User: B677, Location: Florida
Asked on: Saturday, August 30, 2025 at 10:33 am EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 3, 2025 at 1:33 pm EDT
Question: Sorry to beat a resi dead horse but I’ve recently done a third service change with this “not service equipment” variation and third inspector wanted something slightly different than the other twoFirst inspector had me unbond my metal water line because it might be plastic underground. I was simply bonding the metal by the service equipment and had two ground rods already. She said she doesn’t let anyone bond the waterline anymore because it’s a false sense of security. I said that if the inside still has metal this bond in theory might provide a better fault path.Second inspector had me remove bond screw from the “emergency disconnect, not service equipment” effectively leaving that metal case of the disconnect with no fault path (PVC in and out). He tells me I can land the GEC anywhere in or upstream of the service equipment as long as it’s service rated. I took this to mean the GEC can terminate in the Emergency Disconnect, not service equipment - which is service rated but not being used as service equipment in my case. And he agreed (thoughts ?)Third inspector tells me to put the bond screw in the “emergency disconnect, not service equipment” (I agree) and that the bare copper GEC must be extended with an irreversible splice from the emergency disconnect up 18” into the meter enclosureAnyone able to clesrUp with code citations ? I have one I can post relating to the GEC origination location but not sure I’m interpreting correctlyThanks
Okay, let's break down these differing interpretations and see if we can find some clarity with code references. You're right, this "not service equipment" disconnect is causing a lot of confusion.
Understanding the "Not Service Equipment" Disconnect
The root of the problem is how this disconnect is classified. If it's truly not service equipment, it falls under different rules. This is typically installed when a building already has an upstream service disconnect or when there's a generator interlock involved.
Inspector #1: Water Pipe Bonding The Issue
The inspector's concern about plastic underground is valid. You should not use a water pipe as a grounding electrode if there's a chance of it being plastic. This is because it creates a false sense of a grounding electrode when it's not actually connected to earth.
Code Reference
NEC 250.53(A) requires the grounding electrode conductor to be connected to a metallic water pipe when available and in direct contact with the earth for at least 10 feet. If the water pipe is supplemented with a ground rod it will be code compliant, even if part of the water pipe is plastic.
Your Argument
Your argument about providing a better fault path for internal metal piping is correct in theory. If the inside still has metal piping, bonding it can create a lower impedance path to clear faults.
Resolution
The most conservative approach is to not rely on the water pipe as a grounding electrode if you can't confirm 10 feet of underground metallic contact. Use ground rods, concrete encased electrodes (ufer), or other approved electrodes.
Inspector #2: Removing Bond Screw in Disconnect The Issue
Removing the bonding screw from the enclosure is problematic. While the disconnect might not be considered service equipment, it's still a metallic enclosure that needs to be bonded to provide a fault current path.
Code Reference
NEC 250.4(A)(3) requires that "Normally non-current-carrying conductive materials enclosing electrical conductors or equipment...shall be connected together and to the electrical supply source in a manner that creates a low-impedance circuit suitable for clearing overcurrent devices." This means the enclosure must be bonded.
His Point about GEC
His statement that the GEC can land "anywhere in or upstream of the service equipment" is generally true if you're truly dealing with service equipment. The GEC can be connected at any accessible point from the load end of the service drop or service lateral to the service disconnecting means. But if the disconnect isn’t service equipment that’s where things get more complicated
Why it's confusing
The issue with treating the emergency disconnect as service equipment is it would have to be the first disconnect after the meter, which I’m assuming it’s not.
Resolution
The enclosure must be bonded. The question is how to bond it.
Inspector #3: Bonding Screw and GEC into Meter Enclosure The Issue
This is the most confusing, and likely the most correct, but needs more context. He's essentially saying the GEC needs to connect to the service equipment, and he is implying the meter enclosure is part of the service equipment.
Code Reference
NEC 250.24(A)(1) requires that you install a grounding electrode conductor. NEC 250.24(C) permits you to land the GEC at any accessible point from the load end of the service drop or lateral to the service disconnecting means.
Why it's confusing
The terminology of "service equipment" is very vague in practice as the meter enclosure and service disconnect are service equipment in most cases, but depending on the utility’s service design and meter placement, your disconnect could be a subpanel. You would need to consult the utility to know for certain.
The Logic
If the disconnect is not considered service equipment the inspector is likely trying to ensure the GEC is connected to the actual service equipment (in this case the meter enclosure).
Resolution
Extending the GEC into the meter enclosure is a way to ensure it's properly connected to the service equipment. Make sure to comply with the code requirements for GEC sizing and connections.
Key Takeaways and What to Do1. Determine the Status of the Disconnect
Is it truly "not service equipment"? If it's the first disconnect after the meter, it's likely is service equipment, regardless of its intended function. Consult your local utility.2.
Bond the Disconnect Enclosure
The metal enclosure of the disconnect must be bonded. If it's not service equipment, you'll need to run a grounding conductor (equipment grounding conductor, EGC) back to the panel that feeds it. If it is service equipment, then it must have a bonding screw and connection to the GEC.3.
GEC Connection
If the disconnect is service equipment, the inspector's requirement to extend the GEC into the meter enclosure is likely intended to ensure proper connection to the service. If it isn’t service equipment, it would be proper to land the GEC on the service and run an equipment grounding conductor to the enclosure, but not to extend the GEC into the enclosure.4.
Talk to the Inspector
The best approach is to have a clear discussion with the inspector. Ask them to explain their interpretation of the code and why they are requiring specific actions.
In summary, the disconnect enclosure needs to be bonded. How to bond it depends on the utility’s service design, the meter placement, and ultimately the inspectors interpretation of service equipment. Flag for review