User: smajchrzak, Location: Rochester Ny
Asked on: Friday, August 22, 2025 at 8:39 pm EDT
Answered on: Friday, August 22, 2025 at 8:43 pm EDT
Question: Hello everyone,I'm a licensed electrician out of rochester ny. I'm owner and sole operator and my business is about 2 years old.Im struggling to figure out what to charge for small/quick jobs. My hourly is $90 and I have a $160 minimum. My main problem comes from troubleshooting jobs that I finish quickly. As my skill improves and I get better with my tracing equipment I have found myself fixing issues quicker. For example, today I went to a customers house who lost power in two bathrooms and a bedroom. I found which breaker supplied these areas and threw my tracer on it and found a receptacle in the hallway had the home run and the neutral fell out of the receptacle (yes it was back stabbed). After replacing the receptacle and testing everything i was done in about 35 min. So the bill was $175 before tax.I know thats a good rate for 35 min of work but I just feel like bringing power back to all those rooms is worth more than $175. Id appreciate any input! Thanks in advance!
Okay, this is a common problem for skilled tradespeople, especially as they gain experience and become more efficient. Here's a breakdown of approaches you can consider, along with their pros and cons
1. Stick to Your Minimum and Hourly, But Be Mindful of Customer Perception:
How it works
You keep your $160 minimum and $90/hour rate, and in your example, you round up to the minimum.
Pros
Simple and straightforward. Easily explainable to customers. Consistent pricing.
Cons
Might feel underpriced on very quick fixes. Customers may perceive it as excessive for "just a loose wire." This is your biggest challenge.
What to do
Communication is KEY
Before you start the job, clearly communicate your minimum. Say something like: "My rate is $90 an hour, but I have a $160 minimum for service calls. I'll do my best to diagnose the issue quickly and efficiently."
Emphasize the Value
When explaining the bill, highlight the value you brought: "I was able to quickly identify the problem and restore power to your bathrooms and bedroom in under an hour. A loss of power in multiple rooms like that can be inconvenient and even a safety hazard."
Consider a small material markup
Add a small, fixed percentage (10-15%) onto the price of materials to offset the cost of carrying common items.
Offer a small discount for extremely quick fixes
If it takes less than 15-20 minutes, consider rounding down to the minimum. This creates goodwill. e.g., "I appreciate you calling me in. It was a quick fix, so I'll just charge you the minimum of $160 today."
2. Introduce a "Troubleshooting Fee" + Hourly
How it works
Charge a flat fee for troubleshooting (e.g., $120-$180), regardless of how long it takes to diagnose. Then, add your hourly rate after the troubleshooting fee is covered.
Pros
Better reflects the value of your expertise and diagnostic skills. Customers understand they are paying for your knowledge, not just your time. You are compensated even for quick diagnoses.
Cons
More complicated to explain to customers. Requires a clear, concise explanation. You need to determine the right troubleshooting fee that balances profitability with customer acceptance.
What to do
Clear Explanation
"I charge a troubleshooting fee of $X, which covers the cost of using my diagnostic tools and expertise to quickly locate the source of the problem. Once the issue is identified, my hourly rate of $90 applies for the actual repair work."
Transparency
Break down the bill clearly: "Troubleshooting: $150, Repair Time: 15 minutes ($22.50), Total: $172.
50."
Consider a capped total
If the repair is incredibly fast after the troubleshooting, consider capping the total price at a reasonable amount to avoid looking like you're gouging.
3. Value-Based Pricing (More Advanced)
How it works
You estimate the value of the outcome to the customer, rather than focusing solely on your time. Consider the inconvenience, potential safety hazards, or impact on their daily life. This is more difficult to implement consistently.
Pros
Potentially higher profit margins. Aligns your pricing with the customer's perceived benefit.
Cons
Requires excellent communication and sales skills. Can be subjective and difficult to justify. Risk of overpricing if not done carefully.
What to do
Understand the Customer's Pain Points
Ask questions to understand the impact of the problem. "How long has the power been out? What's been most inconvenient about not having power in those rooms?"
Frame the Value
"I understand the inconvenience of having the power out in the bathrooms and bedroom. I've got the equipment and the know-how to get this fixed quickly and safely for you."
Set a Price Based on Value
Instead of $175, you might say, "To restore power to those rooms and ensure everything is safe, the total cost will be $250." (This is just an example; you need to determine what's appropriate for your market).
4. Job Based Pricing for Specific Troubleshooting Tasks
How it works
Instead of an hourly rate for troubleshooting, create a list of common issues with fixed prices. Example: Troubleshoot circuit breaker tripping issue: $180-$350 Troubleshoot lighting issue: $180-$250 Troubleshoot receptacle issue: $160-$250
Pros
Clear and predictable pricing for both you and the customer. Can be more profitable for quick fixes.
Cons
Requires careful planning and accurate pricing. May be difficult to account for all possible scenarios. Need to stick to pricing, even if the job turns out to be very quick.
Key Considerations and Recommendations
Your Market
Research what other electricians in Rochester, NY, are charging for similar services. Don't be the cheapest, but be competitive.
Your Expenses
Accurately calculate all your business expenses (insurance, vehicle, tools, marketing, etc.) to ensure your pricing is profitable.
Customer Service
Excellent communication and a professional demeanor are crucial, no matter which pricing method you choose.
Transparency
Always provide a clear, written estimate or explanation of your pricing before starting the work.
Online Reviews
Encourage satisfied customers to leave positive reviews.
Focus on Long-Term Relationships
Building trust and rapport with customers leads to repeat business and referrals.
In your specific example, here's what I'd suggest
Start with Option 1 (Minimum and Hourly) but focus on your communication. Explain the value of your prompt service and expertise.2. Consider moving towards Option 2 (Troubleshooting Fee + Hourly) as you become more confident in explaining it to customers. Test it out on a few jobs and see how it goes.3. Longer term, analyze all your jobs. Look at how long troubleshooting takes you for different issues, and consider Job Based Pricing.
Ultimately, the best approach is the one that you're comfortable with, that accurately reflects the value you provide, and that is profitable for your business. Don't be afraid to experiment and adjust your pricing as needed. Good luck! Flag for review