Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Sloppy MA. Electricians

User: Eddie702, Location: Western Massachusetts

Asked on: Thursday, August 28, 2025 at 7:08 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 3, 2025 at 1:29 pm EDT

Question: My late BIL was a builder and wouldn't touch a wire and made sure all his sons knew that he always hired electricians. Sometimes that electrician was me. Wired a few houses for him back in the 80sI owned an old lake front property with him and my sister back in the 80s.After we bought it, I pretty much rewired the whole place. One of the issues with it is it dates to around 1900-1920 and believe it or not some of the outside walls are framed with 2 x 2s and the floor joists are 1 x 6 spaced every foot. Probably should be bulldozed but its lasted 100 years and still standing.Because of the 2 x 2 walls the original wiring was all BX and the receptacles were installed in the floor. I ripped all those out and put them in the walls back in the 80s but you have to use shallow boxes due to the 2 x 2sAt that time 2 #14/2s in a box with a receptacle was ok but tight but it wouldn't pass now, but I ended up with a lot of J boxes in the crawl space below back then.After a few years I had a falling out with my sister and I sold my half to them and when they added stuff they called other electricians.Now that they have both passed on my nephew owns it and asked me to fix a few issues. Good job for an old, retired guy LOLHe had an electrician out last year who installed a light by the back door and a kitchen ceiling light and he tied into the SABC!! xxxHe added a spotlight and a couple of porch lights and he grabbed power from one of the "shallow box receptacles" I had installed in the 80s. After he did this he couldn't get the recpt back in the box with the added wire and wire nuts so he left it half in and half out. Could have added a Wire mold box extension.I found he used sheetrock screws to mount a shallow switch box and put the screws through the back of the box (3/4" wood paneling on the other side so ok) but he grounded the box by wrapping the #14 bare around the SR screw. xxxBut when I looked in the panel he had attempted to install an AFCI breakers on the circuits he extended. OKOne of them much to my surprise had the neutral pigtail from the AFCI not connected and hanging in the air xxxx but I had 120 on the H & N coming off the breaker!!! And the circuit workedI also had continuity between N & G with the wires pulled off the breaker and the Eg disconnected in the panel which is why the circuit 'worked"So I followed the circuit to the end after going through 4 receptacles and came to a SP switch and the wire or load on downstream of the switch is the issue. I disconnected that cable and hooked the breaker up correctly with the pigtail and it worked fine and tested ok.I ran out of time and don't know what the switch feeds (maybe a ceiling fan) my nephew will know so I couldn't contact him so it can wait.One of my points is that many are lazy. With the shallow boxes you end up in a short dirt floor crawl space tracing wire and troubleshooting with a bunch of J boxes down there. Is it fun....NOI didn't care for the crawl space when i was 30 years old and rewiring the place and I care for it less now that i am 72 but I spent the afternoon down there anyhow.

This is a great recounting of your electrical adventures! It's a familiar story of old houses, questionable prior work, and the challenges of keeping things safe and up to code. Here are some thoughts and observations, broken down by topic

General Observations
Respect for Experience

Your experience and the detail you provide shine through. You have a deep understanding of the history of the house, its quirks, and the evolution of electrical codes. This kind of knowledge is invaluable.


The Dangers of DIY (or Inexperienced) Work

The issues you're finding highlight the dangers of electrical work done by those without proper training and knowledge. The "electrician's" work you describe is a recipe for potential fire hazards and/or electric shock.

The Aging Electrician

Your reflections on aging are relatable. Crawl spaces get less appealing as the years go on! Your dedication to getting the job done right, despite the discomfort, is commendable.

Specific Issues
Shallow Boxes and Crowded Conditions

You're right, what was "acceptable" (though never ideal) back in the 80s is often no longer compliant. The modern code is much stricter about box fill calculations. The J-boxes in the crawlspace are a consequence of the shallow boxes, and while not ideal, they were likely a necessary compromise at the time. Modern options like wiremold box extensions or even switching to shallower devices (if possible) could help alleviate some of the crowding.

Grounding with Sheetrock Screws

This is a major red flag. Grounding is critical for safety, and relying on a sheetrock screw for grounding is completely unacceptable. It's unreliable and potentially dangerous. The grounding conductor needs to be connected directly to the metal box.

Floating AFCI Neutral

This is extremely dangerous. The fact that the circuit was "working" with the neutral pigtail disconnected on an AFCI breaker indicates a serious problem (as you correctly diagnosed). The continuity between neutral and ground with the breaker disconnected is a classic sign of a neutral-ground fault, likely downstream, as you discovered. AFCI breakers are designed to detect arc faults and other dangerous conditions, but they can't do their job properly if they're not wired correctly.

Neutral-Ground Fault Troubleshooting

Your troubleshooting approach was spot-on. Isolating sections of the circuit to pinpoint the fault is the correct methodology. The fact that the fault was traced to the wiring beyond the switch confirms the problem lies with that specific cable run.

Code Considerations (Past and Present)
Box Fill

As mentioned, box fill calculations are much stricter now. You have to consider the volume of the box, the number of conductors, the number of devices (receptacles, switches), and any internal clamps or supports. There are charts and formulas in the NEC to determine the maximum allowable fill.


Grounding

The grounding practices you observed are definitely not up to current code. Proper grounding is essential for safety. Equipment grounding conductors (EGCs) must be connected to all metal boxes and devices.

AFCI Protection

The fact that the "electrician" attempted to install AFCI breakers is a good sign (in principle), as AFCIs are required in many circuits now to protect against arc faults. However, as you found, they're useless if installed incorrectly.

Recommendations
Document Everything

Take detailed notes and photos of all the issues you find. This will be helpful for future troubleshooting and for explaining the problems to your nephew.

Prioritize Safety

Focus on correcting the most dangerous issues first (e.g., the grounding issue with the sheetrock screws, the floating AFCI neutral).


Consider Upgrades

While it might be tempting to just "patch" things, consider suggesting to your nephew that he invest in some upgrades. Replacing the shallow boxes with larger ones (if possible), running new wiring where necessary, and ensuring proper grounding throughout the house will improve safety and reliability.

Be Mindful of Age and Accessibility

Don't push yourself too hard. If a task is too difficult or uncomfortable, consider recommending that your nephew hire a younger, licensed electrician to handle it.


Consider a Professional Inspection:
Now that your nephew owns the property, it might be worth having a licensed electrician perform a comprehensive inspection of the entire electrical system. This will identify any hidden problems and provide a roadmap for future repairs and upgrades.Your story is a reminder that experience matters, but so does staying up-to-date with current codes and best practices. Keep up the good work, and be safe! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question