User: mannyb, Location: Florida
Asked on: Monday, August 18, 2025 at 6:59 pm EDT
Answered on: Monday, August 18, 2025 at 6:59 pm EDT
Question: I visited an apartment complex today. The build had 8 units being served by 2-250a main breaker panels. 4 units per panel. The apartments had emondmons and the old fashion glass meter monitoring power consumption for utilities not ones provide by utilities. These apartments at one point was all utilities paid.The customer wants to separate the 4 units for each panel into 4 separate panels, one for each unit and monitor. What would be the best way to approach the customer with a solution?
Okay, let's break down the situation and craft a solution to present to your customer. The goal is to provide individual metering for each of the 8 apartments to track consumption of utilities they will now be paying for directly.
Understanding the Situation
Existing Setup
2 Main Panels (250A each) - Each panel serves 4 apartments. Currently, the building is all utilities paid. Old glass meters/Emons are already in place, they will be re-purposed for individual unit metering
Customer Goal
Individual metering for each apartment. Separate panels for each apartment.
Challenges & Considerations
Panel Space
Finding suitable locations for 8 new panels (4 per original panel). Space is always a constraint in existing buildings.
Wiring Capacity
Ensuring the existing wiring from the main panels to each apartment is sufficient for the load.
Cost
This can be a significant project. Keeping the solution cost-effective is important.
Disruption
Minimizing disruption to tenants during the installation.
Code Compliance
All work must meet current electrical codes.
Load Calculation
This is paramount. An electrical load calculation for each unit is necessary.
Future Proofing
Consider if the customer might want to add more load (e.g., EV chargers) in the future and if the new panels can accommodate this.
Proposed Solution Options (with explanations)
Here's how I would present a few options to the customer, highlighting the pros and cons of each:
Option 1: Traditional Panel Upgrade & Sub-metering Description
This is the most straightforward approach, involving installing individual panels for each apartment.1.
Load Calculation
Perform a detailed load calculation for each apartment based on anticipated usage. Include typical loads (lighting, appliances, HVAC) and potential future loads. This is the most important step.2.
Panel Selection
Select appropriately sized sub-panels for each apartment based on the load calculation. Consider 100A or 125A panels as a starting point, but this is completely dependent on the load calculation.3.
Wiring Upgrade (Possibly)
Determine if the existing wiring from the main panel to each apartment is sufficient for the new sub-panel load. If not, new wiring will need to be pulled.4.
Installation
Install the new sub-panels in a suitable location near each apartment. Run wiring from the existing main panel to the new sub-panel. Connect the existing apartment wiring to the new sub-panel. Install new breakers in the new sub-panels.5.
Metering
Re-Purpose the existing emondom or glass-style meters and connect it to each individual sub-panel.6.
Labeling
Clearly label all panels, breakers, and wiring for easy identification.
Pros
Cleanest electrical separation between apartments. Easiest to understand and maintain. Provides the most individual control and circuit capacity for each unit.
Cons
Highest cost (labor and materials). Potentially requires the most physical space. Could involve the most disruption to tenants. Possible costly wiring upgrades, depending on existing capacity.
Option 2: Sub-metering Only (More Cost-Effective, but less flexibility)
Description
This option avoids adding entirely new panels but uses sub-meters to track individual apartment usage. It re-purposes the existing emondons/glass-style meters for individual unit metering.1.
Load Calculation
Still necessary to confirm the existing panel capacity is adequate for all units.2.
Sub-meter Installation
Install a meter base with sub-meter in line with the main wiring in a central location within the apartment.3.
Wiring
May require some re-wiring within the existing panels and the apartment to properly connect the sub-meters.4.
Breaker Allocation
Ensure breakers are clearly labeled and dedicated to each apartment.
Pros
Lower cost than installing new panels. Less invasive installation (less disruption to tenants). Potentially less space required.
Cons
Each apartment still shares a panel. Less control and flexibility if a tenant overloads a circuit. Difficult to add new circuits for an individual apartment in the future. Complex re-wiring can be time consuming.
Option 3: Hybrid Approach (Potentially the Best Balance)
Description
Combine aspects of Option 1 and Option 2. Install a new sub-panel in some apartments that require more capacity based on the load calculation, and use sub-metering for the remaining apartments.
Pros
Balances cost and flexibility. Addresses the specific needs of each apartment.
Cons
Requires careful load analysis to determine which apartments need new panels. More complex design and installation.
How to Present to the Customer
Start with Understanding
Begin by re-confirming their goals and priorities. Ask: "What are your key concerns about this project (cost, disruption, long-term reliability, etc.)?" "Do you have any budget constraints in mind?" "Are there any specific tenants that you anticipate will have higher energy needs?"2.
Present the Options
Clearly explain each option, highlighting the pros and cons in the context of their priorities. Use a table format to make it easy to compare:| Feature | Option 1: Full Panel Upgrade | Option 2: Sub-metering Only | Option 3: Hybrid Approach
Cost | Highest | Lowest | Medium ------------------ | ----------------------------- | ---------------------------- | --------------------------
Panel Capacity | Individual | Shared | Mixed Disruption | Highest | Lowest | Medium
Complexity | Moderate | Moderate | High |3. Future Flexibility | Highest | Lowest | Medium
Emphasize Load Calculation
Stress the importance of the load calculation and its impact on panel sizing and wiring requirements. "The most important step is to accurately determine the electrical load of each apartment. This will ensure that the new panels are appropriately sized and that the existing wiring is adequate."4.
Provide a Range of Estimates
Offer a range of estimated costs for each option based on preliminary assessments. Be upfront that a firm quote requires a detailed site survey and load calculation.5.
Suggest a Phased Approach (If appropriate)
If budget is a major concern, suggest a phased approach where you start with one panel and monitor its performance before expanding to the remaining units.6.
Highlight Benefits
Remind the customer of the long-term benefits of individual metering: Fairer utility billing. Encourages tenants to conserve energy. Increased property value.7.
Offer a Site Survey
Conclude by offering a detailed site survey and load calculation to provide a firm quote and customized solution.
Important Notes
Liability
Make sure you have adequate insurance coverage for this type of work.
Permits
Obtain all necessary permits before starting any electrical work.
Documentation: Keep detailed records of all work performed, including load calculations, panel schedules, and wiring diagrams.By presenting a clear, well-reasoned solution with multiple options, you'll demonstrate your expertise and build trust with your customer. Good luck! Flag for review