Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 220.87 Determining Existing Loads

User: JohnHess, Location: North East US

Asked on: Saturday, August 16, 2025 at 8:31 pm EDT
Answered on: Saturday, August 16, 2025 at 8:33 pm EDT

Question: I believe that the residential load calculations we perform are very bloated. Sometimes they can limit what we can install for the homeowner or cause them to spend unnecessary money on service upgrades or load management products. Instead of submitting load calculations with my electrical permit applications I would like to submit 1 year of the actual maximum demand data because I know that will be much lower and more accurate than the load calc.My question is what the "maximum demand" is, exactly. Our area is served by a very large PoCo and is mostly smart meters now, so I assume that data will be available thru their website. But I am not sure exactly what form it needs to be in to tell me the average load in place of the VA number I get when doing a load calculation.

You've hit on a common frustration among electrical contractors: load calculations can indeed be conservative and potentially overestimate the actual demand on a residential electrical system. Using actual demand data is a smart move if it's accepted by your local authorities.Let's break down "maximum demand" and how to use it effectively

What is Maximum Demand?

Maximum demand is the largest amount of power used by a building over a specified time interval during a given period. It's not the instantaneous peak in power usage. Instead, it's an averaged power usage over a short period, such as 15 minutes, 30 minutes, or an hour. This averaging is crucial. Demand vs. Instantaneous Load

Imagine a microwave oven. It might draw 1500 watts for a few seconds when it starts up. That's an instantaneous peak. However, it likely cycles on and off during the cooking process. The
demand for that microwave during a 15-minute interval might only be 500 watts, reflecting the average power draw.

Why Averaging Matters

Averaging smoothes out short-term peaks and gives a more realistic picture of how the electrical system is stressed over time. Utilities use demand readings for billing purposes (demand charges) and to plan for grid capacity.

What form should the data take to get the equivalent of a VA value?
kWh over a Fixed Interval

This is the most common format. The utility meter will record the amount of energy used (in kilowatt-hours, kWh) during a set interval (e.g., 15 minutes, 30 minutes, or 1 hour). You'll need to know the interval length.


kW (Kilowatts)

Often, the utility will directly calculate and provide the demand in kilowatts (kW) for each interval. This is derived from the kWh reading. For example, if you used 0.25 kWh in a 15-minute interval, that's equivalent to a demand of 1 kW (0.25 kWh / 0.25 hours = 1 kW).

VA (Volt-Amps)

While the load calculation is in VA, what you need from the utility is kW. You can then convert kW to kVA by using the formula:kVA = kW / Power Factor

Finding Maximum Demand Data from Your Utility
1. Contact the Utility

The easiest way is to directly contact your utility's customer service or technical support department. Explain that you need a year's worth of maximum demand data for a specific residential address for electrical permitting purposes. Ask specifically:
What data is available (kWh, kW, or possibly even kVA)? What is the interval length (15 minutes, 30 minutes, 1 hour)? How can you access the data (online portal, report request)? How do they define and calculate "demand?" Is there a specific format the permitting authority requires?2.

Check the Utility's Website

Many utilities now offer online portals where customers can view detailed energy usage data, including demand information. Look for sections like "My Usage," "Energy Insights," or "Smart Meter Data."3.

Data Format

The data will likely be in a CSV (comma-separated values) or Excel format. Each row will represent a time interval, and one of the columns will contain the demand value (kWh or kW).

Interpreting the Data and Finding the Maximum
1. Yearly Maximum

Once you have the data, sort it by the demand value (kW) in descending order. The highest value in the entire year is your maximum demand.2.

Convert kW to kVA (If Necessary)

You'll need to estimate or obtain a reasonable power factor for the residence. Residential power factors are typically in the range of 0.85 to 0.
95. If you don't have a specific power factor, using 0.9 is a generally accepted and conservative assumption. `kVA = kW / 0.9` (assuming a power factor of 0.9)


How to Present This to the Permitting Authority
1. Consult with the Authority

Before you submit anything, talk to the electrical inspector or the permitting department. Explain that you want to use actual demand data instead of a load calculation. Ask: Will they accept this approach? What specific data do they require (format, time period, power factor assumptions)? Do they have any specific guidelines or a form you need to use?2.

Prepare a Report

Create a clear and concise report that includes: Property address and description. Dates covered by the data (full year). Source of the data (utility name and account number). A table showing the date and time of the maximum demand (kW). The calculated kVA (explaining the power factor assumption). A brief explanation of why you believe the actual demand data is more accurate than a load calculation in this case.

Important Considerations and Potential Challenges
Historical vs. Future Load

The historical data reflects
past usage. The permitting authority will want assurance that the new load you're adding won't push the demand significantly beyond the historical maximum. You may still need to estimate the additional demand from the new equipment and demonstrate that the service is adequate.

Seasonal Variations

Be aware of seasonal peaks. Heating in winter or air conditioning in summer can significantly impact demand. Ensure the data covers these peak periods.

Changes in Occupancy/Usage

If the household has changed its usage patterns significantly in the past year (e.g., new occupants, major appliance changes), the historical data may not be representative of current or future demand.


Utility Data Accuracy

While rare, errors in utility data can occur. Double-check the data for any obvious anomalies.

Legality

The utility must be legally allowed to give this data to you. They may require written permission from the homeowner.


Code Compliance

Even if you provide demand data, you still need to comply with other code requirements related to safety, grounding, etc. Demand data primarily addresses service capacity.

In summary:
Obtaining and using maximum demand data can be a powerful tool for more accurately sizing electrical services. However, it's crucial to work closely with your local permitting authority and utility to ensure your approach is acceptable and meets all requirements. Communication and transparency are key. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question