Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Generator Size Vs. Service Amperage

User: smithjo30, Location: Wisconsin

Asked on: Thursday, August 14, 2025 at 3:57 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, August 14, 2025 at 4:20 pm EDT

Question: Hello all,I have a Waste Water Treatment Plant that has an 800A 3 Phase 480V service, and they currently only have a 180 kW Generator backing up a 300A MCC. The are other circuits that are fed from a 800A Main Circuit Breaker. The plant wants whole plant backup. Does my generator size need be as big as the system amperage or only as big as the existing load calculations, and adding roughly 40% for future growth?The calculations I ran on the plant came up to needing a 348.42 kW size generator, times by 40% = 487.79.487.79 kW = 586.72 AMPSWould a 500 kW generator be sufficient in this scenario?

Okay, let's break this down step-by-step to determine the appropriate generator size for your wastewater treatment plant's whole-plant backup needs.

Key Considerations


Code Compliance

The National Electrical Code (NEC) is paramount. Article 700 (Emergency Systems) and Article 701 (Legally Required Standby Systems) will dictate many of the requirements for generator sizing, transfer switches, and wiring methods. Also, you'll need to comply with local codes and AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction) requirements. Consulting a qualified electrical engineer familiar with the NEC and local regulations is crucial.2.

Load Calculations are Key

You are on the right track with your load calculations. The NEC Article 220 is used for calculating load.3.

Demand Factors

Understand that the connected load (the sum of all nameplate ratings) is almost always higher than the actual load. Demand factors allow you to reduce the calculated load based on the likelihood of all equipment running at full capacity simultaneously. Wastewater treatment plants often have significant motor loads, and understanding the starting characteristics of those motors is crucial (see below).4.

Motor Starting

Motors, especially large ones, draw significantly higher current during startup (inrush current) than their running current. This is critical for generator sizing. The generator must be able to handle the inrush current without excessive voltage dip, which can cause other equipment to malfunction.5.

Future Growth

Your 40% allowance for future growth is prudent. It's better to slightly oversize the generator than to be undersized in a few years.6.

Fuel Type

The type of fuel (diesel, natural gas, propane) affects the generator's output capabilities and operating costs. Diesel is generally the most reliable for emergency power, but natural gas may be more readily available and have lower emissions in some locations.7.

Generator Ratings

Generators have different ratings (prime, standby, continuous). For whole-plant backup in a wastewater treatment plant, you'll likely need a standby or prime rated generator, depending on the specific requirements of your local codes. Standby ratings are typically higher than prime ratings but are only intended for use during outages. Prime ratings are more conservative and allow for continuous operation at a specified load factor.

Analyzing Your Situation



Current Service

800A, 480V, 3-Phase. This is the capacity of your utility connection,
not necessarily the demand.

Existing Generator

180kW backing up a 300A MCC. This implies that not all of the plant's loads are currently backed up.

Your Load Calculation

348.42 kW. This is your
calculated load before applying any margin for future growth.

Future Growth Adjustment

348.42 kW 1.40 = 487.79 kW. This is your calculated load with a 40% margin for future growth.

Amps Equivalent

487.79 kW is approximately 586.72 Amps (at 480V, 3-phase). Your math is correct there.

Is a 500 kW Generator Sufficient?
Maybe, but highly unlikely. While 500 kW is close to your calculated load with future growth, it doesn't account for motor starting inrush. Here is where you would need to determine your Largest motor, and then multiply by 6-7x. Motor Starting Concerns

Wastewater treatment plants typically have large pumps and other motor-driven equipment. The inrush current during motor starting can significantly exceed the generator's continuous rating, causing voltage dips that could damage equipment or prevent motors from starting.

Derating

Some generators may need to be derated based on altitude or ambient temperature.


Generator Efficiency

Generators are not 100% efficient. The fuel input required to produce 500 kW of electrical output will be higher.

Recommendations and Next Steps


Detailed Load Study

Conduct a very detailed load study. Don't just rely on nameplate data. Use a power logger to measure the actual demand over a representative period (at least a week, ideally longer). This will give you a more accurate picture of your plant's actual load profile and peak demand.2.

Motor Starting Analysis

Perform a motor starting analysis. Determine the largest motor load and calculate its inrush current. Work with a generator vendor to ensure the selected generator can handle the inrush without unacceptable voltage dips. Soft starters or variable frequency drives (VFDs) can help reduce inrush current.3.

Consult with a Qualified Electrical Engineer

This is non-negotiable. An engineer experienced in generator sizing and wastewater treatment plants can help you: Accurately calculate your load, including demand factors and motor starting requirements. Select the appropriate generator size and type. Specify the correct transfer switch(es). Ensure compliance with all applicable codes and regulations.* Design the electrical system to safely and reliably connect the generator to your plant.4.

Consider a Load Management System

A load management system can shed non-critical loads during generator operation to reduce the overall demand and prevent overloading the generator. This is especially useful during motor starting.5.

Get Quotes from Reputable Generator Vendors

Provide the vendors with your load study and motor starting analysis. Ask them to provide detailed proposals that include generator size, type, fuel consumption, noise levels, and warranty information.

Likely Scenario

Given the factors outlined above, it's highly probable that you will need a generator larger than 500 kW to provide reliable whole-plant backup. A generator in the 600-800 kW range is a more realistic possibility, but this will depend on the specific details of your plant's load profile and motor starting characteristics.

In summary: While your initial calculations are a good starting point, a more thorough analysis, particularly focusing on motor starting and code compliance, is essential before making a final generator selection. Consulting with a qualified electrical engineer is crucial.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question