Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: To ground a generator or not to ground a generator. That is the question

User: focalpoint11, Location: Flagstaff

Asked on: Saturday, August 16, 2025 at 9:03 pm EDT
Answered on: Saturday, August 16, 2025 at 9:59 pm EDT

Question: can someone answer a question about grounding generators that has been concerning me for a while now. I've looked into the code book, I have paid for mikes system online (all the videos and books I purchased) Ive watched his YouTube videos including MikeHolt.com/aux. Maybe I'm just slow, but I have the determination. I can't figure out a couple things, using a portable generator with a transfer switch that is (separate from generator) that switches the neutral (separately derived system) can I run a grounding electrode conductor from the generator frame lug to the existing main electrical service grounding system (ground rod) and if not, why? And also why does the code say (if I'm reading it right) you do not drive a ground rod to ground the generator and you use the existing grounding system (ground rod) for a non separately derived system(no neutral switching). Also, what is the purpose or difference of using a system that doesn't switch the neutral and a system (transfer switch) that does switch the neutral or a non separately derived system or separately derived system. Can you please give me some help. Thank you

Okay, let's break down the portable generator grounding conundrum and address your specific questions. This is a common point of confusion, and the language in the NEC can be dense.

Understanding Separately Derived Systems (SDS) vs. Non-Separately Derived Systems

The key to understanding the generator grounding rules lies in distinguishing between these two types of systems. The difference comes down to whether the generator neutral is connected (bonded) to the generator frame, and whether your transfer switch switches the neutral conductor. Separately Derived System (SDS)



Definition

An electrical system whose power is derived from a source that is electrically independent of other wiring systems. The generator's neutral is bonded to the generator's frame (usually via a bonding jumper inside the generator). This means the neutral conductor is intentionally connected to ground at the generator.

Transfer Switch

Crucially, the transfer switch

MUST
switch the neutral conductor. This is because you only want the neutral bonded to ground at one location in the electrical system. Switching the neutral prevents parallel neutral paths and circulating currents. Why Neutral Switching is Important

If the neutral were not switched in an SDS, when the generator is running, the neutral would be bonded to ground at both the generator and the main service panel. This creates a parallel path for neutral current, which can overload conductors, cause nuisance tripping, and potentially energize metallic enclosures, creating a safety hazard.

Non-Separately Derived System (Non-SDS)



Definition

The generator's neutral is NOT bonded to the generator frame. The neutral conductor from the generator is connected directly to the neutral bar in your main service panel, and your transfer switch does not switch the neutral.

Neutral Connection

The neutral is only bonded to ground at the main service panel.


Less Common

Non-SDS configurations are less common because many portable generators come from the factory with the neutral already bonded to the frame.

Answering Your Specific Questions
1. "Using a portable generator with a transfer switch that is (separate from generator) that switches the neutral (separately derived system) can I run a grounding electrode conductor from the generator frame lug to the existing main electrical service grounding system (ground rod) and if not, why?"No, you should NOT run a grounding electrode conductor (GEC) directly from the generator frame lug to the existing ground rod at the main service panel when using a transfer switch that switches the neutral. This is based on the 2023 NEC, but will hold true for older NEC versions too. Here's why: It violates the principle of a Separately Derived System

The point of switching the neutral is to isolate the generator's neutral-to-ground bond from the main service's neutral-to-ground bond. Adding a GEC between the generator frame and the main grounding system essentially creates a parallel neutral path.


The proper grounding method for a separately derived system is to bond the generator's frame (which is already bonded to the neutral) to the equipment grounding conductors that run WITH the circuit conductors (hot and neutral) from the generator to the transfer switch.


This is typically done by a properly sized equipment grounding conductor (EGC) that is run from the generator to the transfer switch, in the same conduit/cable with the power conductors (hot and neutral).2. "Also why does the code say (if I'm reading it right) you do not drive a ground rod to ground the generator and you use the existing grounding system (ground rod) for a non separately derived system(no neutral switching)."

Here's a clarification of the code requirements for portable generators: Portable generators (SDS)

NEC 250.34(A) provides three ways to ground a portable generator when the generator supplies equipment by cord and plug:1. The generator can serve as the grounding electrode (no ground rod required) when the generator only supplies equipment connected through cord and plug.
2. If the generator supplies equipment connected through cord and plug and also supplies a structure, the generator may not be used to supply a structure unless the generator is connected to the building's existing grounding electrode system (ground rod). The connections must comply with NEC 250.34(C).
3. If the generator supplies only equipment mounted on the generator or cord-and-plug connected equipment by means of one or more receptacles mounted on the generator, the equipment grounding conductor terminals of the receptacles shall be connected to the generator frame.


Portable generators (Non-SDS)

NEC 250.301. The grounding electrode conductor shall connect the equipment grounding conductor of the generator to the building or structure grounding electrode system.
3.


"Also, what is the purpose or difference of using a system that doesn't switch the neutral and a system (transfer switch) that does switch the neutral or a non separately derived system or separately derived system."
Purpose of Switching the Neutral (SDS)

The primary purpose is to maintain a
single point where the neutral is bonded to ground. This prevents parallel neutral paths, circulating currents, and associated safety hazards (overloaded conductors, shock hazards). SDS systems generally offer a higher degree of isolation and protection.

When you don't switch the neutral (Non-SDS)

The assumption is that the neutral is only bonded to ground at the main service panel. The generator simply becomes an extension of the utility power source, sharing the same neutral-to-ground bond. It's a simpler setup, but it relies on the integrity of the main service's grounding system.

In Summary: The Importance of Following the Instructions


The NEC requires that you follow the manufacturer's instructions for grounding equipment (NEC 110.3(B)). Also, do not modify equipment in the field that is not in accordance with the listing. For these reasons, many electricians will choose to use the method mentioned in NEC 250.34(C) if the generator has a neutral that is bonded to the frame, by running a four conductor system to a transfer switch and using a switch that switches the neutral.

Recommendation1. Review the Generator and Transfer Switch Manuals

The manufacturer's instructions are paramount. They should specify whether the generator is intended to be used as an SDS or non-SDS, and the appropriate grounding methods.2.

Confirm Neutral Bonding

Determine if your generator has the neutral bonded to the frame. If it does, it's designed to be used as an SDS.3.

Choose the Right Transfer Switch:
Select a transfer switch that is compatible with the generator's intended grounding configuration (switches the neutral for SDS).I hope this clarifies the concepts and helps you understand the requirements for grounding portable generators. If you're still unsure, consulting with a licensed electrician is the safest option to ensure your installation is code-compliant and safe. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question