Sensitivity

Is the breaker working correctly? Is it a standard breaker, a GFCI breaker, or an AFCI breaker? A GFCI breaker would provide a much quicker response to even small amounts of current imbalance between the hot and neutral.

Why it's still risky

Even with proper grounding, the elevated voltage on the neutral can still cause problems. Also, relying solely on a standard breaker to trip in a low-impedance ground fault condition isn't foolproof.

Scenario 2: Sub Panel - No EGC, Lost Utility Neutral, Ground Fault, Enclosure Bonded to Neutral
The Setup

Subpanel with NO EGC run back to the main panel. The subpanel enclosure is improperly bonded to the neutral bar.

The Event

Utility loses its neutral
and a ground fault occurs.

The Outcome

Extremely dangerous. Here's why:

Ground Fault Path

When a ground fault occurs, the fault current now has a path back to the source through:
The metallic enclosure of the subpanel The bond to the neutral bar in the subpanel The neutral conductor back to the service entrance.

Elevated Enclosure Voltage

Because the enclosure is bonded to the neutral, and the neutral is now floating at a high voltage due to the lost utility neutral, the entire enclosure becomes energized. Anyone touching the enclosure becomes part of the fault current path.


No Reliable Overcurrent Protection

The fault current might not be high enough to trip the breaker quickly (or at all) because the neutral conductor is not designed to carry fault current like an EGC. The resistance of the neutral conductor and its connections will also limit the fault current.

Lethal Shock Hazard

This situation creates a significant and prolonged shock hazard.

Ramifications of Not Bonding Enclosure at the Main Panel
Elevated Touch Voltage

If the enclosure isn't bonded to ground at the main panel, it becomes a potential floating electrode. If a fault occurs within the panel, the enclosure will become energized relative to true earth ground. Anyone touching the enclosure and a grounded object will receive a shock.

Inadequate Fault Current Path

Without a proper bonding connection, there's no low-impedance path for fault current to flow back to the source. This means breakers might not trip quickly, increasing the duration and severity of a shock hazard.


Stray Voltage

Even without a fault, stray voltage can appear on the enclosure if it's not bonded, especially in areas with high electrical noise or nearby power lines.

Risk of Corrosion

Bonding helps to equalize the electrical potential between different metal components of the electrical system. Without bonding, stray currents can cause galvanic corrosion.

Why Might They Not Have Experienced Problems Before?


That's the scary part of electrical safety. The absence of an immediate problem doesn't mean the system is safe. Some reasons why they might not have noticed issues:
Luck

They may have simply avoided situations where a ground fault occurred at the same time as a lost neutral.

Low-Draw Loads

The neutral currents might have been low enough that the effects of the floating neutral weren't dramatic enough to cause obvious problems.


Unnoticed Damage

Over time, the voltage imbalances caused by the lost neutral could have slowly damaged appliances and equipment without them realizing the root cause.

Higher Resistance to Earth

Depending on the earth's resistivity and where other equipment grounds were installed, the panel and grounded objects may have had similar resistances to ground, minimizing the potential difference (voltage) between the panel and the earth.

In Conclusion


Your observations are spot on. The scenarios you describe highlight the critical importance of proper grounding and bonding. Here are some key takeaways:
EGCs are Essential

Always install an EGC to subpanels.

Neutral and Ground Separation

Always keep the neutral and ground conductors separate in subpanels. Bond ONLY at the service entrance (main panel).


Bonding is Key

Ensure that all metal enclosures and other conductive parts of the electrical system are properly bonded together and to the grounding electrode system at the main panel.

GFCI/AFCI Protection

Consider using GFCI and AFCI breakers for added protection, especially in older homes or in potentially hazardous areas.


Education is Crucial:
Continue to expand your knowledge of electrical safety codes and best practices. Mike Holt's books are excellent resources.You're doing the right thing by questioning the "just do it" mentality and focusing on understanding the underlying principles. Electrical safety is a serious matter, and a thorough understanding of grounding and bonding is essential for protecting people and property. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question