User: JohnHess, Location: North East US
Asked on: Thursday, August 21, 2025 at 1:48 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, August 21, 2025 at 2:02 pm EDT
Question: I have a question about whether this is compliant or not. An inspector failed me for installing a typical “chair lug” in a residential electrical panel. I added this lug because I had to land an EGC and the neutral bar inside of this main panel was absolutely full. It was also behind a birds nest of wires so I didn’t want to try to make room by removing EGC’s and splicing them.I attached a picture below, this is not the installation that was failed, but it illustrates the same exact thing that I’ve done many times in different places.I drilled a hole and tapped it to 10/32 threads using a drill/tap combo.I removed the paint from the area.I used a random brand UL listed lug and held it to the panel with a random brand UL listed green ground screw.The inspector failed it because he said I have to use the ground bar that is listed on the panel’s label.Back when I did commercial work I have used countless random chair lugs in transformers and enclosures and panels, etc.What say you?
Okay, let's break down this situation and see if the inspector's call is valid according to the NEC (National Electrical Code).
Analysis1. Panel Listing
The inspector's main argument hinges on the panel's listing. Electrical panels are tested and listed by organizations like UL (Underwriters Laboratories) as a complete unit. The listing includes specific components, wiring configurations, and instructions. Adding or altering components not specifically called out in the listing documentation can void the listing.2.
Field Modifications and the NEC
NEC 110.3(B) states that "Equipment that is listed, labeled, or identified for a specific purpose shall be installed and used in accordance with any instructions included in the listing, labeling, or identification." This is key. If the panel manufacturer's instructions specifically state that only the provided ground bar is to be used for grounding, and no other grounding points are permitted, then the inspector has a point.3.
Suitability (NEC 110.3(A))
The NEC also requires that all equipment be suitable for the intended use. This means, at a minimum, that the lug and screw you used are UL listed for grounding and of the appropriate size for the conductor you're landing.4.
Integrity of Grounding Path (NEC 250)
The NEC requires a low-impedance ground fault path to facilitate the operation of overcurrent devices. The lug has to be reliably connected to the panel enclosure to provide that path.5.
Common Practice vs. Code Compliance
Your experience in commercial work is relevant, but it doesn't automatically override code requirements. There might have been specific procedures, engineering approvals, or manufacturer guidelines in those situations that made those installations compliant.
Arguments Against the Inspector's Call Lack of Specific Prohibition
The inspector needs to provide evidence that the panel's listing explicitly prohibits additional grounding points. If the instructions don't say anything about adding grounding lugs, the inspector is making an assumption.
Equivalency
You could argue that a properly installed, UL-listed grounding lug, attached to the panel enclosure with a proper screw, provides an equivalent grounding path to the listed ground bar.
Local Amendments
Some jurisdictions have local amendments to the NEC that might affect this issue.
Arguments Supporting the Inspector's Call Potential for Inconsistent Grounding
If not done carefully, field-added grounding points could have higher impedance than the factory-installed bar. This is especially true if the drilling, tapping, and surface preparation weren't perfect.
Voiding Listing
The inspector might be concerned that the addition of the lug voids the panel's listing, which could have liability implications for them and you.
Subjectivity
Even though a properly installed grounding lug should be fine, the inspector has to make a judgment call based on what they see in the field. Unless there's an explicit allowance in the manufacturer's documentation, they can err on the side of caution.
Best Course of Action1. Review the Panel's Listing
Obtain the manufacturer's documentation for the specific panel model and see if there are any statements about additional grounding points. This is the most critical step.2.
Talk to the Inspector
Calmly discuss the issue with the inspector. Ask them to provide the specific code section or manufacturer's instruction that prohibits the installation. Explain your reasoning and the steps you took to ensure a proper grounding connection. Be open to their concerns.3.
Contact the Manufacturer
If the panel documentation is unclear, contact the panel manufacturer's technical support. They can provide an official answer about whether adding grounding lugs is permissible.4.
Consider an Alternative
If the inspector remains firm, and the manufacturer is also against the addition of the lug, then splicing the EGCs together in order to free up some space on the factory provided bus bar may be the path of least resistance.
Important Considerations Conductor Fill
Make absolutely sure that you're not exceeding the conductor fill limits for the panel. Cramming too many wires into the panel is a code violation in itself.
Neat and Workmanlike Manner (NEC 110.12)
The installation has to be neat and workmanlike. This means clean wiring, properly secured conductors, and no hazards.
In Conclusion
The inspector's call is not necessarily wrong, but it's also not necessarily right. It depends on the specifics of the panel's listing, the inspector's interpretation of the code, and the quality of your installation. The best approach is to gather information, communicate with the inspector, and be prepared to make adjustments if necessary.Good luck! Flag for review