User: Casey the Electrician, Location: OH
Asked on: Thursday, August 14, 2025 at 10:18 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, August 14, 2025 at 10:19 pm EDT
Question: Hello all,I am looking at bidding a project with 144 electrical panels in an apartment complex that all need changed. I’m going to look at it for the first time tomorrow. Problem is there will likely only be three wire from the first means of disconnect, the meter bank on the back of the apartment buildings. Does anybody have any good ideas to get equipment grounding from the point where the grounded conductor and the electrode grounding conductor terminate and bond,I don’t know the pipe pathways yet. It could be totally inaccessible, SE cable, it could be piped the whole way. Wire that has sat in conduit for 60 years, probably won’t come out without a lot of damage, even if it comes out at all. I seem to remember an exception somewhere that allows you to run a ground outside of the pipe, which would make life easier. I know there are some instances with liquid type or this is used.I appreciate anyone’s advice.Thank you in advance.
Okay, this sounds like a challenging but potentially profitable project. Dealing with old apartment buildings and grounding can be tricky. Let's break down your options and considerations
Understanding the Problem
Lack of Equipment Ground
Your main problem is the absence of an equipment grounding conductor (EGC) back to the meter bank in many older installations. This is unsafe and doesn't meet current code requirements. The current panels need to be replaced with new ones.
Three-Wire System
Three-wire systems (Hot, Neutral, Hot or Hot, Neutral, Hot) provide power but lack a dedicated EGC, creating a potential shock hazard in case of a fault.
Old Wiring Challenges
You're right to be concerned about the existing wiring. It's likely brittle, potentially asbestos-containing (if the building is old enough), and difficult to pull without damage.
Solutions and Code Considerations
Here's a breakdown of possible solutions, keeping in mind the National Electrical Code (NEC) and safety practices:1. Running a Separate Ground Wire (The Most Likely Solution)
Within the Existing Raceway
If the existing conduit is large enough and accessible, this is ideal. You'd pull in a new EGC (green insulated wire) along with the existing conductors.
Challenge
As you mentioned, pulling new wire through 60-year-old conduit is often difficult or impossible. Use pulling compound and consider the condition of the existing conductors.
Externally to the Raceway (The Article 250.130(C) Exception You Mentioned)
NEC 250.130(C)
This section allows for the use of an equipment grounding conductor run separately from the circuit conductors in specific circumstances. Crucially, it states: "For replacement of existing branch-circuit and feeder equipment only, and where the equipment grounding conductor is not required to be installed in the raceway with the other conductors..."
Practical Application
This is often the best option for your scenario. You can run a properly sized bare or insulated copper wire (check NEC Table 250.122) along the outside of the existing conduit or cable run, securing it at regular intervals.
Termination
This ground wire must be securely connected to: The grounding electrode conductor (GEC) at the meter bank (where the neutral is bonded to ground). This is usually at the main service disconnect. The grounding bar in each new panel.
Pros
Avoids the major headache of pulling through old conduit.
Cons
Aesthetics, potential for physical damage to the external ground wire (though properly securing it mitigates this), and you need to ensure a very solid connection at the meter bank and each panel.
Important
Check with your local inspector! They have the final say on interpretations.2.
Metal Conduit as the EGC
If the entire run from the meter bank to each panel is continuous, electrically sound metal conduit (rigid metal conduit [RMC], intermediate metal conduit [IMC], or electrical metallic tubing [EMT] with proper fittings), and all connections are tight and corrosion-free, the conduit itself can act as the equipment grounding conductor.
Challenge
This is very unlikely in an old apartment building. Conduit often has breaks, loose fittings, corrosion, or is not consistently metal throughout the entire run. You cannot rely on it without thorough inspection and testing.
Testing
You would need to perform a ground impedance test to verify the integrity of the conduit as a grounding path.3.
Creating a New Grounding Electrode System
This involves driving ground rods (or installing other approved grounding electrodes) near each building and bonding them together and back to the meter bank's grounding electrode conductor.
Pros
Potentially improves overall grounding.
Cons
Very expensive, requires significant digging and disruption, and may be difficult due to underground utilities. Likely overkill unless the existing grounding system is demonstrably inadequate.4.
GFCI Protection (As a Supplemental Measure, Not a Replacement for Grounding)
GFCI (Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter) protection can be added to the circuits feeding the panels. GFCIs detect small current leaks to ground and quickly shut off the power, reducing the risk of shock.
NEC Considerations
GFCIs are REQUIRED in many locations (bathrooms, kitchens, outdoors, etc.). They do NOT eliminate the need for proper grounding, but they provide an additional layer of safety, especially where grounding is compromised or questionable.
Practical Application
You might consider using GFCI circuit breakers in the new panels to provide enhanced safety. You could even use GFCI receptacles in the first outlet of each circuit downstream from the panel.
Cost
GFCI breakers are more expensive than standard breakers.
Before Bidding: Essential Steps1. Thorough Site Survey
Map the Existing System
Carefully document the existing wiring pathways, conduit types, and condition of the electrical system.
Identify Conduit Runs
Determine if the conduit is continuous metal, and if so, its type and condition.
Check Grounding at the Meter Bank
Inspect the grounding electrode conductor (GEC) at the meter bank. Is it in good condition? What type of grounding electrodes are used (ground rods, water pipe, etc.)?
Assess Accessibility
Determine how accessible the conduit runs are for pulling new wire.
Look for Hazards
Be aware of potential asbestos or other hazardous materials.2.
Consult with Your Electrical Inspector
Discuss Your Proposed Solutions
Get their feedback on your grounding plan before you bid. They can tell you what they will accept and what they won't. This is the most important step to avoid surprises later.
Clarify Local Requirements
Local jurisdictions may have specific requirements that go beyond the NEC.3.
Consider Permitting and Inspections
This project will definitely require permits and inspections. Factor in the costs and time involved.4.
Pricing
Material Costs
Accurately estimate the cost of new panels, circuit breakers, grounding wire, conduit (if needed), connectors, GFCI breakers (if used), and other materials.
Labor Costs
Account for the time it will take to remove the old panels, install the new panels, run the grounding wire, and make all connections. Factor in the difficulty of working in confined spaces and dealing with old wiring.
Contingency
Add a contingency to cover unexpected problems (e.g., damaged wiring, unforeseen obstructions, asbestos remediation). 10-20% is typical for projects like this.
Overhead and Profit
Include your overhead costs (insurance, vehicle expenses, etc.) and your desired profit margin.
Key Takeaways Safety First
Prioritize safety throughout the project. Wear appropriate PPE, use properly insulated tools, and de-energize circuits before working on them.
NEC Compliance
Ensure that all work complies with the latest edition of the NEC and any applicable local codes.
Document Everything
Keep detailed records of your work, including wiring diagrams, grounding connections, and inspection reports.
Communication: Maintain clear communication with the building owner or manager throughout the project.By thoroughly assessing the situation, consulting with your inspector, and planning carefully, you can submit a competitive bid and complete this project successfully. Good luck! Flag for review