Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: HVAC SCCR

User: Rock86, Location: new york

Asked on: Saturday, August 16, 2025 at 2:09 pm EDT
Answered on: Saturday, August 16, 2025 at 2:14 pm EDT

Question: Situation: Mechanical engineer sent a cut sheet for a temporary chiller. Voltage, load calc, and OCP all checked to be compatible. The cut sheet says the SCCR is 5kA. I ran an available fault current calculation and the result was over 12kA. I went to my mechanical engineer to discuss this with him and he said that no electrical engineer in his 25 years has ever mentioned a concern for SCCR.Do I have a valid point telling him the SCCR is underrated for the electrical condition, or am I misunderstanding SCCR vs AFC?Note: I am not talking about the AIC rating.

You are absolutely correct, and you have a valid, critical point to raise. The mechanical engineer's experience doesn't negate the code requirements and safety implications. Here's a breakdown of why you're right, and how to explain it

Understanding the Issue:
SCCR (Short-Circuit Current Rating)

This is the maximum
prospective short-circuit current that a component or piece of equipment can safely withstand without catastrophic failure. It's a rating assigned by the manufacturer based on testing. If a fault current exceeds the SCCR, the equipment could explode, catch fire, or otherwise fail dangerously.

Available Fault Current (AFC)

This is the maximum amount of current that your electrical system can deliver at a specific point (like the connection point for the chiller) during a short circuit. It's calculated based on the utility's supply, transformer impedance, conductor size/length, and other factors in your system.

Why You're Correct


Code Compliance (NEC Article 110.10)

The National Electrical Code (NEC) mandates that equipment must have an SCCR equal to or greater than the available fault current at the equipment's terminals. This is a fundamental safety requirement. The exact wording may vary slightly depending on the year of the NEC you are using, but the principle remains the same.2.

Safety Hazard

Connecting equipment with a 5kA SCCR to a system with a 12kA AFC is a significant safety hazard. If a short circuit occurs, the chiller is likely to fail violently, potentially causing injury or property damage.3.

Liability

As the electrical engineer, you have a responsibility to ensure the electrical system is safe and code-compliant. Ignoring this SCCR issue puts you and your company at risk.

How to Explain to the Mechanical Engineer


Focus on Safety

Start by emphasizing the safety implications. "The SCCR is about protecting people and equipment from the dangers of a short circuit. If the fault current exceeds the SCCR, the chiller could explode or catch fire, posing a risk to anyone nearby."2.

Explain the Difference (Simply)

"The SCCR is like the 'breaking point' of the chiller. The available fault current is how much force our electrical system will apply during a short circuit. We need to make sure the 'breaking point' is higher than the 'force'."3.

Cite the NEC

"The National Electrical Code (NEC) requires us to ensure that the SCCR of equipment is equal to or greater than the available fault current at its terminals. [Quote the relevant section of NEC 110.10 if possible, but don't get bogged down in details initially]."4.

Offer Solutions (Collaborate)

Don't just point out the problem; offer solutions. This shows you're a team player:

Option 1: Ask for a Chiller with a Higher SCCR

"The easiest solution is to find a chiller with an SCCR of 12kA or higher. Can you check with the supplier to see if a suitable model is available?"


Option 2: Current Limiting Devices

"We could potentially install a current-limiting fuse or circuit breaker upstream of the chiller. This would reduce the available fault current at the chiller's terminals to below 5kA. However, this would add cost and complexity, and we'd need to ensure coordination with the rest of the electrical system." This is your likely answer if you can't get a chiller with a higher SCCR.



Option 3: Series Ratings (Carefully)

While sometimes possible, series ratings should be approached with extreme caution and ONLY done if
specifically listed by the equipment manufacturer. DO NOT assume a series rating without manufacturer documentation. Series ratings involve using upstream protective devices to enhance the SCCR of downstream equipment.5.

Documentation

Document everything. Keep records of your conversations, your fault current calculation, the chiller cut sheet, and any proposed solutions. This is essential for liability protection.6.

Escalate if Necessary

If the mechanical engineer remains dismissive, escalate the issue to a supervisor or project manager. This is a critical safety concern and needs to be addressed.

In summary

You are 100% correct. You are not misunderstanding anything. The fact that the mechanical engineer hasn't encountered this before doesn't mean it's not a valid and critical concern. Your responsibility is to ensure the electrical system is safe and code-compliant, and that includes verifying the SCCR of equipment is adequate for the available fault current.

Important Considerations



Temporary vs. Permanent

Even though it's a temporary chiller, the SCCR requirements still apply.

Coordination Study

If you're considering current-limiting devices, a coordination study is essential to ensure they properly protect the chiller and don't cause nuisance tripping elsewhere in the system.


Manufacturer's Instructions: Always follow the chiller manufacturer's instructions and recommendations regarding electrical connections and protection.Your diligence is commendable. By addressing this issue proactively, you're preventing a potentially dangerous situation and fulfilling your ethical and professional obligations as an electrical engineer. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question