Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: smart thermostats with internal relays

User: g-and-h_electric, Location: northern illinois

Asked on: Monday, August 25, 2025 at 3:25 am EDT
Answered on: Monday, August 25, 2025 at 3:26 am EDT

Question: As the electrician for an hvac shop I have been running into incompatibility issues with "add a wire " kits and smart thermostats.The kits the shop sends out with the install crew are from IO hvac controls. Their instructions (yes I read them) clearly state that their product is incompatible with thermostats using triacs to control the hvac equipment. I have rewired several systems with 8 conductor wire, and these were easy ones (fish wire from furnace and make no new holes). Sooner or later my luck will run out.I know the Honeywell T6 PRO wifi has relays. Does anyone know for sure if any others do? I know for sure ECOBEE uses triacs. Lacking that Are there any known "add a wire" kits that will work with a non relay smart stat?Howard

You're smart to be proactive about this. The "add-a-wire" kit incompatibility is a real headache, especially with the increasing popularity of smart thermostats. Here's a breakdown of thermostats and add-a-wire kit compatibility, plus some troubleshooting tips

Thermostats and Relay vs. Triac Control
Relay-Based Thermostats

These use mechanical relays to switch the HVAC equipment on and off. They are generally more compatible with "add-a-wire" kits because they provide a clean, isolated voltage signal.


Triac-Based Thermostats

Triacs (Triode for Alternating Current) are solid-state switches. They are more energy-efficient and quieter than relays, but they can leak a small amount of current even when "off." This leakage current is what causes problems with some "add-a-wire" kits, especially when the kits rely on voltage sensing to determine which wire is energized.

Known Relay-Based Smart Thermostats (Confirmed or Highly Likely)



Honeywell T6 Pro Wi-Fi

As you know, this is a good option because it definitely uses relays.


Honeywell Home T9/T10 Pro Smart Thermostat

Often uses relays, but double-check the specific model.

Nest Learning Thermostat (3rd Gen and possibly others)

While Nest's documentation isn't explicit, many users and HVAC techs report good results with "add-a-wire" kits, suggesting it's likely relay-based.
However, keep in mind that Nest uses power stealing technology, and you still need to ensure proper power to the thermostat.

Sensi Touch Smart Thermostat

Some models of the Sensi Touch are relay based.

Emerson Sensi Smart Thermostat

Same as above some models relay based.

Important Note

It's
always best to confirm with the manufacturer's specifications or technical support to be 100% sure. Model numbers can change, and manufacturers sometimes switch components without much fanfare. Look for language in the specs about "isolated relay outputs" or "dry contact switching." If you can't find definitive information, call the manufacturer's tech support line and ask specifically.

Add-a-Wire Kits That Might Work with Triac-Based Thermostats
Note: This is a tricky area, and success isn't guaranteed. Use these at your own risk and with careful testing. Fast-Stat Common Maker

This kit is specifically designed to address compatibility issues. It adds a dedicated common wire without relying on voltage sensing. It might work with some triac-based thermostats, but read the fine print and test carefully. Some users have reported success, while others have not. Requires a 24VAC transformer in the furnace.



Ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium/Enhanced with included PEK (Power Extender Kit)

I understand you are aware that Ecobee Thermostats are Triac based, however, they DO have a product included with the Stat to correct the issues.

Troubleshooting Tips and Considerations



Voltage Testing

Before and after installation, use a multimeter to check for voltage between the common (C) wire and the other wires (R, Y, G, W). Even with a triac-based thermostat, the voltage should be near zero when a particular function (heat, cool, fan) is not active. If you see significant voltage on the "off" wires, it indicates a potential issue.

Load Resistor

Sometimes, adding a small load resistor (e.g., 10k ohm, 1/4 watt) between the common (C) and the problem wire (e.g., Y) can help bleed off the leakage current from the triac and allow the "add-a-wire" kit to function correctly.

Be very cautious when experimenting with resistors, and consult with an experienced HVAC technician or electrician. This is more of an advanced troubleshooting step.


Isolation Relay

You could install a separate 24VAC relay that is triggered by the thermostat's triac output. This would create an isolated relay contact for the "add-a-wire" kit to use. This adds complexity but can be a reliable solution.

Consider the HVAC System

The type of HVAC system (furnace, heat pump, boiler) can also influence compatibility. Heat pumps, for example, often have more complex wiring configurations.


Check for Transformer Overload

"Add-a-wire" kits and smart thermostats draw power from the HVAC system's 24VAC transformer. Make sure the transformer has enough capacity to handle the additional load. If not, you may need to upgrade the transformer.

Prioritize New Wire

As you've experienced, running a new 8-conductor wire is the most reliable solution when possible.

Recommendations


Research and Document

Create a spreadsheet or database of known thermostat models and their relay/triac status. Share this information with your install crews.2.

Standardize on a Relay-Based Thermostat (When Possible)

If your shop can standardize on a relay-based smart thermostat like the Honeywell T6 Pro Wi-Fi (or a similar model), it will simplify installations and reduce compatibility issues.3.

Carry Spare Wire

Continue to stock 8-conductor wire for situations where "add-a-wire" kits won't work.4.

Communicate with Install Crews

Train your install crews on the potential incompatibility issues and provide them with troubleshooting guidance.5.

Test Before You Leave

Always thoroughly test the system after installing an "add-a-wire" kit to ensure proper operation.

Disclaimer:
* I am an AI chatbot and cannot provide professional electrical advice. Consult with a qualified electrician or HVAC technician for specific troubleshooting or installation guidance. Incorrect wiring can damage equipment or create a safety hazard. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question