User: Moosifer, Location: Panama City Beach, FL
Asked on: Tuesday, September 2, 2025 at 4:51 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 3, 2025 at 1:40 pm EDT
Question: Found 3 neutrals for other circuits landed in ansul system subpanel - subpanel main breaker tripping. Going to correct this but wondering if that is tripping the main breaker feeding the subpanel.It is a shunt trip breaker and a ansul system subpanel for everything under the hood.This is a new breaker we just replaced but still have the same issue.I figured this out when I went to land the neutral better so the cover wasn't pressing on it with the subpanel ansul breaker off. Lots of sparks and 15 amps on the neutral. It seems they figured out the hood fans should not be killed by the shunt and ran power to them from the main panel but kept the neutrals and grounds in there. (120v hood fans). The ansul system control power was also wired the same.So, what I am wondering is if this could cause random shunt (subpanel feed breaker) to trip randomly. It has worked for some time (3 years?). The other panel is 1 foot away.Not safe, but can't figure out what is tripping the 100a shunt breaker when it only has 35amps on it under full load. This happens 6 times a day or not at all. Never get the same info as to what might have tripped it. One person actually told me only half of the stuff under the hood was turning off at first which would be very unlikely. Nothing appears to be backfeeding that panel.Any thoughts aside from the obvious bad wiring practice? I did not rewire it because my guys can do that and I keep minimal supplies on my truck.I just can't help but wonder if the additional neutral load is causing some kind of electrical voodoo.
You've got a classic multi-wire branch circuit (MWBC) gone wrong, and it's absolutely plausible, if not highly probable, that the shared neutrals are contributing to your nuisance tripping. Here's a breakdown of why and what else to consider
Why Shared Neutrals Can Cause Problems:
Increased Neutral Current
When you have multiple circuits sharing a neutral, the neutral conductor carries the unbalanced current between those circuits. If the loads on those circuits are not perfectly balanced, the neutral current can exceed the capacity of the conductor, causing overheating and potentially tripping the breaker.
Voltage Imbalance
An overloaded neutral can also lead to voltage imbalances on the individual circuits sharing that neutral. This can damage equipment or cause it to malfunction.
Phantom Tripping (Your Specific Case)
Because you have a shunt trip breaker on this subpanel, it is possible that the other panels are causing a voltage drop. This can affect the signal to the shunt. The increased neutral current is a sign that the circuit breakers are not providing the proper "load". If you have a breaker that is not pushing the proper load, it is not able to trip. That is its sole purpose. This can cause arcing.
Why This Might Be Happening Randomly
Load Fluctuations
The loads on the circuits feeding the shared neutrals are likely fluctuating throughout the day. This will cause random trips.
Why the 100A Breaker Is Tripping Even at 35A Load
Neutral Current Is Additive
Remember, the 35A load reading only reflects the current on the "hot" legs of the circuits within that subpanel. The neutral current could be significantly higher due to the shared neutrals with other circuits. If a 20A neutral is shared on a 15A circuit it will attempt to overload the lower circuit at 35 Amps.
Loose Connections/High Resistance
Loose neutral connections, especially in a heavily loaded circuit, can create high resistance, leading to localized heating and voltage drops. This can trip the breaker even if the overall current draw seems low.
Faulty Breaker (Unlikely, But Possible)
While you replaced the breaker, there's always a chance the new one is also faulty. It is also possible it is not compatible or defective.
Addressing the Issue
Correct the Wiring Immediately
This is the first and most critical step. Your guys need to rewire those circuits so that each circuit has its own dedicated neutral that originates from the panel feeding that circuit. There should be absolutely no shared neutrals between the subpanel and the main panel or any other panel.2.
Verify Neutral and Ground Integrity
Once the wiring is corrected, carefully check all* neutral and ground connections for tightness and proper termination. Use an ohmmeter to verify low resistance between the grounding busbar and the metal enclosure of the subpanel. A high resistance ground can also cause these types of problems.3.
Monitor Loads and Balance Circuits
After correcting the wiring, use an amp meter to monitor the current draw on each circuit in the subpanel. Try to balance the loads across the phases as much as possible to minimize neutral current.4.
Test the Shunt Trip Function
After the wiring is corrected and the loads are balanced, test the shunt trip function of the breaker to ensure it is working correctly.
Addressing the Hood Fans
The fact that the hood fans are intentionally wired to remain on during an ansul system activation is a design flaw and a potential hazard. The purpose of shutting down the electrical equipment under the hood is to prevent further spread of a fire. This should be addressed immediately with the owner/operator of the facility and the fire suppression system installer.
Electrical Voodoo?
You're right, it's not exactly "voodoo," but shared neutrals can create seemingly unpredictable behavior, especially when combined with fluctuating loads and potential loose connections. By systematically addressing the wiring errors and potential connection issues, you'll likely resolve the nuisance tripping. Flag for review