User: Eeyore's Tail, Location: Tukwila, WA
Asked on: Wednesday, August 20, 2025 at 12:33 am EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, August 20, 2025 at 12:34 am EDT
Question: I got this thrown on my plate and hoping you guys can shed some light as the vast majority of my transformer experience is delta/wye. After reading a few posts stating not to run a neutral with the primary side figured I should head here for some answersI have no single phase loads on the secondary 480v side. Trying to figure out grounding and bonding since normally I’d land my GEC on X0 and bond X0 to the chassis, run neutral as per usual. How does any of this work with a high volt delta secondary?
Okay, let's break down grounding and bonding a Delta-Delta transformer with a 480V secondary, assuming you have no single-phase loads on the 480V side. This is a common scenario.
Understanding the Challenge
Your instinct to ground X0 and bond it is based on grounded wye systems. With a Delta-Delta, you don't have a naturally occurring neutral point like X0 in a wye. This means you need to create a ground reference.
Here are the common methods and considerations
1. Corner Grounded Delta What it is
One phase of the delta (A, B, or C) is directly grounded.
How it works
One of the phases (e.g., phase B) is connected directly to the grounding electrode conductor (GEC), and the enclosure is also bonded to this same point.
Pros
Simple to implement, may be useful for motor control circuits.
Cons
Now one phase (Phase B) is at 0V, while the other two phases are at 480V potential to ground. Creates phase-to-ground voltages of 480V on the ungrounded phases. Difficult to troubleshoot since normal phase-to-ground voltage is a phase-to-phase voltage.
Less common due to safety concerns and troubleshooting challenges. In many areas, it's prohibited for new installations. NEC Article
See NEC 250.26(4) if you MUST use this
2. High-Resistance Grounded Delta (HRG) What it is
A resistor (typically sized to limit ground fault current to a few amps) is placed between one phase and ground.
How it works
The resistor limits the fault current during a ground fault, preventing a high-energy event. The enclosure is still bonded to the GEC.
Pros
Reduces arc flash hazard significantly. Allows continued operation during a single ground fault (first fault). Easier to locate ground faults while the system is energized.
Cons
More complex and requires a dedicated HRG monitoring system to detect and locate ground faults. Requires careful coordination with overcurrent protective devices.
NEC Article
NEC 250.36
Important Notes
You MUST have a monitoring system that alarms on a ground fault. You should have procedures in place to locate and clear ground faults promptly. The resistor value is critical and must be selected based on the system parameters.
3. Ungrounded Delta (Impedance Grounded but NOT High Resistance) What it is
No intentional connection to ground is made.
How it works
The system relies on the distributed capacitance of the conductors to ground.
Pros
Can continue operating with a single ground fault.
Cons
Overvoltages can occur during ground faults due to resonant conditions, leading to insulation failure. Difficult to locate ground faults. Arc flash hazard is still significant.
Generally not recommended, and often prohibited by code in many applications. NEC Article
(Discouraged)
Important Notes
Voltage spikes to 6x normal can occur during transient events
Recommendation: High-Resistance Grounded Delta (HRG) is the best practice
In your situation (no single-phase loads, 480V Delta-Delta), a High-Resistance Grounded (HRG) system is highly recommended for the following reasons: Safety
Significantly reduces arc flash hazard compared to ungrounded or corner-grounded systems.
Reliability
Allows continued operation during a single ground fault, minimizing downtime.
Fault Location
Makes it easier to locate ground faults while the system is energized.
Code Compliance
HRG is a recognized and preferred grounding method in many applications.
Steps for Implementing High-Resistance Grounding (HRG)1. Select a Phase
Choose one phase (A, B, or C) of the 480V delta secondary to connect to the HRG resistor.2.
Install the HRG Resistor
Connect the HRG resistor between the selected phase and the grounding electrode conductor (GEC). The resistor value is critical and must be selected based on the system capacitance to ground. Consult with a qualified engineer or equipment supplier to determine the correct resistor value. Common fault current limits are 5A or 10A.3.
Connect GEC
Connect the grounding electrode conductor (GEC) to the ground busbar in the transformer enclosure. The GEC size is determined by the size of the service conductors (or the equivalent).4.
Bond the Enclosure
Bond the transformer enclosure to the ground busbar in the enclosure using a bonding jumper. This ensures that the enclosure is at the same potential as the ground reference.5.
Install Ground Fault Monitoring
Install a ground fault monitoring system that detects ground faults and provides an alarm. This system is essential for identifying and locating ground faults quickly. The monitoring system typically consists of a ground fault relay, current transformer(s), and an alarm indicator.6.
Coordinate Overcurrent Protection
Coordinate the HRG system with the overcurrent protective devices (circuit breakers or fuses) to ensure proper protection. The overcurrent devices should be sized to protect the equipment and conductors in the event of a ground fault.
NEC Requirements (General) Article 250 (Grounding and Bonding)
This is the primary article for all grounding and bonding requirements.
Article 450 (Transformers)
Contains specific requirements for transformer grounding.
250.20 (Systems to be Grounded)
This outlines when systems are required to be grounded.
250.30 (Grounding Separately Derived AC Systems)
Provides rules for grounding systems derived from transformers. This is a KEY section for your application.
250.162 (Ground-Fault Detection)
(For HRG) Requires ground-fault detection and annunciation for high-resistance grounded systems.
Important Considerations
Engineering Design
This isn't a DIY project. You need to have a qualified electrical engineer design the grounding system, especially if you're implementing HRG. They'll calculate the appropriate resistor value and coordinate the overcurrent protection.
Local Codes
Always check with your local electrical codes and AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction) to ensure compliance. Some areas may have specific requirements.
Documentation
Keep thorough documentation of the grounding system design, including calculations, resistor values, wiring diagrams, and testing results.
Testing
Perform thorough testing of the grounding system after installation to verify its proper operation. This should include insulation resistance tests, ground impedance tests, and functional testing of the ground fault monitoring system.
In Summary
While you can run an ungrounded delta system, it's generally not recommended due to safety and reliability concerns. A corner-grounded delta has limited applications. A High-Resistance Grounded (HRG) delta is usually the best practice for your situation. Consult with a qualified electrical engineer to design and implement the grounding system properly. This is a crucial safety issue. Do NOT proceed without professional guidance. Flag for review