Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Question / Opinions on 600.5

User: SparkyAdam, Location: Oregon

Asked on: Sunday, August 24, 2025 at 4:19 pm EDT
Answered on: Sunday, August 24, 2025 at 4:20 pm EDT

Question: So we are doing a bunch of new sign installations in existing commercial bank buildings all over our state (OR). The new signs are LED and have an absolutely tiny load on them, as most LED signs do these days.In reading 600.5, it seems to require these be installed on a dedicated circuit, but it also kind of is worded in a way that leads you to believe it is more for commercial new construction, which i would understand as the load of the sign would not necessarily be known, and it's not like it adds a lot of cost if the walls are all open anyway. But this just seems not to make a lot of sense in our situation, or really at all anymore if you ask me, LED signs have such a small load these days, its not like back in the day when signs had a really big load, everything is LED anymore and the loads are all really small.Installing these signs as a dedicate circuit will more than quadruple the cost to the customer in some of these installations, while offering no difference in the end result what would you do here? I mean code is code i guess, but it just seems silly to me to charge a customer for a dedicated circuit when the load of the new sign isn't even a single amp.

You've hit upon a common frustration in the electrical world: code compliance versus practical application, especially with rapidly changing technology like LEDs. Let's break down the situation and potential approaches.

Understanding the Code (600.5)

You're right to focus on NEC 600.5 (2023) (or the equivalent section in your state's adopted code). The key phrase is usually something like: "Each sign and outline lighting system shall be supplied by a branch circuit that supplies only that sign or outline lighting system. The branch circuit shall be rated to supply at least 125 percent of the total calculated load of the sign or outline lighting system."Why the Dedicated Circuit Requirement?

The NEC has historically mandated dedicated circuits for signs for several reasons:
Safety

Signs can be exposed to the elements, potentially leading to shorts or ground faults. A dedicated circuit with proper overcurrent protection isolates these issues and prevents them from affecting other critical circuits.

Load Management

Older signs (neon, incandescent) had significantly higher power demands. A dedicated circuit ensured adequate power was available without overloading general-purpose circuits.


Maintenance

Having a dedicated circuit simplifies troubleshooting and maintenance. Technicians can easily isolate the sign's power source without affecting other equipment.

Preventing Interference

In the old days, some sign types could produce electrical interference. A dedicated circuit minimized the chance of that interference affecting other equipment.


Future Proofing

While it seems counterintuitive in your case, the code is written to cover all signs, including those that may have higher power requirements.

Your Situation and the Argument Against Dedicated Circuits

Your argument is valid. Modern LED signs consume minimal power, often less than a standard light fixture. Requiring a dedicated circuit in your scenario seems excessive and adds significant cost without a tangible safety benefit.

What to Do? Options and Considerations

Here's a breakdown of your options, ranging from strict compliance to more pragmatic approaches, along with their pros and cons:1.

Strict Compliance



Action

Install a dedicated circuit for each sign as required by 600.5.


Pros

Absolute code compliance. No risk of red-tagging during inspection.

Cons

Highest cost for the customer. May seem wasteful and unnecessary.2.

Seek an Interpretation from the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)



Action

Contact your local electrical inspector or building department. Explain the situation (low-power LED signs, existing building, cost impact). Ask for a formal interpretation of 600.5 as it applies to your specific project. Important: Get the interpretation in writing.



Pros

Potentially allows you to use an existing circuit. Provides a clear, documented basis for your installation.


Cons

The AHJ may still require dedicated circuits. Takes time and effort. Depends entirely on the local inspector's willingness to be flexible.

What to say

Frame it in terms of safety. "The addition of this sign load to the existing circuit does not compromise safety as the total load including the sign is well below the circuit capacity and code requirements." Also, emphasize that you are using appropriate overcurrent protection and wiring methods.3.

Request a Variance (If Allowed)



Action

Some jurisdictions have a process for requesting variances from specific code requirements. This typically involves submitting a formal application explaining why the variance is justified and demonstrating that safety will not be compromised.

Pros

Potentially allows you to use an existing circuit.


Cons

Can be a lengthy and complex process. No guarantee of approval.4.

Careful Load Calculation and Existing Circuit Evaluation



Action

Thoroughly document the load calculation for the sign (including the 125% requirement). Evaluate the existing circuit's capacity, existing load, conductor size, and overcurrent protection. If the existing circuit has ample capacity and meets all other code requirements, you might (carefully) proceed with adding the sign to the existing circuit.


Pros

Reduced cost. Potentially a reasonable solution if the existing circuit is significantly underutilized.

Cons

Risk of failing inspection if the AHJ disagrees. Requires meticulous documentation. You need to be absolutely sure the existing circuit is suitable and that you can confidently defend your decision.5.

The "Ask Forgiveness, Not Permission" Approach (Use with Extreme Caution)



Action

Install the signs on existing circuits and hope for the best during inspection.

Pros

Lowest initial cost.


Cons

High risk of failing inspection, being forced to redo the work, and damaging your reputation with the customer and the AHJ.

I strongly advise against this approach. It is unethical and potentially unsafe if the circuit is overloaded.

Key Considerations for Any Approach



Documentation

Keep meticulous records of your load calculations, circuit evaluations, and any communication with the AHJ. This will be essential if you face any challenges during inspection.


Safety First

Never compromise safety to save money. Ensure that any installation meets all applicable electrical codes and safety standards.

Professionalism

Maintain a professional relationship with the AHJ. Be respectful and willing to work with them to find a solution that meets both code requirements and your customer's needs.


Written Agreements

Clearly communicate your approach to the customer in writing. Explain the code requirements, the potential cost savings of using an existing circuit (if applicable), and the risks involved. Get their written consent before proceeding.

Grounding

Pay very close attention to grounding requirements. Since the sign is likely exposed to the elements, proper grounding is crucial for safety.


GFCI Protection

Consider GFCI protection for the circuit if the sign is in a damp or wet location.

Recommendation

I would recommend starting with

Option 2 (Seek an Interpretation from the AHJ). This is the most responsible approach. Explain the situation clearly and respectfully, and see if you can reach a mutually agreeable solution. If the AHJ insists on dedicated circuits, then you'll have to comply or explore options 3 or 4.

Example Scenario (How to Present to the AHJ):"We are installing new LED signs at [Bank Name] locations throughout the state. These signs have a very low power consumption – typically less than [X] amps. We are finding that the requirement for dedicated circuits under NEC 600.5 is adding significant cost to these projects without a corresponding increase in safety, as the existing circuits have ample capacity. For example, at [Specific Branch Address], we have a [Circuit Breaker Size] amp circuit with an existing load of [Existing Load] amps. The new sign will only add [Sign Load] amps, bringing the total load to [Total Load] amps, well below the 80% continuous load requirement. We are using appropriate wiring methods and overcurrent protection. We would like to request an interpretation as to whether we can utilize existing circuits in these situations, provided that the total load remains within code limits and safety is not compromised."Good luck! Remember to document everything. Let me know if you have any other questions. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question