User: RobertCyr, Location: Sycamore, Illinois
Asked on: Monday, August 18, 2025 at 4:12 pm EDT
Answered on: Monday, August 18, 2025 at 4:13 pm EDT
Question: I have a PV roof mount system using a supply side connection at the meter, Milbank. The conduit to the PV disconnect is not calling for a separate ground. The plans essentially call for the neutral to be the neutral and ground. I can not find a code to support this but engineer claims this is standard. I have never seen this "dual" function for the neutral before.
You're right to be skeptical. Combining the neutral and ground (equipment grounding conductor) on the load side of the service disconnect (which your PV disconnect effectively is in this configuration) is a very common cause for alarm. This is generally a violation of the National Electrical Code (NEC) and a dangerous practice.
Let's break down why this is likely problematic and what code sections apply: NEC 250.24(A)(5): Identification of Neutral Conductor
This section generally allows the neutral conductor of a service-entrance cable to be used for grounding equipment when it is used for the service. However, this is only permissable in the main panel (service).
NEC 250.30(A)(1): Grounding Separately Derived AC Systems
While a PV system isn't exactly a separately derived system in the same way as a generator or transformer, it is treated very similarly for grounding purposes. The inverter is the "source" in this case. NEC 250.30(A)(1) explicitly states:> For separately derived systems derived from utility services,
the neutral conductor shall not be used for equipment grounding purposes on the load side of the separately derived system.
NEC 250.6(A): Objectionable Current
This section covers methods to deal with objectionable currents on grounding conductors. Using the neutral as a ground guarantees current flow on the neutral/ground path, which can create many problems. The key is to isolate the grounding path.
Why it's dangerous
Current on Metallic Surfaces
If the neutral carries fault current and is bonded to metallic enclosures (like conduit, junction boxes, inverter chassis), those enclosures become energized with fault current. This creates a shock hazard.
Loss of Neutral
If the neutral connection is lost or becomes loose, all grounded equipment could become energized at the voltage difference between the phase conductor and ground due to the current trying to return to the source through the ground path.
Electromagnetic Interference (EMI)
Shared neutral/ground paths create loops that can radiate EMI, potentially interfering with sensitive electronic equipment.
Improper Operation of Overcurrent Devices
Fault current needs a dedicated, low-impedance path back to the source to trip circuit breakers quickly and safely. A shared neutral/ground may not provide that, delaying or preventing proper operation of overcurrent devices.
Why the Engineer is likely wrong
While some legacy systems incorrectly use the neutral as a ground, this is a very outdated and unsafe practice that is specifically prohibited by the modern NEC. Using the neutral as a ground on the load side of the service is a violation of NEC 250.30(A)(1) and other relevant code sections.
What You Should Do
Request a Formal Clarification from the Engineer
Document your concerns in writing. Ask the engineer to provide the specific NEC code sections that allow this combined neutral/ground configuration on the load side of the service entrance point for the PV disconnect. Politely but firmly state that you're unable to proceed with the installation as designed because you believe it violates the NEC.2.
Contact the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)
If the engineer insists that this is acceptable and provides dubious justification, contact your local building inspector or electrical inspector before proceeding with the installation. They have the final say on whether an installation meets code. Provide them with a copy of the plans and your concerns.3.
Correct the Design
The proper solution is to run a dedicated equipment grounding conductor (EGC) from the PV disconnect back to the service entrance equipment. This EGC must be separate from the neutral. The neutral should only be used as a current-carrying conductor and not be bonded to any metallic enclosures on the load side of the service.
In summary, your concern is valid. The plan as described is likely in violation of the NEC and could create a serious safety hazard. Do not proceed until you have a clear, documented justification from the engineer that complies with the NEC, and confirmation from the AHJ if necessary.* Flag for review