User: ptonsparky, Location: NE (9.06 miles @5.9 Degrees from Winged Horses)
Asked on: Thursday, August 14, 2025 at 11:38 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, August 14, 2025 at 11:38 am EDT
Question: I have several motors <=15HP that never run at the same time but I would like to get feedback when each does. The output goes to a plc. Not high accuracy requirement but it does initiate a shut down when parameters are exceeded. I would monitor one phase of each motor after its starter. Is there a reason I should not do this?
Monitoring one phase of each motor after its starter to detect if the motor is running is a common and generally acceptable practice, especially given your requirements of non-simultaneous operation and moderate accuracy with shutdown initiation. However, it's crucial to consider potential drawbacks and ensure proper implementation.Here's a breakdown of the reasons why it's generally okay, and what to watch out for
Reasons why it's generally acceptable:
Simple and Cost-Effective
It's a straightforward approach that usually requires minimal hardware (current transformers or voltage sensors, depending on the chosen method).
Clear Indication of Running Status
If the motor is drawing current, it's highly likely it's running. The absence of current indicates it's not.
Suitable for Shut-Down Triggering
The on/off signal is generally reliable enough to initiate a shutdown sequence when parameters exceed limits (though you will need to define these parameter limits).
Non-Simultaneous Operation
The fact that the motors never run simultaneously greatly simplifies the monitoring. You don't have to worry about current overlaps or misinterpretation of aggregate current values.
Potential Drawbacks and Considerations
False Negatives
Open Phase
A blown fuse on a different phase before the starter could leave the monitored phase with no current, even if the motor is trying to run. This would give a false "off" signal, preventing your PLC from detecting a potential problem.
Very Light Load/No Load
If the motor is running but drawing very little current (e.g., idling), your current sensor might not detect enough current to register it as "on." Consider your current transformer or sensor selection to account for this.
Mechanical Failure
If there is a mechanical issue causing the motor to be slow or stalled, but it is not sufficient to trip the starter, the motor may be running but not drawing enough current to be reliably detected.
False Positives
Leakage Current
Depending on the wiring and environment, there might be a small amount of leakage current that could be misinterpreted as the motor running. This is rare but possible.
Sensor Noise
Electrical noise or interference could trigger a false positive.
No Fault Detection
This method only detects if the motor is powered. It doesn't provide information about motor health, overload conditions, overheating, or other potential problems.
Harmonic Distortion
High levels of harmonic distortion in the power system could affect the accuracy of your current or voltage measurements. Consider using true RMS sensors if harmonics are a significant concern.
Sensor Selection
Current Transformers (CTs)
Good for detecting current flow but need to be sized correctly. Too small, and they will saturate; too large, and they will be insensitive to small currents. Make sure the CT has a suitable burden resistor to convert the current into a voltage signal.
Voltage Sensors
Can detect the presence of voltage on the phase.
Wiring and Safety
Proper wiring and insulation are crucial for safety. Working with motor circuits can be dangerous. Ensure that qualified personnel perform the installation.
PLC Programming
The PLC logic should be robust enough to handle potential noise or glitches in the signals. Consider adding filtering or hysteresis to the PLC input signals.
Maintenance
Regularly inspect the sensors and wiring to ensure they are in good condition and functioning correctly.
Recommendations and Best Practices
Choose the Right Sensor
Carefully select the current transformer or voltage sensor based on the expected motor current/voltage range, accuracy requirements, and the type of signal the PLC accepts. Consider a "true RMS" meter for greater accuracy.2.
Proper CT Sizing
Size the CT so that the primary current range corresponds to the expected motor current. The secondary current is typically 5A or 1A. Choose a CT with a VA rating high enough for the secondary burden (resistance) you will use. Don't open circuit the secondary of a CT while current is flowing in the primary, or very dangerous voltages will be induced.3.
Proper Wiring and Termination
Use appropriate wiring and terminals. Ensure secure connections to prevent loose connections and signal degradation. Use shielded cable for sensor signals to minimize noise.4.
PLC Input Filtering
Implement digital filters in the PLC program to smooth out the input signals and reject noise.5.
Hysteresis
Add hysteresis to the PLC logic to prevent chattering (rapid on/off switching) due to minor current fluctuations. For example, the motor is considered "on" if the current exceeds 5 amps and "off" if it drops below 2 amps.6.
Test and Calibrate
Thoroughly test the system after installation to ensure it's working correctly. Calibrate the sensors if necessary.7.
Safety Precautions
Always follow proper safety procedures when working with electrical equipment.8.
Consider Overcurrent Protection
If not already in place, consider using current monitoring relays (more sophisticated than simple CTs) that can detect overload conditions and trigger alarms or shutdowns. These can give more granular information about motor health.9.
Consider a Soft Starter or Variable Frequency Drive. If there is not one in place. Inrush Current can lead to false positives.
Alternatives
Smart Motor Protectors/Relays
These devices monitor various motor parameters (current, voltage, temperature) and provide more comprehensive protection and diagnostics.
Power Meters
Measure voltage, current, power, and energy consumption. Provide a more detailed view of motor operation but are more expensive.
In conclusion:
Monitoring one phase after the starter is generally acceptable if* you address the potential drawbacks and follow best practices. Given that your motors never run simultaneously and that the primary goal is to initiate shutdowns when parameters are exceeded, this is a reasonable approach. However, carefully consider the factors mentioned above and choose the solution that best meets your specific needs and budget.Always prioritize safety and consult with qualified electrical professionals. Flag for review