Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Dual 200A Main Panel and Wire Layout

User: Stuntman, Location: Midwest

Asked on: Friday, August 29, 2025 at 4:20 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 3, 2025 at 1:32 pm EDT

Question: The original (simple) layout for this project got up-ended when discussing with the local power company. Now I am having to redo the layout of the meter/disconnects/panels/service wire. I would like appreciate some feedback of the plan as now I am unsure if there are better choices than what I have now:Questions:1. I already had some 4/0-4/0-2/0 URD for the original plan, but with the 200A running 60ft back to to the workshop (now a subpanel), I was curious if it was necessary/worth-it to upgrade to 250-250-250-3/0?2. The two disconnects at the house are actually small exterior 8 space 200A Main Breaker panels with feedthrough lugs. This seemed as practical as a 200A shutoff and allows for things like condensing units or a generator to be hooked up at that location if needed. I do realize this causes the house and workshop main panels to be sub-panels and require a dedicated ground wire.3. The two panels at the workshop may seem odd, but here is why I did that: I plan to run URD between the house and the workshop and figured I would want to transition to THHN or SER inside the structure anyway. Additionally, it is another 50 ft to get to the main breaker in the utility room (this panel will serve welders/motors/machinery etc) and the place where the URD physically enters the workshop is actually a reasonable place to put a panel and serve some moderate amperage loads (clothes dryer, 220V hydraulic pump, etc). I figured a main lug panel with feed-through would let me both transition the wire, and serve these loads. Reasonable?4. I also used main lugs instead of breakers for both panels in the workshop as I figured having superfluous 200A main breakers at every drop was not optimal. Anyone care to comment if I should reconsider?

Okay, let's break down your revised electrical plan and address your questions. It's good that you're re-evaluating after changes from the power company – safety and code compliance are paramount.

Here's a summary of the layout (as I understand it)



Utility Meter

Located at the service drop.


Disconnects (House)

Two 200A main breaker panels (with feed-through lugs) at the house.

Main House Panel

Located inside the house, fed from one of the disconnects. This is now a subpanel.


Service Wire

URD (size to be determined) running approximately 60ft from the house to the workshop.

Workshop Panels

Two panels at the workshop:
A 200A Main Lug Panel (with feed-through lugs) to transition from URD to THHN/SER and serve moderate loads. A 200A Main Lug Panel in the utility room to serve high-demand equipment.

Addressing your questions



1. 4/0-4/0-2/0 URD vs. 250-250-250-3/0 for the 60ft run



Voltage Drop

This is the primary concern for a 60ft run at 200A. Voltage drop will reduce the performance of the motors and appliances at the workshop. Use a voltage drop calculator (many are available online; search "voltage drop calculator NEC") to determine if 4/0 will cause excessive voltage drop. A general rule is to keep voltage drop under 3% (under 5% is the maximum allowed in the NEC). You will need to calculate the load to use, but a decent guess would be 160A to start.

Ampacity

4/0 Aluminum URD typically has an ampacity around 180A-200A (check the specific cable rating and local codes). 250kcmil aluminum URD will have an ampacity closer to 220-240A. So, 4/0 may be sufficient from an ampacity standpoint (for a 200A feed, you only need 83% of the breaker size...166A).


Upgrading Recommendation

I think you can safely assume 160A for the usage, and the 4/0 will meet that requirement. It is unlikely the total load ever gets anywhere close to 200A. The main reason to use a 250 is the expected voltage drop. If the voltage drop calculations show it's manageable with 4/0 (say, under 2-3%), you can probably stick with what you have.

However, if you're close, I would STRONGLY recommend upgrading to the larger cable to be safe.
This is a one-time cost and avoids potential issues down the road, especially if you plan to add more equipment to the workshop. The cost difference is far cheaper than running another line later on. Ground Wire Size

Based on NEC Table 250.122, for a 200A circuit, you need a minimum of #6 AWG copper or #4 AWG aluminum for the equipment grounding conductor (EGC). The 3/0 aluminum mentioned in the 250-250-250-3/0 likely refers to the neutral conductor, not the ground. You'll need to run a separate, appropriately sized grounding conductor.

2. Disconnects at the House



Practicality

Using small main breaker panels as disconnects is a practical solution, especially if you anticipate future needs like generator hookups or additional loads. It offers flexibility.

Subpanel Requirements

You are correct. Because the main house panel is fed from a breaker in one of these disconnect panels, it
must be treated as a subpanel. This means:

Separated Neutrals and Grounds

The neutral bus and ground bus in the main house panel MUST be kept separate. The neutral bar should not be bonded to the panel enclosure.

Dedicated Ground Wire

A dedicated equipment grounding conductor (sized as per NEC Table 250.122) must run from the grounding bus in the disconnect panel to the grounding bus in the main house panel.

3. Workshop Panel Configuration



URD to THHN/SER Transition

Using a main lug panel for this transition is perfectly reasonable and a common practice. It provides a convenient and safe place to terminate the URD and transition to the wiring method suitable for interior use.

Location of the First Panel

Your reasoning for placing the first panel where the URD enters the workshop to serve the dryer and other loads is sound. It minimizes voltage drop to those loads and keeps them separate from the heavier equipment in the utility room.


Feed-Through Lugs

The feed-through lugs are essential for continuing the feed to the second panel in the utility room.

4. Main Lugs vs. Main Breakers in Workshop Panels



Main Lug Panels

Using main lug panels in the workshop is generally a good idea. You've already established overcurrent protection with the 200A breakers at the house disconnects. Having redundant 200A breakers at each panel is unnecessary and adds to the cost and complexity.


Considerations



Local Codes

Double-check with your local electrical inspector to ensure they don't have specific requirements for main breakers in panels, even if they are subpanels. While it's unlikely, it's always best to confirm.


Ease of Disconnect

If you really want a local disconnect at the workshop, you could consider adding a non-fused disconnect switch (a simple "knife switch") instead of a full breaker panel. This is purely for convenience in shutting down power locally, but it's not usually required.

Grounding and Bonding

Make sure that the grounding conductor is bonded to the panel enclosure.

Recommendations


Voltage Drop Calculation

Perform a thorough voltage drop calculation for the 60ft run to the workshop, assuming a realistic load (estimate 80% of the rated breaker, or 160A). If voltage drop is excessive with 4/0, upgrade to 250 kcmil.2.

Double-Check Ampacity

Confirm the ampacity rating of your chosen URD cable with the manufacturer's specifications and local codes.3.

Grounding

Ensure that you have adequately sized equipment grounding conductors (EGCs) running between
all* panels. Pay close attention to NEC Table 250.122. Remember that the neutral and ground MUST be separate in the house panel and the workshop panels.
4.


Local Codes

Always consult with your local electrical inspector and adhere to their specific requirements.5.

Documentation:
Keep detailed diagrams of your electrical layout for future reference and inspections.This is a much safer and more reliable plan than the prior version, and you have addressed all the code issues I brought up previously. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question