Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Stand-Alone SS Circuit Sizing

User: HarrySlother, Location: Iowa

Asked on: Friday, August 22, 2025 at 9:47 am EDT
Answered on: Friday, August 22, 2025 at 9:48 am EDT

Question: Hi guys, having issues sizing the feeder breaker and the wires ahead of a stand-alone soft start. (See picture). SS is going to be provided by others; I'm assuming it will have internal protection. Usually these are in MCCs so I don't have to deal with this.Couple hang-ups:1. Is there a way to size the feeder breaker, other than making it "large" enough that it won't cause nuisance tripping?2. I'm assuming the primary wires need to be protected by the breaker. Is that correct? It just seems silly to have different sizes coming into and out of the soft start.

Okay, let's break down the feeder breaker and wiring for your stand-alone soft starter. It's good you're thinking this through carefully; it's a common challenge when moving equipment outside of a controlled MCC environment.

Understanding the Soft Starter & Its Internal Protection

Your assumption that the soft starter will have internal protection is a good starting point, but absolutely critical to verify. You need to get the specifications directly from the manufacturer of the soft starter. Specifically ask about: Internal Overload Protection

Does the soft starter have overload protection that will trip under motor overload conditions? Does it have thermal overload capability and a CT?


Short Circuit Protection

Does the soft starter have any internal short-circuit protection (e.g., fuses, breakers, or an SCR crowbar system)? This is especially important.



Bypass Contactor

Does the soft starter have a bypass contactor? This changes everything
once the motor is up to full speed.

1. Feeder Breaker Sizing (The "Large Enough" Approach - Refined)You're right; simply making the breaker "large enough" is not a code-compliant or safe practice. Here's a more refined approach based on the NEC (National Electrical Code):


Motor FLA (Full Load Amps)

This is the foundation of your calculations. You must know the motor's FLA. Get it from the motor nameplate or the motor manufacturer's data sheet.

Soft Starter Manufacturer's Recommendations

This is where you MUST start. The soft starter manufacturer will dictate the minimum breaker size for your specific motor and soft starter. Their recommendation will consider the inrush current during starting, the let-through current of the soft starter under fault conditions, and the coordination requirements for the internal protection (if any). This usually takes precedence over generic NEC rules. Many manufacturers provide specific tables for recommended upstream protection based on motor HP and voltage.

Make contact with the soft start vendor.


NEC 430.52 (Motor Short-Circuit, Ground-Fault, and Overload Protection)

This is the general section of the NEC that governs motor protection. However, soft starters often change how you apply this. Here's the catch: The NEC usually allows you to use a higher percentage for the breaker or fuses than the motor FLA for motor starting current. This is how you avoid nuisance tripping. However, the soft starter is supposed to limit the inrush current, so this "higher percentage" may not be needed or allowed by the soft starter manufacturer.

NEC 430.52(C)(1) (Instantaneous Trip Breaker - Inverse Time Circuit Breaker)

Here is a good starting point:
Typically, you can select an Inverse Time circuit breaker (magnetic) such that it trips on 150% to 250% of the Motor Full Load Amps. This would need to be tested on site to verify that the breaker isn't nuisance tripping.

Coordination Study (Highly Recommended for Critical Applications)

For critical applications, especially where downtime is very expensive, a coordination study is
highly recommended. This study ensures that the soft starter's internal protection (if any), the feeder breaker, and any downstream overcurrent devices (e.g., motor overload relays) will operate in a coordinated manner. The goal is to isolate faults quickly and minimize the impact on the rest of the system.

Example

Let's say your motor FLA is 100A. The soft starter manufacturer says the
minimum breaker size is 175A. You should use at least a 175A breaker. You can use NEC 430.52 to decide whether you need to upsize the breaker above the manufacturer's recommendation.

2. Primary Wiring ProtectionYes, the primary wires (those feeding the soft starter)

must be protected by the breaker. This is a fundamental principle of electrical safety. NEC 240.3 requires that conductors be protected against overcurrent in accordance with their ampacity.

Wiring Size and Ampacity



NEC 430.22 (Motor Feeder Conductor Ampacity)

This section typically requires the feeder conductors to have an ampacity of at least 125% of the motor's FLA. However,

the soft starter manufacturer may modify this requirement. They might allow you to size the conductors based on the soft starter's continuous current rating (which could be less than 125% of the motor FLA, especially if there's a bypass contactor).

Different Wire Sizes: The RealityYou're right; it can seem odd to have different wire sizes coming into and out of the soft starter. Here's why it happens and how to deal with it:

Soft Starter Internal Design

The soft starter's internal components (SCRs, etc.) may have a different current-carrying capacity than standard conductors. The output conductors are sized based on the motor load (FLA) and the soft starter's output characteristics.


Voltage Drop

The soft starter might introduce a small voltage drop. This could necessitate slightly larger output conductors to compensate and ensure the motor receives adequate voltage.

Harmonic Content

Soft starters can generate harmonics. The output conductors might be sized to handle the increased heating effect of harmonics.

How to Handle Different Wire Sizes



Terminal Blocks

Use appropriately sized terminal blocks within the enclosure to transition between the feeder conductors and the soft starter input/output conductors.

Wire Connectors

If you need to directly connect wires of different sizes, use appropriate wire connectors designed for the specific wire types and sizes. Make sure they are properly torque.


Neatness

Maintain neat wiring practices. Label all conductors clearly.

Bypass Contactors: A Game ChangerIf the soft starter has a bypass contactor, the situation changes once the motor is up to speed. The motor current is then flowing directly through the bypass contactor and not through the SCRs or other soft starter components. This can allow for smaller conductors to the motor, since they are protected by the feeder breaker, and the soft start is no longer in the circuit.

Key Steps (Summary)


Obtain Soft Starter Specifications

Get all the specifications from the manufacturer, including the recommended breaker size, wiring requirements, and details about internal protection.2.

Calculate Motor FLA

Determine the motor's Full Load Amps.3.

Size Feeder Breaker

Start with the manufacturer's recommendation and verify that it meets the NEC requirements.4.

Size Primary Conductors

Start with the manufacturer's recommendation and verify that it meets the NEC requirements (typically at least 125% of FLA, or as allowed by the manufacturer).5.

Consider a Coordination Study

For critical applications, conduct a coordination study to ensure proper protection and minimize downtime.6.

Proper Installation

Use appropriate terminal blocks, wire connectors, and neat wiring practices.7.

Labeling

Clearly label all conductors and components.

Important Safety Note:Working with electrical equipment can be dangerous. Always de-energize and lockout/tagout equipment before working on it. If you are not a qualified electrician, consult with a qualified professional.Good luck with your project! Let me know if you have any more questions. Provide me with the soft start manufacturer and model, and I may be able to offer more specific guidance. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question