User: Grouch, Location: New York, NY
Asked on: Tuesday, September 2, 2025 at 12:03 am EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 3, 2025 at 1:37 pm EDT
Question: Article 440 cover the branch circuits for AC units. I'm looking at an old Mike Holt book, Electrician's Exam Preparation.. 1999 version, reviewing calculations.I attached a picture of one of the pages. Where I circled in red, how come it references section 440.34 to size the AC unit feeder, when article 440 is for AC unit branch circuits only?
You've highlighted a very important point and caught a potential error or at least a point of confusion in that older Mike Holt book. You're correct that Article 440 of the NEC primarily deals with air-conditioning and refrigeration equipment, not just branch circuits. It does cover branch circuits, but it's broader than only branch circuits.
Here's a breakdown of why the book might be referencing 440.34 for feeder sizing (and why it's a complex issue even with that in mind, and how the NEC wording has shifted over time): 440 Scope - Equipment, not only Branch Circuits
While it's true Article 440 deals with branch circuits for AC/Refrigeration, its scope is broader than just the branch circuit. It covers the equipment itself, including the nameplate data that dictates the branch circuit and feeder requirements. The sections within Article 440 provide guidance on the various aspects of installing AC/R equipment including branch-circuit and feeder calculations.
440.34 - "Single Motor-Compressor Equipment"
440.34 in older NEC versions (and still in current versions) directly addresses feeder conductor ampacity for equipment having a single motor-compressor. This is crucial. The feeder supplying an AC unit (which contains a motor-compressor) must be sized to handle the starting and running current of that motor-compressor plus the current of any other loads associated with the AC unit (fans, controls, etc.).
Why It's About the Equipment Data
Feeder sizing for AC units isn't just about the branch circuit OCPD (Overcurrent Protective Device) rating. It's about the specific requirements of the AC equipment as listed on its nameplate. The nameplate provides Minimum Circuit Ampacity (MCA) and Maximum Overcurrent Protective Device (MOCP) or similar ratings (often Largest Operating Current [LOC] and Overload Relay rating). The feeder must be sized to meet or exceed the MCA, regardless of what the branch circuit might be.
Potential Book Ambiguity
The book's phrasing is a bit ambiguous. It's not wrong to reference 440.34 for feeder sizing in this context (especially given that the example is likely for a single motor-compressor unit), but it should emphasize that the starting point for feeder sizing is the equipment's nameplate data as interpreted through Article 440. The feeder isn't just a longer branch circuit; it has to supply the entire load of the equipment.
In summary: The reference to 440.34 in that older Mike Holt book is understandable within the context of sizing a feeder for air conditioning equipment with a single motor-compressor. The book should have been more explicit about the role of the equipment nameplate. Article 440 does apply to the branch circuit, but also to the equipment, which the feeder must serve. The NEC wording has evolved over time, so always refer to the specific edition of the code you're working with.When sizing a feeder for air conditioning equipment:1. Start with the equipment nameplate.
2. Identify the Minimum Circuit Ampacity (MCA) and Maximum Overcurrent Protective Device (MOCP) or related information (LOC, Overload).3. Use Article 440, and specifically relevant sections like 440.34, to determine the required feeder conductor ampacity, considering the motor-compressor, any other loads in the equipment, and the NEC requirements for motor starting current.I hope this clarifies the issue! Let me know if you have any other questions. Flag for review