Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Overcurrent protection for incoming feeders and compliance with NEC225.31

User: kwn, Location: USA

Asked on: Thursday, August 7, 2025 at 3:03 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, August 7, 2025 at 3:07 pm EDT

Question: We have a customer owned transformer at a gas Compressor site, so primary metering applies. The service disconnect will be a fused disconnect switch in the primary circuit between the utility meter and the transformer. This disconnect switch will be located about a half mile from the transformer, and close to the utility meter (pole mounted) at the station entrance road. The secondary of the transformer will feed an electrical building (MCC) that's located approx 400 ' away. A generator (with circuit breaker) and an automatic transfer switch will be located near the transformer, with the automatic transfer switch feeding the electrical building from either the generator or the transformer (utility).We'd like to make sure we have the proper protection for the feeder conductors running from the transformer to the transfer switch, and then from the transfer switch to the electrical building, while also meeting the requirements of NEC 225.31: Disconnecting means.Since the service disconnect is already located in the primary circuit of the transformer, I believe the transfer switch does not have to be "service entrance" rated, and so is not required to include a circuit breaker (for the utility power from the transformer).The generator already includes a circuit breaker, that will protect the conductors from it to the transfer switch. These conductors have less current capacity than the conductors from the utility transformer.My question then is if we install an incoming feeder circuit breaker in the electrical building (MCC), will this breaker protect both the incoming conductors from the transfer switch to the electrical building (MCC) and the conductors from the transformer to the transfer switch ? Does the fact the Transfer switch and transformer are approx 400' away affect code compliance for this ?Or should we instead install a circuit breaker in the transfer switch (and not in the electrical building/MCC) to protect the conductors from the transformer to the transfer switch and from the transfer switch to the electrical building (MCC), which is 400' away. If we do it this way, will we need to install a disconnect switch in the electrical building (MCC) for the incoming feeder conductors ? or will the breaker in the transfer switch qualify as the disconnect switch for the feeders into the electrical building (MCC) under NEC 225.31 ?Would appreciate any comments on this.

Okay, this is a multi-faceted design question with several considerations. Let's break it down step-by-step

Understanding the Situation
Primary Metering

The utility owns and meters the energy on the primary side of the transformer. This is key, as it fundamentally changes the requirements downstream.


Remote Service Disconnect

The service disconnect is on the primary side, near the meter and far from the transformer.

Transformer to Transfer Switch to MCC

The utility power flow is: Transformer -> (400') -> Transfer Switch -> (400') -> MCC


Generator System

Generator provides backup power, with its own breaker protecting the conductors from generator -> transfer switch.

Goal

Protect feeder conductors from transformer to transfer switch and transfer switch to MCC while meeting NEC 225.31 (Disconnecting Means).

Analysis and Recommendations
1. Transfer Switch as "Service Entrance" Equipment

You are correct. Because the service disconnect is on the
primary side (utility side) of the transformer, the transfer switch does not need to be service entrance rated. This removes the requirement for a main breaker within the transfer switch itself for the utility source.2.

Feeder Protection from Transformer to Transfer Switch to MCC

This is your primary challenge. You need to ensure proper overcurrent protection for
all conductors between the transformer secondary and the MCC. The 400' distance plays a crucial role here. You have two options:

Option A: Breaker in the MCC Only
Install a appropriately sized circuit breaker in the MCC to protect the conductors from the transfer switch to the MCC, as well as the conductors from the transformer to the transfer switch. Challenge

Code Compliance NEC 240.21(B)(1)(1): Feeder Taps Not Over 10 ft Long. This section cannot be applied for the protection of the feeder conductors from the transformer to the transfer switch because they are 400' in length. NEC 240.21(B)(2): Feeder Taps Not Over 25 ft Long. This section cannot be applied for the protection of the feeder conductors from the transformer to the transfer switch because they are 400' in length. NEC 240.21(B)(3): Feeder Taps Supplying a Transformer. This section cannot be applied for the protection of the feeder conductors from the transformer to the transfer switch because the feeder conductors are not supplying a transformer. NEC 240.21(B)(5): Feeder Taps Over 25 ft Long. This section cannot be applied for the protection of the feeder conductors from the transformer to the transfer switch because the overcurrent device at the termination of the conductors must be sized according to the ampacity of the conductors, and there would be no overcurrent device at the transfer switch. Therefore,

this option is not code compliant
because the feeder conductors between the transformer and the transfer switch (400' away) cannot be adequately protected by a breaker in the MCC alone, 400' away. Option B: Breaker in the Transfer Switch Install a appropriately sized circuit breaker in the Transfer Switch to protect the conductors from the transformer to the transfer switch and from the transfer switch to the MCC. Install a disconnecting means in the MCC. Advantages

Better feeder protection for the long run between transformer and transfer switch.

NEC 225.31 Compliance

The breaker in the transfer switch
cannot serve as the disconnecting means required by NEC 225.31 for the MCC building. NEC 225.31 requires a disconnecting means to be installed at or near the point of entrance of the feeder conductors in the building.

Disconnecting Means Requirement

You will need a separate disconnecting means (e.g., a fused or non-fused disconnect switch, or a circuit breaker) within or immediately adjacent to the MCC to satisfy NEC 225.31.
3.


Conductor Sizing

Regardless of which option you choose, ensure conductors are sized properly for the load and are protected per NEC 240.4. You must also consider voltage drop over the 400' runs, especially with motor starting loads.

Recommendation


Based on the distances and the need for code compliance, Option B (Breaker in the Transfer Switch + Disconnecting Means in MCC) is the preferred solution.In summary, my recommendation is


Install a circuit breaker within the transfer switch
rated to protect the feeder conductors running from the transformer to the transfer switch and from the transfer switch to the electrical building/MCC. The conductors from the transformer to the transfer switch are approximately 400' in length and need this protection.2. Install a disconnecting means (switch or breaker) at or near the point of entry of the feeder conductors into the MCC. This satisfies NEC 225.31. It doesn't have to be a circuit breaker; a fused disconnect switch is also acceptable.
3. Ensure proper conductor sizing and voltage drop calculations. This is critical for reliability, especially with motor loads.4. Coordinate the overcurrent protection: Make sure the breaker in the transfer switch and the disconnecting means/breaker in the MCC are properly coordinated to avoid nuisance tripping.Consult with a qualified electrical engineer familiar with NEC requirements in your jurisdiction to finalize the design and ensure compliance with all applicable codes and regulations. They can perform load calculations, voltage drop analysis, and select the appropriate overcurrent protection devices. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question