Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Submerged Cables

User: W@ttson, Location: NJ-USA

Asked on: Wednesday, August 20, 2025 at 7:40 am EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, August 20, 2025 at 7:41 am EDT

Question: Hello,Have a project where the contractor has been careless and has left in-ground pull boxes open in an industrial environment during construction. The pull boxes are part of the new work and all of the conductors inside are supposed to be new. The boxes are large cast iron boxes that are supposed to be NEMA 4X rated (think of large junction boxes for street lighting applications). During the last 2 years the boxes have been open and have been getting filled with water and the water has been lingering for the majority of that time. The water is contaminated with oils, dirt, debris, salt (marine environment). The cable insulation is XHHW2.If they pump out the water from these junction boxes would these cables still be fit for continued service?I assume someone will ask what the insulation resistance reading is on the conductors (I don't have that information) - say they let the cables dry and the test comes back above NETA minimums, is there any more that can be done?Are there any guidelines out there with how to handle flooded electrical installations?

This is a challenging situation, and you're right to be concerned. Even if the insulation resistance tests pass, there are potential long-term issues that could lead to failures. Here's a breakdown of the concerns and potential solutions, considering your environment and cable type

Concerns:
Contaminant Absorption

XHHW-2 is water-resistant,
not waterproof. While designed to resist water absorption, prolonged submersion in contaminated water will lead to absorption. The oils, dirt, debris, and especially salt, will exacerbate this process. The XHHW-2 will be damaged from the oil and the salt will begin to permeate through the insulation.

Degradation of Insulation

The contaminants, particularly salt, can chemically attack the insulation over time, reducing its dielectric strength and increasing the risk of breakdown.

Corrosion

Even with XHHW-2, the ends of the conductors exposed in the pull box and any imperfect terminations are susceptible to corrosion from the salty water. This can increase resistance, causing heat and potential arcing.


Capillary Action

Water can wick up the conductors inside the insulation, even if the ends are technically sealed, especially if the cable ends are damaged or not properly sealed.

Sealed Systems

These pull boxes are supposed to be sealed systems to maintain the NEMA 4X rating. If the contractor is leaving them open, the conductors that connect between the pull boxes are also likely filled with contaminated water. This can be difficult to determine without excavating the conductors and finding the lowest point in the system.


Code Compliance

While passing an IR test might seem like compliance, the underlying issue is the compromise of the cable's integrity due to the environment. It's questionable if the installation meets the intent of the NEC (or equivalent local code) regarding proper installation methods and suitable materials for the environment.

Addressing the Situation

A thorough investigation and a risk-based approach are crucial.1.

Documentation is Key

Meticulously document everything: dates of exposure, descriptions of contaminants, photos/videos, cable sizes, pull box locations. Record the type of connections in the pull box (are they standard butt splices or something that should have been potted or sealed?).2.

Inspection



Visually inspect the cable inside the pull boxes

Look for signs of swelling, discoloration, cracking, or any other physical damage to the insulation.


Check Cable Ends

Pay close attention to the cable ends and terminations. Are they corroded? Are the terminations suitable for wet locations?

Pull Box Condition

Are the pull boxes themselves damaged or corroded? Are the covers properly sealing (after the water is removed)?


Verify 4X Rating

Confirm the pull boxes actually are NEMA 4X rated and that the covers are designed to create a watertight seal.3.

Testing



Insulation Resistance (IR) Testing

This is a
minimum. Perform this after the cables have been allowed to dry adequately. Use a calibrated megohmmeter at the appropriate voltage for the cable rating.

Polarization Index (PI) Test

A PI test (IR test performed over 10 minutes and the 10-minute reading divided by the 1-minute reading) provides a better assessment of insulation quality than a simple IR test. It can reveal moisture or contamination that a single IR test might miss.

Dielectric Absorption Ratio (DAR) Test

Similiar to PI, but takes a reading at 30 and 60 seconds.


AC Hipot Test (With Caution)

An AC hipot test can stress the insulation to a higher voltage and reveal weaknesses. However, it can also further damage already compromised insulation. This should only be considered if other tests are inconclusive and with careful consideration of the risks. Never exceed the manufacturer's recommended test voltage.



Laboratory Analysis (If Warranted)

If you suspect significant contamination, consider sending a sample of the cable insulation to a lab for analysis. They can identify contaminants and assess the degree of degradation.4.

Consult with Experts



Cable Manufacturer

Contact the cable manufacturer (with all your documentation) and ask for their recommendations. They may have specific guidelines for handling submerged cables.

Electrical Engineer

A qualified electrical engineer experienced in industrial installations and cable testing is crucial for interpreting the test results and recommending a course of action.


Testing Company

A reputable electrical testing company can perform the necessary tests and provide expert analysis.

Potential Courses of Action (Based on Severity)



Least Severe (IR/PI Passes, Minimal Visual Damage)

Thoroughly clean and dry the pull boxes and cables. Ensure proper sealing of the pull boxes (replace gaskets if necessary). Apply a suitable corrosion inhibitor to the connections. Implement a more frequent inspection schedule to monitor for future problems.

Moderate (IR/PI Marginal, Some Visual Damage)

Replace the cable sections within the pull boxes, along with all terminations. Consider replacing the cable back to the next pull box in each direction. Implement a more frequent inspection schedule.

Most Severe (IR/PI Fails, Significant Visual Damage, High Risk)



Replace all affected cables. This is the most conservative and safest option, especially in a critical industrial environment.
Replace the pull boxes if they are significantly corroded or damaged. Review installation practices with the contractor to prevent future incidents.

Guidelines & Standards



National Electrical Code (NEC) - Article 314

Covers junction boxes, pull boxes, and handhole enclosures. Pay particular attention to requirements for wet locations. While not specifically about flooded installations, it establishes the baseline for proper installation.

IEEE Standards

The IEEE has various standards related to cable testing and maintenance, including standards for insulation resistance testing and cable life cycle management.


NETA Standards

NETA (InterNational Electrical Testing Association) provides standards for electrical testing, including insulation resistance testing. You mentioned this already, but ensure compliance with NETA guidelines for testing frequency and acceptance criteria.

Manufacturer's Recommendations

Always consult the cable manufacturer's specifications and recommendations for installation and maintenance.

Key Takeaways



Don't rely solely on IR tests. They are a snapshot in time and may not reveal underlying degradation.

Err on the side of caution. In a critical industrial environment, the cost of replacing cables is often less than the cost of downtime and potential safety hazards.


Document everything. This is essential for future troubleshooting and liability purposes.

Get expert advice. This situation requires the expertise of qualified electrical engineers and testing professionals.

In summary, while pumping out the water and getting a passing IR test is a first step, it is far from a guarantee that the cables are safe and reliable. A thorough inspection, comprehensive testing, and expert analysis are crucial to make an informed decision about the best course of action.
*Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question