Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: More than one place to derive a ground?

User: jbmdux, Location: Rhode Island

Asked on: Tuesday, September 2, 2025 at 2:58 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 3, 2025 at 1:39 pm EDT

Question: I have a new house with a single phase service. I have an automatic transfer switch for my generator. The 200 amp breaker at the auto transfer switch is used as an emergency disconnect and a service disconnect.There are 2 legs and a neutral from the meter trough that are brought into the auto transfer switch which has an integral 200 amp breaker on the normal supply. The generator connection has 4 conductors, L1 and L2 connected to the transfer switch, a neutral connected to the neutral bus in the ATS and a ground connected to a ground bus in the ATS (this ground is only a chassis ground for the generator). The neutral bus and ground bus are bonded here.There are only 3 conductors from the ATS cabinet to the breaker panel in the house (about 140 feet away), L1, L2 and a neutral. There is no ground conductor.There is no main breaker at the panel. At the panel there is a ground conductor run outside to 2 ground rods and the neutral bus is bonded to the ground bus in the panel via a bonding screw.Questions:What is the better method of connection, what I have or consider the ATS to be service entrance and have the ground derived there (add ground rod(s)) and consider the panel in the house a sub panel?In that arrangement, I know I need a ground conductor (minimum #6) run to the panel with the high sides and the neutral and then separate the neutral and the ground in the panel.If this is better, is it best to abandon the existing ground rods. I don't think I want to be the best ground in the neighborhood.I will be adding a tap off the existing line (10 foot rule) for a shed. While scoping that out I realized there was no ground from the cabinet where the main breaker is to the breaker panel. This got me wondering.

Okay, this is a very common scenario, and it's great you're asking these questions. Your concern about the lack of a ground conductor between the ATS and the house panel is absolutely valid and needs to be addressed. Your current setup is potentially unsafe and almost certainly not code-compliant.Here's a breakdown of the issues and the recommended solution

The Problem with Your Current Setup:
Missing Ground Path

The biggest issue is the lack of a grounding conductor (equipment grounding conductor - EGC) between the ATS and the house panel. The neutral conductor cannot serve as a grounding conductor. This creates a dangerous situation because:


Fault Current Path

If a fault occurs in an appliance or device connected to the house panel, there's no reliable low-impedance path back to the source (the ATS). This means fault current may not be high enough to trip the breakers quickly, potentially leading to electrocution or fire.

Stray Voltage

Without a dedicated ground wire, stray voltage can build up on metallic parts of appliances and equipment, creating a shock hazard.


Improper Grounding at Panel

While you have ground rods connected to the ground bus at the house panel, this isn't a substitute for a properly sized EGC. Ground rods are primarily for dissipating lightning and static electricity, not for carrying fault current.

Bonded Neutral at ATS and Panel

You currently have the neutral bonded to ground in both the ATS and the main panel. This is only allowed at
one location in the system; at the service entrance. Bonding in multiple locations creates parallel neutral paths which can cause dangerous circulating currents on the grounding system.

The Better Solution: Treat the ATS as the Service Entrance


The correct and safest approach is to treat your ATS as the service entrance and make the following changes:1. Grounding Electrode System at the ATS

Install at least two ground rods (or meet the requirements for a single rod, which can be difficult to achieve - see below) at the location of the ATS. These rods must be driven at least 8 feet into the ground and be spaced at least 6 feet apart. Check your local jurisdiction for requirements. Connect these ground rods to the grounding bus in the ATS enclosure with a copper conductor (typically #6 AWG or larger, depending on the service size – consult the NEC Table 250.66). This conductor is called the grounding electrode conductor (GEC). Ensure the cold water metallic pipe is grounded too. Connect the metallic cold water pipe (within 5 feet of where it enters the building) to the grounding bus in the ATS. This is normally done with a #6 copper wire.2.

Run a 4-Wire Feeder to the House Panel

This is the most crucial step. Run a 4-wire feeder (L1, L2, Neutral, and Ground) from the ATS to the house panel.

Size the Ground Wire

The ground wire (EGC) must be sized according to NEC Table 250.122. For a 200 amp service, you would need a minimum of #6 copper. Larger may be required depending on the OCPD and conductor material.

Run All Wires Together

Run all four wires (L1, L2, Neutral, and Ground) together in the same conduit or cable assembly. This is important for minimizing impedance and ensuring effective fault current clearing.3.

Convert the House Panel to a Subpanel



Separate Neutral and Ground

At the house panel, remove the bonding screw or strap that connects the neutral bus to the ground bus. Completely isolate the neutral bus from the panel enclosure and the ground bus.

Connect Ground Wire to Ground Bus

Connect the ground wire (EGC) from the ATS to the ground bus in the house panel. The ground bus should only be connected to the metal enclosure of the panel and to any branch circuit ground wires.

Why This is Correct and Safer



Dedicated Ground Path

Provides a low-impedance path for fault current to return to the source (ATS), ensuring breakers trip quickly and reducing the risk of electrical shock.

Single Point Grounding

Bonding the neutral and ground only at the service entrance (the ATS) eliminates parallel neutral paths and circulating currents on the grounding system.


Code Compliance

This setup meets the requirements of the National Electrical Code (NEC) for grounding and bonding.

Addressing Your Additional Questions



Abandoning Existing Ground Rods at the Panel

You
can abandon the existing ground rods at the house panel. The most important thing is to have a proper grounding electrode system at the service entrance (the ATS). The ground rods at the house panel were ineffective in your current setup because they were not part of a complete grounding system with a dedicated return path. However, it's not necessary to remove them, as long as the neutral is isolated from the ground at the panel. The grounding electrodes are what tie earth potential to your grounding system.

Important Note

The NEC requires a resistance to ground of 25 ohms or less for the grounding electrode system. If you use only one ground rod and it measures more than 25 ohms to ground, you must install a second ground rod. It's always best to install two ground rods to avoid having to measure and test the resistance.

Tap for Shed

When you add the tap for the shed, make sure you run a 4-wire feeder (L1, L2, Neutral, and Ground) to the shed. The shed panel must also be configured as a subpanel, with the neutral and ground separated.

Important Considerations



Bonding Jumpers

Be sure all metallic enclosures (conduit, junction boxes, etc.) are properly bonded together. Use bonding bushings and jumpers as needed to ensure a continuous ground path.

Professional Help

This is a complex electrical project. It's highly recommended to consult with a qualified electrician to ensure the work is done safely and correctly, and in accordance with all applicable codes. Improper grounding can be extremely dangerous.


Local Codes

Local codes may have additional requirements or modifications to the NEC. Always check with your local building department to ensure compliance.

In summary: treat the ATS as the service entrance, install a proper grounding electrode system there, run a 4-wire feeder to the house panel, and convert the house panel to a subpanel by separating the neutral and ground.
This is the safest and most code-compliant solution. Don't take shortcuts when it comes to electrical safety. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question