User: 82angelfan, Location: Hesperia, Ca
Asked on: Thursday, August 14, 2025 at 6:03 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, August 14, 2025 at 6:10 pm EDT
Question: Architect specced out the cheaper see through exit signs that you can see through. Now fire marshal is wanting back side covered to avoid confusion. Makes sense to me. Has anyone tried black out film for this?Sexond question, my inspector keeps asking if exits are dual circuit. I tell him they are on generator with the rest of the egress lights.Am I going to have an issue? Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety.
Let's break down both of your issues
1. See-Through Exit Signs and Blackout Film
The Problem
The fire marshal is right. See-through exit signs, while aesthetically modern, can cause confusion in an emergency. People on the "back side" might see the letters reversed, distorted, or think it's an entrance rather than an exit. The primary goal is clear, unambiguous exit guidance.
Blackout Film – Yes, it's an Option, BUT... Code Compliance is Key
The most important thing is that any modification to a listed (UL, etc.) exit sign must maintain the sign's listing and intended performance. Adding blackout film could affect the light output, uniformity, and visibility of the sign, potentially voiding the listing.
Check the Exit Sign's Documentation
The manufacturer's specifications and installation instructions should be your first stop. See if they explicitly allow or prohibit the use of films. If they prohibit it, you'll likely need to replace the signs.
Professional Installation
If the film is permissible, have it installed by a professional who understands lighting and the relevant codes. They can ensure proper adhesion, avoid air bubbles, and ensure even light distribution. They can also measure light output to ensure it still meets code requirements after the film is applied.
Light Output Measurements
After applying the film, measure the light output of the sign. NFPA 101 (Life Safety Code) and the IBC (International Building Code), which Los Angeles likely uses, have minimum light output requirements for exit signs (typically 5 foot-candles on the illuminated surface). The film cannot reduce the light to below these minimums.
Consider Alternatives
Before resorting to film, explore these alternatives:
Paint
A carefully applied coat of matte black paint designed for plastics might be acceptable. Again, check with the sign manufacturer and test the light output afterward. Mask off the illuminated areas meticulously.
Replace the Signs
This is often the simplest and safest solution. Standard, non-see-through exit signs are readily available and relatively inexpensive.
Recommendation
Strongly suggest replacing the signs with standard, non-see-through models. It's the most reliable and code-compliant solution. If replacement is not possible, contact the exit sign manufacturer directly to ask about acceptable methods for blocking the back, and document their response. Get the fire marshal's pre-approval of your chosen method before proceeding.2. Dual Circuit Exit Sign Power in Los Angeles The Issue
Your inspector is asking about dual circuits, which typically means:
Normal Power
The exit sign is normally powered by the building's standard electrical service.
Emergency Power
In the event of a power outage, the exit sign is automatically switched to a separate, independent power source (usually a generator or a battery backup system integral to the sign).
Your Situation
You say your exit signs are on a generator along with other egress lighting.
Potential Problem in Los Angeles (and many jurisdictions)
While a generator can fulfill the emergency power requirement, the inspector might be concerned about the reliability of the generator. Here's why:
Generator Start-Up Time
Generators can take several seconds (or even longer if poorly maintained) to start and come up to full power. During that time, the exit signs (and other egress lighting) would be off unless there's an additional battery backup system integrated into the exit sign itself.
Generator Failure
Generators can fail. A malfunctioning generator leaves you with no emergency power.
Code Requirements (Likely NFPA 101 and/or IBC)
These codes often require instantaneous or near-instantaneous switching to emergency power. A generator alone might not meet that requirement. They often mandate a battery backup for a minimum amount of time (e.g., 90 minutes).
Load Shedding
If the generator powers all emergency systems, a failure in one area could affect the exit signs. A dedicated, self-contained battery backup for each exit sign eliminates that risk.
Likely Corrective Actions
Individual Battery Backup
The most common solution is to use exit signs that have built-in battery backup systems. These signs run on normal power but immediately switch to their internal battery if the normal power fails. They typically provide at least 90 minutes of illumination. This is often the simplest path to code compliance. The generator covers overall egress lighting, and the batteries cover the immediate exit path.2.
UPS System
A UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply) can provide backup power for a group of exit signs, offering faster switching than a generator. This may be a better solution, but has its own problems with longevity, maintenance and initial cost.3.
"Dual Feed" System (Less Common)
It is possible, though less common, for exit signs to be wired with two separate power feeds – one from normal power and one from the generator. However, this system still needs to guarantee a very fast transfer switch and sufficient battery back up to cover potential generator failure or start up.
Recommendations
Consult the Inspector
The best approach is to directly discuss the situation with the inspector. Ask them specifically what they are looking for in terms of emergency power. Get their interpretation of the local codes and the AHJ's (Authority Having Jurisdiction) requirements.
Review Your Plans
Double-check the approved architectural and electrical plans to see what was originally specified for exit sign power. If the plans specified battery backup, you need to comply with the plans.
Document Everything
Keep records of all conversations with the inspector, any code interpretations, and any changes you make to the exit sign system.
Consider an Electrical Engineer
If you're unsure how to proceed, consult a licensed electrical engineer experienced with life safety systems. They can review the codes, assess your current setup, and recommend the best solution to meet the requirements.
In Summary Exit Signs
Don't use blackout film without manufacturer approval. Replace with standard signs if possible.
Dual Circuit/Emergency Power: The inspector is likely concerned about the reliability and immediacy* of the emergency power supply. Exit signs with integrated battery backup are often the easiest and most compliant solution. Talk to the inspector to understand their specific concerns and requirements. Flag for review