User: SolarSuperstar, Location: Denver, CO
Asked on: Friday, August 29, 2025 at 1:30 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 3, 2025 at 1:31 pm EDT
Question: I am trying to figure out whether I need overcurrent protection for several ATS that I have on a utility scale battery project where I have a sizeable emergency aux load to feed battery HVAC.Situation: I have a local 34.5kV circuit connected to an on-site/project substation feeding several 34.5kV:480V transformers. These transformers have integrated OCPD on the primary that either we or the transformer mfr will spec. The secondary of each transformer, currently without an OCP, will pass through an ATS and hit a 2500A switchboard. The emergency side of the ATS connects to a switchboard with breakers for each ATS. Our current design is to have a breaker in the switchboard downstream of the ATS, but that leaves the ATS unprotected. I'm struggling to find anything in the code (450, 700, 705 etc.) that can help me understand where this OCPD is needed - at the ATS or at the switchgear. The switchgear will be far simpler to implement OCPD within. Any help our guidance would be much appreciated!
Okay, this is a common and important design consideration for critical systems like yours. Let's break down the applicable codes, best practices, and recommendations for OCPD placement, focusing on the ATS protection.
Key Considerations & Code References
Overcurrent Protection Philosophy
The fundamental principle of electrical protection is selective coordination. You want the closest overcurrent device to a fault to trip first, minimizing the impact on the rest of the system. Tripping the upstream device means losing more than necessary, leading to unnecessary downtime.2.
Component Ratings
You need to ensure the short-circuit withstand rating of your ATS is greater than the available fault current at its terminals. This is CRITICAL. If the available fault current exceeds the ATS's withstand rating, it can be catastrophically damaged, even if a breaker upstream trips eventually.3.
NEC 110.9 (Interrupting Rating)
Equipment intended to interrupt current at fault levels must have an interrupting rating sufficient for the nominal circuit voltage and the current that is available at the line terminals of the equipment. Equipment intended to interrupt current at other than fault levels shall have an interrupting rating at nominal circuit voltage sufficient for the current that must be interrupted.4.
NEC 110.10 (Circuit Impedance, Short-Circuit Current Ratings, and Other Characteristics)
The overcurrent protective devices, the total impedance, component short-circuit current ratings, and other characteristics of the circuit to be protected shall be selected and coordinated to permit the circuit protective devices to clear a fault to limit the damage to electrical equipment. This coordination shall be calculated or verified using calculations.5.
NEC 445.12 - Generator Overcurrent Protection: Even though you're using batteries to provide this load, you need to ensure that the characteristics of the batteries' inverter output is within the generator's fault current capability. It's still a generator in that you're generating AC power to provide an alternative source of power to a distribution system.6. NEC 450.3 (Transformer Overcurrent Protection)
While you have primary protection, the secondary protection is ALSO important. 450.3 addresses secondary protection requirements. However, this section is primarily concerned with protecting the transformer itself. It doesn't directly address the protection of downstream equipment like the ATS.7.
NEC 700 (Emergency Systems) & NEC 705 (Interconnected Electric Power Production Sources)
While these sections don't explicitly mandate OCPD at the ATS, they emphasize reliability and proper operation of emergency and interconnected systems. This implicitly demands adequate protection for all components within those systems. Failure of an unprotected ATS could compromise the entire emergency power system.8.
NEC 700.28 addresses coordination of emergency power systems with other systems. Coordination means all the OCPD devices are configured to only shut down the load circuit nearest the fault to leave all the other critical loads running.
Recommendations & Best Practices
OCPD Immediately Downstream of the Transformer Secondary
This is almost a must. The purpose is to protect the transformer conductors from overcurrent as per 240.21. However, the overcurrent is allowed to be at the switchgear depending on the length of the conductors and the tap rules in 240.
21.
OCPD at the ATS Input
This is highly recommended for optimal protection. This will protect the conductors between the ATS and the switchgear.
Reasoning
It limits the amount of conductors from the transformer to the switchgear that are unprotected in case of a fault within the ATS.
Sizing
Size the breaker appropriately for the ATS's continuous current rating and withstand rating.
OCPD at the ATS Output/Switchboard
This is a given, to protect the downstream loads.
Why OCPD at the ATS Input is Preferable (even though it might seem redundant)
ATS is a "Weak Link"
ATSs, while robust, are electromechanical devices with complex control circuits. They are more susceptible to failure than passive components like busbars. An internal fault within the ATS (e.g., contactor failure, control board short) can result in a significant overcurrent event.
Fault Isolation
An OCPD at the ATS input isolates the fault to just the ATS. Without it, a fault in the ATS could trip the upstream transformer secondary breaker, potentially taking down more of your system than necessary.
Higher Withstand Rating
Installing an appropriately sized breaker at the ATS input increases the effective withstand rating of the system. If the breaker's interrupting rating is higher than the ATS's withstand rating, the breaker will clear the fault before the ATS is damaged.
Maintenance & Testing
Having an OCPD at the ATS input simplifies maintenance and testing. You can isolate the ATS for servicing without affecting the upstream transformer.
How to Implement OCPD at the ATS
Fused Disconnect
A fused disconnect switch is a simple and cost-effective solution. Ensure the fuses are sized appropriately for the ATS's continuous current rating and selected to provide adequate short-circuit protection.2.
Molded Case Circuit Breaker (MCCB)
An MCCB offers better flexibility (adjustable trip settings, remote tripping/indication).3.
Integrated ATS with Breaker
Some manufacturers offer ATSs with integrated circuit breakers. This simplifies installation and ensures compatibility.
Your Design Considerations
Available Fault Current Calculation
You must perform a thorough short-circuit study to determine the available fault current at each point in your system, including at the ATS terminals. This will dictate the interrupting/withstand ratings of your OCPD devices.
Coordination Study
Conduct a coordination study to ensure that your OCPD devices are selectively coordinated. This involves plotting the time-current curves of each breaker/fuse to ensure that the downstream device trips before the upstream device for any given fault current.
In Summary:
While you can arguably get away with only the switchgear breaker downstream of the ATS, it's highly recommended to include an OCPD (fused disconnect or breaker) at the ATS input*. This provides a significant improvement in system reliability, safety, and maintainability. Ensure all devices have adequate interrupting/withstand ratings and that the system is selectively coordinated. It will pay for itself in the long run.This detailed response should provide a good starting point for your design review. Consult with a qualified electrical engineer to ensure that your design meets all applicable codes and standards and is appropriate for your specific application. Flag for review